AI summary by TwinMind

Ep# 14 | WTF is Happening with EV? Nikhil ft. Founders of Reva, Ather, Blusmart, and Ossus

Nikhil Kamath

3h 8m 47s

Punit Goyal's Background and Blue Smart

  • Born 1984 in Kolkata, age 39, moved to Bombay in 2000
  • Education: Sydenham College (2005), London School of Economics (MSc Finance), Aston Business School (second Masters)
  • Third generation entrepreneur from family business background
  • First startup: PLG Power (2007-2012) - solar panel manufacturing in Nashik
    • Named after grandfather Prem Lal Goyal who passed away April 2007 at age 78
    • European market crash led to shutdown after 4 years
    • Had 150 crores working capital, raised bank funding and private equity
  • Second venture: 20 MW solar power plant in Gujarat
    • Sold to Saudi company for $68 million after 2 years operation
    • Met co-founder Anmol Jaggi through this project
  • Third venture: 70 MW solar power plant in Rajasthan
    • Sold to Sterling & Wilson for $55 million
  • Met Brent Keenan (ex-CFO Uber) and Shervin Pishevar in Las Vegas
    • Inspired to enter EV space after discussions about mobility future

Blue Smart Business Model

  • Energy infrastructure and mobility company founded with Anmol Jaggi
  • Fleet of 5,000+ Tata Tigor cars
  • Revenue: 440-450 crores ARR, 1.3-1.4 crores daily revenue
  • Charging revenue: 100 crores ARR
  • Three subsidiaries: Blue Smart Mobility (holding), Blue Smart Charge, Blue Smart Fleet, Blue Smart Tech
  • Secured financing for 20,000 cars, targeting 40,000 cars
  • Adding 400-500 cars per month (capacity for 1,000-2,000)

Blue Smart Operations and Economics

  • Lease vehicles from SPVs funded by DFIs (Development Financial Institutions)
  • Example: 13 lakh car requires 2 lakh margin, rest financed at sub-10% interest
  • Operating cost: 1.20-2 rupees per kilometer vs 4-4.5 rupees for CNG, 8 rupees for petrol/diesel
  • Utilization: 200km per day, 6,000km per month, 70,000+ km per year
  • Battery replacement needed after 200,000-250,000 km (4 years)
  • Vehicle body lasts 8-10 years, allowing second battery cycle

Solar Power Investment Opportunities

  • Current cost: 3-3.25 crores per MW (down from 18 crores in 2012)
  • Land requirement: 4 acres per MW
  • Post-tax returns: 18-19% annually
  • Power purchase agreements: 25-year contracts with state discoms
  • Example pricing: Gujarat - 15 rupees/unit first 12 years, 5 rupees/unit remaining 13 years
  • Current bidding rates: around 2.75 rupees/unit for large-scale projects

Suchi Srinivasan - Ojas Innovations (Green Hydrogen)

  • PhD in Bioprocess Technology from Institute of Chemical Technology (ex-UDCT)
  • Developed microorganisms to convert agricultural waste to ethanol
  • Founded Ojas after Shell E4 program funding
  • Uses microorganisms to produce electricity from wastewater
  • Technology produces green hydrogen while cleaning wastewater simultaneously

Green Hydrogen Production and Economics

  • Process: Microorganisms on electrodes produce electrons from wastewater
  • Two electrodes + two protons combine to make hydrogen gas
  • Water is cleaned and recycled for reuse
  • Current capacity: 250 kg/day using 18,000 liters wastewater
  • Cost: 88 rupees per kg hydrogen (target under $1/kg for "1 1 1" program)
  • With compression: 112 rupees per kg
  • Market price from multinationals: 400 rupees per kg
  • Raw material cost in 4kW battery pack: $240, recycling cost: $10-20

Hydrogen vs Electric Vehicles Debate

  • Hydrogen fuel cells: 3x less efficient than direct electric due to conversion losses
  • Better suited for long-distance trucking, aviation, industrial applications
  • Electric vehicles: 30-35% better than ICE even with current grid mix
  • Power plants 35% efficient vs ICE engines 20-25% efficient
  • Local emissions advantage for EVs in cities
  • Grid getting cleaner over time improves EV advantage

Tarun Mehta - Ather Energy Background

  • Born in Madras, graduated IIT Madras 2012
  • Started Ather Energy 2013 with co-founders
  • Always wanted to build energy company, not just vehicle company
  • Vision: Complete energy cycle - generation, distribution, storage, application
  • Started with swappable battery design, later moved to fixed batteries

Athan vs Swapping Debate

  • Ather's experience: Indian consumers unwilling to manually swap 8-10kg batteries
  • Consumer concerns: Don't want to exchange new battery for degraded one
  • Range anxiety vs convenience trade-offs
  • Ather focused on fixed batteries with comprehensive charging network
  • Built largest fast-charging network for two-wheelers in India

Sun Mobility - Chetan Maini's Battery Swapping

  • Founded by Chetan Maini (previously Reva Electric) and partner
  • Universal battery solution: 1 battery for scooters, 2 for rickshaws, 4 for small trucks
  • 600 touchpoints in Delhi, 400+ stations
  • Every 2 km coverage planned
  • Battery as a Service model with 15+ OEM partners
  • Mobility as a Service for fleet operators
  • 15,000 vehicles currently on platform
  • Economics: 18-22% returns for franchise partners with 1 lakh investment

Battery Technology Deep Dive

  • Cell components: Anode, cathode, separator, electrolyte
  • Lithium provides high voltage differential (3.2-3.6V vs 1.5V zinc, 2V lead acid)
  • Battery pack assembly: 200 cells, 800 welds in typical scooter
  • Six Sigma quality needed (3 failures per million)
  • Thermal management critical for battery life
  • Ather uses passive cooling with phase-change materials
  • Fast charging restrictions due to heat generation

Manufacturing and Costs

  • Battery: 35% of vehicle cost
  • Motor + controller: 10%
  • Chassis: 15%
  • Dashboard: 10%
  • Charger and peripherals: 10%
  • Aesthetics (lights, plastics): 10%
  • Vehicle weight: 104kg total, 20kg battery
  • Selling price: 1.25-1.65 lakhs
  • R&D team: 1000+ members (world's largest for electric two-wheelers)

Policy Challenges and Opportunities

  • PLI scheme favors established players over startups
  • GST structure: 5% on vehicles, 18% on batteries creates inverted duty
  • Fame 2 subsidy reduced from 60,000 to 20,000 rupees per vehicle
  • Entry barrier for new companies: 100 million minimum investment
  • Need for technology-agnostic policies

Future Opportunities for Entrepreneurs

  • Battery recycling: High-margin business with guaranteed demand
  • Material recovery: $240 raw materials recoverable for $10-20 recycling cost
  • Franchise opportunities in charging/swapping networks
  • New form factor vehicles enabled by electric technology
  • Subscription/leasing models for vehicle ownership
  • Data analytics and AI solutions for energy-mobility intersection

Industry Outlook and Market Dynamics

  • EV adoption accelerating across all segments
  • Two-wheeler penetration: 30% Ola, 20% TVS, 15% Ather, 12% Bajaj
  • Distribution not a long-term moat in India
  • Technology differentiation becoming key
  • Carbon tax implementation expected
  • Recycling will become major industry as vehicles age
  • Integration of renewable energy with charging infrastructure

Investment Commitments for Young Entrepreneurs

  • Punit Goyal: 5 lakhs
  • Chetan Maini: 25 lakhs + mentorship
  • Suchi Srinivasan: 1-2 lakhs (10-25 depending on opportunity)
  • Tarun Mehta: 25 lakhs
  • Total pool: ~55-60 lakhs for promising hardware startups

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome