AI summary by TwinMind

Ep #22 | WTF are Craft Beverages? Nikhil ft. the Founders of Blue Tokai, Subko, Svami, and Mossant

Nikhil Kamath

3h 25m 44s

Introduction & Background

  • Panel discussion with craft beverage entrepreneurs in India
  • Participants: Matt (Blue Tokai Coffee), Aditya (Mossant Kombucha), Rahul (Subko Coffee), Anish (Swami Tonic Water), Nikhil (investor/host)
  • Focus on coffee shop, kombucha, and tonic water business opportunities for new entrepreneurs

Matt's Journey - Blue Tokai Coffee

  • Background: Half-Indian (Chennai father), half-Polish/German American mother
  • Born/raised in Wisconsin, studied Finance in New York, moved to San Francisco
  • Career progression: hedge fund trader (real estate) → international development → Chennai (IFMR) → coffee
  • Started Blue Tokai in 2012 at age 29 with wife from bedroom in Delhi
  • Initial challenge: Indian growers believed consumers wouldn't pay for quality coffee
  • Started with 500g tabletop roaster, wife did grinding/packaging
  • Current scale: 400 CR run rate, 135 outlets
  • Geographic distribution: Delhi 40%, Mumbai 35%, Bangalore 12%, Pune 9%, Kolkata 9%
  • International expansion: One cafe in Japan (started as B2B/e-commerce, opened cafe 3 months ago)
  • Revenue split: 45% beverages, 40% food, 15% retail packets/bread

Aditya's Journey - Mossant Kombucha

  • Born/raised in Bangalore, engineering background (6 years to complete)
  • Mother ran Country Club kitchens, early exposure to food business
  • Australia culinary school after engineering
  • Owned cafe (Casablanca area) 2010-2012, sold when partner died in accident
  • Partner Shush started making kombucha for health issues (skin allergy, gut problems)
  • Started Mossant October 11, 2019, named after deceased friend's favorite art deco poster
  • Focus: tea-forward kombucha showcasing Indian teas (Assam, Darjeeling, Nilgiris)
  • Challenge: alcohol regulation (must stay below 0.5% to avoid excise)
  • Business model: started with 6 lakhs (3 lakhs each partner)
  • Current pricing: 130 rupees vs market at 200 rupees
  • Tested 99 rupees pricing: 6X business increase in 3 months
  • Revenue channels: 60% quick commerce, rest retail/restaurants
  • Gross margins: 70-77%
  • Market size: kombucha market ~200 crores in India, projected 1 billion by 2032
  • Target: building "better soda" category vs pure health positioning

Rahul's Journey - Subko Coffee

  • Background: Born in US (Fremont, CA), father from Hyderabad (semiconductor entrepreneur)
  • Childhood experience: struggled with Indian identity in US, moved to Bangalore 1997-2000
  • Education: International relations, marketing, French minor, lived in Paris
  • Career: decade between New York/London, studied international development
  • Coffee interest: developed specialty coffee obsession, analyzed tasting notes
  • Motivation: prove India could build world-class coffee brand with global relevance
  • Differentiation from Blue Tokai:
    • More expensive/niche premium positioning
    • Focus on design language and baked goods integration
    • "Speak Easy" menu: coffee-based cocktails using tonic water
    • Micro-lot packaging design variations
  • Revenue split: 50/50 coffee and food
  • Philosophy: building "global indic design language"

Anish's Journey - Swami Tonic Water

  • Background: Army kid, father ASC logistics core (retired Brigadier)
  • Moved across India, photography hobby started in 10th standard
  • Education: 12th CBSE, skipped college, worked at photo labs
  • Career path: photography → wine/alcohol industry exposure → beverage app development
  • Photography led to wine education, built wine app (almost acquired by Diageo)
  • Swami founding: gin drinkers frustrated with tonic quality, started with Rahul and brother-in-law
  • Market gap: only Schweppes available, poor taste with gin
  • Product differentiation: better taste, less bitter than Schweppes
  • Business scale: 30-35 CR projected next year
  • Distribution strategy: restaurant/bar first, then retail
  • Positioning: premium pricing vs Schweppes, never cheaper internationally

Coffee Shop Business Analysis

Market Size & Opportunity

  • Only 5,000 branded coffee shops in India (vs much larger populations elsewhere)
  • Coffee culture maturing, moving from functional to experiential consumption
  • Starbucks challenges: high real estate costs, customers sit longer vs US grab-and-go model
  • Indian vs international brand preference shifting toward homegrown

Starting a Coffee Shop - Key Insights

  • Capital requirement: 80 lakhs to 1.5 CR for 2,000 sq ft prime location
  • Optimal size: ~1,000 sq ft (2,000+ sq ft increases capex without proportional revenue)
  • Location strategy: mixed office/residential areas, higher density, posher areas
  • Staffing: 21-28k monthly salary for baristas, 8-hour shifts, 5 days/week
  • Equipment: European brands (Lamarzocco, Slayer), avoid Chinese/Indian machines
  • Revenue split: 45-50% beverages, 40-50% food, 10-15% retail
  • Delivery: 35% of revenue despite quality compromise
  • Food importance: wider menu increases sales, but kitchen complexity challenging

Differentiation Strategies

  • Multi-roaster concept: offer various coffee brands vs single brand
  • Subculture focus: vinyl records, investment advice, cigar lounge concepts
  • Premium positioning: 250 rupees price tolerance threshold
  • Consistency crucial for repeat customers
  • Coffee shop as cultural space replacing bars for younger demographics

Kombucha Business Deep Dive

Product & Market

  • Definition: fermented sweetened tea using SCOBY (symbiotic colony bacteria/yeast)
  • Health positioning: better than Coke, not necessarily better than water
  • Market size: 200 crores currently, projected 1 billion by 2032
  • Mossant market share: 32% on quick commerce platforms
  • Pricing strategy: accessibility vs premiumization balance

Manufacturing & Regulations

  • Alcohol content: must stay below 0.5% to avoid excise classification
  • Taxation: 40% GST on sweet carbonated beverages (major constraint)
  • Raw materials: high-quality tea primary cost driver
  • Started with 6 lakhs capital, gross margins 70-77%
  • Distribution: 60% quick commerce, 40% offline

Market Dynamics

  • US vs India taste preferences: US prefers sour, India requires sweeter profiles
  • Education challenge: consumers don't understand category
  • Competition: fragmented market with many small players
  • Future potential: hard kombucha (alcoholic version) when market matures

Tonic Water & Mixer Business

Swami's Positioning

  • Founded to address gin & tonic quality issues
  • Historical context: Indian tonic water origins (British malaria prevention)
  • Product range: tonics, ginger ale, lemonade, soda water
  • Gross margins: ~60% with own production
  • Scale: 30-35 CR projected revenue

Market Strategy

  • Restaurant/bar distribution first, then retail expansion
  • Premium positioning: never cheaper than international brands
  • Taste differentiation: less bitter than Schweppes, better water profile
  • Geographic focus: strong in South, challenges in North (sugar preferences)

Industry Challenges & Opportunities

Taxation Issues

  • 40% GST on sweet carbonated beverages major barrier
  • Comparison: UK has graduated sugar tax system
  • Impact: forces brands to work backwards from MRP, limits innovation
  • Calls for reform: calorie-based or graduated taxation system

Supply Chain & Manufacturing

  • Bottling/canning mafia: consolidation limiting access for new entrants
  • Bottle costs: ~8-9 rupees per bottle
  • Minimum order quantities challenging for startups
  • Chinese equipment: avoid due to service issues
  • Local suppliers recommended for initial scale

Distribution Strategies

  • Quick commerce: 30-50% commission rates, good for established brands
  • Offline crucial: restaurants, bars, retail for brand building
  • Performance marketing: generally ineffective for beverages
  • Content strategy: founder-led authentic storytelling preferred
  • Celebrity endorsements: mixed effectiveness

Investment & Growth Outlook

Market Trends

  • Younger demographics choosing coffee shops over nightclubs
  • Health consciousness driving "better for you" beverage demand
  • Nationalism supporting homegrown brands over international
  • Potential trade fragmentation favoring domestic brands

Financial Metrics

  • Coffee shops: 80 lakhs-1.5 CR initial investment
  • Kombucha: 6 lakhs startup possible
  • Marketing spend: 1-5% of revenue typical
  • Gross margins: 60-77% achievable in craft beverages

Future Opportunities

  • Functional beverages: protein, collagen, beauty applications
  • Indian flavor profiles: ethnic kombucha, regional specialties
  • Export potential: Indian coffee/beverage brands internationally
  • Consolidation: acquisition opportunities as market matures
  • Alternative alcohol: hard kombucha, coffee cocktails

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome