AI summary by TwinMind
Ep# 14 | WTF is Happening with EV? Nikhil ft. Founders of Reva, Ather, Blusmart, and Ossus
Nikhil Kamath
3h 8m 47s
Punit Goyal's Background and Blue Smart
- Born 1984 in Kolkata, age 39, moved to Bombay in 2000
- Education: Sydenham College (2005), London School of Economics (MSc Finance), Aston Business School (second Masters)
- Third generation entrepreneur from family business background
- First startup: PLG Power (2007-2012) - solar panel manufacturing in Nashik
- Named after grandfather Prem Lal Goyal who passed away April 2007 at age 78
- European market crash led to shutdown after 4 years
- Had 150 crores working capital, raised bank funding and private equity
- Second venture: 20 MW solar power plant in Gujarat
- Sold to Saudi company for $68 million after 2 years operation
- Met co-founder Anmol Jaggi through this project
- Third venture: 70 MW solar power plant in Rajasthan
- Sold to Sterling & Wilson for $55 million
- Met Brent Keenan (ex-CFO Uber) and Shervin Pishevar in Las Vegas
- Inspired to enter EV space after discussions about mobility future
Blue Smart Business Model
- Energy infrastructure and mobility company founded with Anmol Jaggi
- Fleet of 5,000+ Tata Tigor cars
- Revenue: 440-450 crores ARR, 1.3-1.4 crores daily revenue
- Charging revenue: 100 crores ARR
- Three subsidiaries: Blue Smart Mobility (holding), Blue Smart Charge, Blue Smart Fleet, Blue Smart Tech
- Secured financing for 20,000 cars, targeting 40,000 cars
- Adding 400-500 cars per month (capacity for 1,000-2,000)
Blue Smart Operations and Economics
- Lease vehicles from SPVs funded by DFIs (Development Financial Institutions)
- Example: 13 lakh car requires 2 lakh margin, rest financed at sub-10% interest
- Operating cost: 1.20-2 rupees per kilometer vs 4-4.5 rupees for CNG, 8 rupees for petrol/diesel
- Utilization: 200km per day, 6,000km per month, 70,000+ km per year
- Battery replacement needed after 200,000-250,000 km (4 years)
- Vehicle body lasts 8-10 years, allowing second battery cycle
Solar Power Investment Opportunities
- Current cost: 3-3.25 crores per MW (down from 18 crores in 2012)
- Land requirement: 4 acres per MW
- Post-tax returns: 18-19% annually
- Power purchase agreements: 25-year contracts with state discoms
- Example pricing: Gujarat - 15 rupees/unit first 12 years, 5 rupees/unit remaining 13 years
- Current bidding rates: around 2.75 rupees/unit for large-scale projects
Suchi Srinivasan - Ojas Innovations (Green Hydrogen)
- PhD in Bioprocess Technology from Institute of Chemical Technology (ex-UDCT)
- Developed microorganisms to convert agricultural waste to ethanol
- Founded Ojas after Shell E4 program funding
- Uses microorganisms to produce electricity from wastewater
- Technology produces green hydrogen while cleaning wastewater simultaneously
Green Hydrogen Production and Economics
- Process: Microorganisms on electrodes produce electrons from wastewater
- Two electrodes + two protons combine to make hydrogen gas
- Water is cleaned and recycled for reuse
- Current capacity: 250 kg/day using 18,000 liters wastewater
- Cost: 88 rupees per kg hydrogen (target under $1/kg for "1 1 1" program)
- With compression: 112 rupees per kg
- Market price from multinationals: 400 rupees per kg
- Raw material cost in 4kW battery pack: $240, recycling cost: $10-20
Hydrogen vs Electric Vehicles Debate
- Hydrogen fuel cells: 3x less efficient than direct electric due to conversion losses
- Better suited for long-distance trucking, aviation, industrial applications
- Electric vehicles: 30-35% better than ICE even with current grid mix
- Power plants 35% efficient vs ICE engines 20-25% efficient
- Local emissions advantage for EVs in cities
- Grid getting cleaner over time improves EV advantage
Tarun Mehta - Ather Energy Background
- Born in Madras, graduated IIT Madras 2012
- Started Ather Energy 2013 with co-founders
- Always wanted to build energy company, not just vehicle company
- Vision: Complete energy cycle - generation, distribution, storage, application
- Started with swappable battery design, later moved to fixed batteries
Athan vs Swapping Debate
- Ather's experience: Indian consumers unwilling to manually swap 8-10kg batteries
- Consumer concerns: Don't want to exchange new battery for degraded one
- Range anxiety vs convenience trade-offs
- Ather focused on fixed batteries with comprehensive charging network
- Built largest fast-charging network for two-wheelers in India
Sun Mobility - Chetan Maini's Battery Swapping
- Founded by Chetan Maini (previously Reva Electric) and partner
- Universal battery solution: 1 battery for scooters, 2 for rickshaws, 4 for small trucks
- 600 touchpoints in Delhi, 400+ stations
- Every 2 km coverage planned
- Battery as a Service model with 15+ OEM partners
- Mobility as a Service for fleet operators
- 15,000 vehicles currently on platform
- Economics: 18-22% returns for franchise partners with 1 lakh investment
Battery Technology Deep Dive
- Cell components: Anode, cathode, separator, electrolyte
- Lithium provides high voltage differential (3.2-3.6V vs 1.5V zinc, 2V lead acid)
- Battery pack assembly: 200 cells, 800 welds in typical scooter
- Six Sigma quality needed (3 failures per million)
- Thermal management critical for battery life
- Ather uses passive cooling with phase-change materials
- Fast charging restrictions due to heat generation
Manufacturing and Costs
- Battery: 35% of vehicle cost
- Motor + controller: 10%
- Chassis: 15%
- Dashboard: 10%
- Charger and peripherals: 10%
- Aesthetics (lights, plastics): 10%
- Vehicle weight: 104kg total, 20kg battery
- Selling price: 1.25-1.65 lakhs
- R&D team: 1000+ members (world's largest for electric two-wheelers)
Policy Challenges and Opportunities
- PLI scheme favors established players over startups
- GST structure: 5% on vehicles, 18% on batteries creates inverted duty
- Fame 2 subsidy reduced from 60,000 to 20,000 rupees per vehicle
- Entry barrier for new companies: 100 million minimum investment
- Need for technology-agnostic policies
Future Opportunities for Entrepreneurs
- Battery recycling: High-margin business with guaranteed demand
- Material recovery: $240 raw materials recoverable for $10-20 recycling cost
- Franchise opportunities in charging/swapping networks
- New form factor vehicles enabled by electric technology
- Subscription/leasing models for vehicle ownership
- Data analytics and AI solutions for energy-mobility intersection
Industry Outlook and Market Dynamics
- EV adoption accelerating across all segments
- Two-wheeler penetration: 30% Ola, 20% TVS, 15% Ather, 12% Bajaj
- Distribution not a long-term moat in India
- Technology differentiation becoming key
- Carbon tax implementation expected
- Recycling will become major industry as vehicles age
- Integration of renewable energy with charging infrastructure
Investment Commitments for Young Entrepreneurs
- Punit Goyal: 5 lakhs
- Chetan Maini: 25 lakhs + mentorship
- Suchi Srinivasan: 1-2 lakhs (10-25 depending on opportunity)
- Tarun Mehta: 25 lakhs
- Total pool: ~55-60 lakhs for promising hardware startups
