AI summary by TwinMind

Elon Musk & The Longtermists: What Is Their Plan?

Sabine Hossenfelder

16m 28s

Introduction to Long-termism

  • Long-termism: philosophical idea that long-term future of humanity is way more important than present
  • Those alive today should make sacrifices for all generations to come
  • Roots in effective altruism movement (followers try to be smart about donating money for biggest impact)
  • Popular among rich people: Elon Musk, Peter Thiel, Jan Talinn

Scale of Future vs Present Lives

  • Visual representation: hourglass with grains of sand representing 10 million people each
    • Red grains: past lives (~110 billion people)
    • Green grains: current lives (~8 billion people)
    • Conservative estimate: billion people for billion years = billion billion human life years
    • With 100-year lifespan: ~10^16 human lives
    • If populate galaxy/other galaxies: numbers explode into billions and billions

Key Figures and Institutions

Nick Bostrom

  • Philosopher who believes we live in computer simulation
  • 2008: discussed existential risk of programmer pulling plug on simulation
  • 2009 paper: "non-existential disaster causing breakdown of global civilization is potentially recoverable setback"
    • "Giant massacre for men, small misstep for mankind"
  • 2013: calculated reducing existential risk by 1 billionth of 1 billionth of 1% worth 100 billion times more than billion human lives in present
  • Director of Future of Humanity Institute, Oxford

William MacAskill

  • Professor of philosophy, University of Oxford
  • Published book "What We Owe the Future"
  • 2019 paper with Hilary Greaves: "The Case for Strong Long-termism"

Hilary Greaves

  • Philosopher and director of Global Priorities Institute, Oxford
  • Co-authored paper stating decision makers can "often simply ignore all effects contained in first 100 or even 1,000 years"
  • This passage later removed from 2021 version

Supporting Organizations

  • Future of Life Institute (Cambridge, Massachusetts)
  • Supported by billionaires: Peter Thiel, Elon Musk, Jan Talinn
  • Musk commented MacAskill's book is "close match for his philosophy"

Core Long-termist Principles

  • First priority: minimize existential risks
  • Existential risks include: asteroid impact, nuclear world war, other extinction events
  • Don't care about famines/floods (won't lead to extinction)
  • Current conditions of living don't play big role
  • Few million deaths acceptable so long as don't go extinct
  • Can ignore short-term effects (first 100-1000 years) while focusing on far future

Criticisms of Long-termism

Peter Singer (Effective Altruism Founder)

  • Frustrated that followers flocking to long-termism
  • Calls referring to helping global poor/reducing animal suffering as "feel-good project" harsh language
  • Argues long-termism might be excuse to stop donating to Africa
  • Points out tragedy of premature death: cuts short lives of specific living persons
  • Notes entire argument depends on how much value put on future lives

Steven Pinker

  • Complained about certainty on matters we're ignorant about
  • Future is "garden of exponentially forking paths"
  • Criticized "stipulating incorrect answers to unsolvable philosophical conundrums"
  • Noted "blind confidence in tech advances that may never happen"

Media Criticism

  • Time Magazine: Musk sold fantasy that tech + market could change world without government role
  • Washington Post (Christine Emba): long-termism allows tech/finance/philosophy elites to indulge anti-humanistic tendencies
  • Criticism of technocratic vision as anti-democratic
  • "Future becomes clean slate for moral certitude and techno-utopian fantasies"

Philosophical Analysis

Pascal's Mugging Thought Experiment

  • Stranger in alley claims to be mugger, asks for wallet
  • Offers increasingly large returns (double, 100x, million times)
  • Economic logic suggests eventually risk worth it
  • But most people wouldn't give money regardless of promise
  • Point: if agree to any value, anyone can use same strategy to take everything

Core Problem

  • How to assign probability to unlikely future events
  • For Pascal's mugger: unlikely event mugger will deliver promise
  • For long-termism: unlikely existential threats
  • Logical conclusion: spend as much as possible on unlikely events we know least about
  • Makes most currently alive people expendable

Moral vs Logical Arguments

  • Value of human lives requires moral argument, not just logic
  • Nothing irrational about not caring about starving children in Africa
  • Nothing irrational about not caring about people who may/may not live on Mars in billion years
  • Question of personal moral values

Author's Perspective

  • Appreciates long-term strategies (10-20 years to 10,000-10 billion years)
  • Values long-termist focus on preventing existential risks
  • Believes they underestimate how technological progress depends on:
    • Reliability/sustainability of current political systems
    • Economic systems
    • Ecological systems
  • Progress needs ideas, ideas come from brains that need food and knowledge

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome