AI summary by TwinMind
Ep #22 | WTF are Craft Beverages? Nikhil ft. the Founders of Blue Tokai, Subko, Svami, and Mossant
Nikhil Kamath
3h 25m 44s
Introduction & Background
- Panel discussion with craft beverage entrepreneurs in India
- Participants: Matt (Blue Tokai Coffee), Aditya (Mossant Kombucha), Rahul (Subko Coffee), Anish (Swami Tonic Water), Nikhil (investor/host)
- Focus on coffee shop, kombucha, and tonic water business opportunities for new entrepreneurs
Matt's Journey - Blue Tokai Coffee
- Background: Half-Indian (Chennai father), half-Polish/German American mother
- Born/raised in Wisconsin, studied Finance in New York, moved to San Francisco
- Career progression: hedge fund trader (real estate) → international development → Chennai (IFMR) → coffee
- Started Blue Tokai in 2012 at age 29 with wife from bedroom in Delhi
- Initial challenge: Indian growers believed consumers wouldn't pay for quality coffee
- Started with 500g tabletop roaster, wife did grinding/packaging
- Current scale: 400 CR run rate, 135 outlets
- Geographic distribution: Delhi 40%, Mumbai 35%, Bangalore 12%, Pune 9%, Kolkata 9%
- International expansion: One cafe in Japan (started as B2B/e-commerce, opened cafe 3 months ago)
- Revenue split: 45% beverages, 40% food, 15% retail packets/bread
Aditya's Journey - Mossant Kombucha
- Born/raised in Bangalore, engineering background (6 years to complete)
- Mother ran Country Club kitchens, early exposure to food business
- Australia culinary school after engineering
- Owned cafe (Casablanca area) 2010-2012, sold when partner died in accident
- Partner Shush started making kombucha for health issues (skin allergy, gut problems)
- Started Mossant October 11, 2019, named after deceased friend's favorite art deco poster
- Focus: tea-forward kombucha showcasing Indian teas (Assam, Darjeeling, Nilgiris)
- Challenge: alcohol regulation (must stay below 0.5% to avoid excise)
- Business model: started with 6 lakhs (3 lakhs each partner)
- Current pricing: 130 rupees vs market at 200 rupees
- Tested 99 rupees pricing: 6X business increase in 3 months
- Revenue channels: 60% quick commerce, rest retail/restaurants
- Gross margins: 70-77%
- Market size: kombucha market ~200 crores in India, projected 1 billion by 2032
- Target: building "better soda" category vs pure health positioning
Rahul's Journey - Subko Coffee
- Background: Born in US (Fremont, CA), father from Hyderabad (semiconductor entrepreneur)
- Childhood experience: struggled with Indian identity in US, moved to Bangalore 1997-2000
- Education: International relations, marketing, French minor, lived in Paris
- Career: decade between New York/London, studied international development
- Coffee interest: developed specialty coffee obsession, analyzed tasting notes
- Motivation: prove India could build world-class coffee brand with global relevance
- Differentiation from Blue Tokai:
- More expensive/niche premium positioning
- Focus on design language and baked goods integration
- "Speak Easy" menu: coffee-based cocktails using tonic water
- Micro-lot packaging design variations
- Revenue split: 50/50 coffee and food
- Philosophy: building "global indic design language"
Anish's Journey - Swami Tonic Water
- Background: Army kid, father ASC logistics core (retired Brigadier)
- Moved across India, photography hobby started in 10th standard
- Education: 12th CBSE, skipped college, worked at photo labs
- Career path: photography → wine/alcohol industry exposure → beverage app development
- Photography led to wine education, built wine app (almost acquired by Diageo)
- Swami founding: gin drinkers frustrated with tonic quality, started with Rahul and brother-in-law
- Market gap: only Schweppes available, poor taste with gin
- Product differentiation: better taste, less bitter than Schweppes
- Business scale: 30-35 CR projected next year
- Distribution strategy: restaurant/bar first, then retail
- Positioning: premium pricing vs Schweppes, never cheaper internationally
Coffee Shop Business Analysis
Market Size & Opportunity
- Only 5,000 branded coffee shops in India (vs much larger populations elsewhere)
- Coffee culture maturing, moving from functional to experiential consumption
- Starbucks challenges: high real estate costs, customers sit longer vs US grab-and-go model
- Indian vs international brand preference shifting toward homegrown
Starting a Coffee Shop - Key Insights
- Capital requirement: 80 lakhs to 1.5 CR for 2,000 sq ft prime location
- Optimal size: ~1,000 sq ft (2,000+ sq ft increases capex without proportional revenue)
- Location strategy: mixed office/residential areas, higher density, posher areas
- Staffing: 21-28k monthly salary for baristas, 8-hour shifts, 5 days/week
- Equipment: European brands (Lamarzocco, Slayer), avoid Chinese/Indian machines
- Revenue split: 45-50% beverages, 40-50% food, 10-15% retail
- Delivery: 35% of revenue despite quality compromise
- Food importance: wider menu increases sales, but kitchen complexity challenging
Differentiation Strategies
- Multi-roaster concept: offer various coffee brands vs single brand
- Subculture focus: vinyl records, investment advice, cigar lounge concepts
- Premium positioning: 250 rupees price tolerance threshold
- Consistency crucial for repeat customers
- Coffee shop as cultural space replacing bars for younger demographics
Kombucha Business Deep Dive
Product & Market
- Definition: fermented sweetened tea using SCOBY (symbiotic colony bacteria/yeast)
- Health positioning: better than Coke, not necessarily better than water
- Market size: 200 crores currently, projected 1 billion by 2032
- Mossant market share: 32% on quick commerce platforms
- Pricing strategy: accessibility vs premiumization balance
Manufacturing & Regulations
- Alcohol content: must stay below 0.5% to avoid excise classification
- Taxation: 40% GST on sweet carbonated beverages (major constraint)
- Raw materials: high-quality tea primary cost driver
- Started with 6 lakhs capital, gross margins 70-77%
- Distribution: 60% quick commerce, 40% offline
Market Dynamics
- US vs India taste preferences: US prefers sour, India requires sweeter profiles
- Education challenge: consumers don't understand category
- Competition: fragmented market with many small players
- Future potential: hard kombucha (alcoholic version) when market matures
Tonic Water & Mixer Business
Swami's Positioning
- Founded to address gin & tonic quality issues
- Historical context: Indian tonic water origins (British malaria prevention)
- Product range: tonics, ginger ale, lemonade, soda water
- Gross margins: ~60% with own production
- Scale: 30-35 CR projected revenue
Market Strategy
- Restaurant/bar distribution first, then retail expansion
- Premium positioning: never cheaper than international brands
- Taste differentiation: less bitter than Schweppes, better water profile
- Geographic focus: strong in South, challenges in North (sugar preferences)
Industry Challenges & Opportunities
Taxation Issues
- 40% GST on sweet carbonated beverages major barrier
- Comparison: UK has graduated sugar tax system
- Impact: forces brands to work backwards from MRP, limits innovation
- Calls for reform: calorie-based or graduated taxation system
Supply Chain & Manufacturing
- Bottling/canning mafia: consolidation limiting access for new entrants
- Bottle costs: ~8-9 rupees per bottle
- Minimum order quantities challenging for startups
- Chinese equipment: avoid due to service issues
- Local suppliers recommended for initial scale
Distribution Strategies
- Quick commerce: 30-50% commission rates, good for established brands
- Offline crucial: restaurants, bars, retail for brand building
- Performance marketing: generally ineffective for beverages
- Content strategy: founder-led authentic storytelling preferred
- Celebrity endorsements: mixed effectiveness
Investment & Growth Outlook
Market Trends
- Younger demographics choosing coffee shops over nightclubs
- Health consciousness driving "better for you" beverage demand
- Nationalism supporting homegrown brands over international
- Potential trade fragmentation favoring domestic brands
Financial Metrics
- Coffee shops: 80 lakhs-1.5 CR initial investment
- Kombucha: 6 lakhs startup possible
- Marketing spend: 1-5% of revenue typical
- Gross margins: 60-77% achievable in craft beverages
Future Opportunities
- Functional beverages: protein, collagen, beauty applications
- Indian flavor profiles: ethnic kombucha, regional specialties
- Export potential: Indian coffee/beverage brands internationally
- Consolidation: acquisition opportunities as market matures
- Alternative alcohol: hard kombucha, coffee cocktails
