AI summary by TwinMind

Etch: Lithography's Unheralded Sibling

Asianometry

18m 22s

Introduction to Semiconductor Etching

  • Lithography transfers chip design onto photoresist-coated wafer
  • Etching engraves design into wafer's layers using liquid or plasma gas etchant
  • Removes unwanted parts of chip design to bring it to life

Early Wet Etching Era

  • Beginning only had wet etching technology
  • Process: dunk wafer into heated $10,000 quartz bath full of acid chemicals
    • Acid type depends on material being etched (bare silicon, silicon dioxide, aluminum interconnects)
    • Shake wafer like Polaroid picture to bring fresh etchant to surface
    • Shaking loosens gas bubbles that prevent etching and slow etch rate
  • After completion: wash off acid, dry wafer using spin dryer
  • Goal: high and consistent etch rates across every wafer and run
  • Evolution: switched from immersion etching to spray etching for more continual fresh etchant supply

Wet Etching Advantages and Limitations

  • Advantages:
    • Chemical reaction is selective - can etch one material without affecting other layers
  • Disadvantages:
    • Difficult to consistently control chemical reaction
    • Hard to automate, effectiveness depends on operator skill
    • Environmental concerns: particle contamination and toxic waste
    • Critical limitation: isotropic etch profile (etches equally in all directions)
      • Cannot guide etching in proper direction
      • Undercutting occurs when resist lines are thin enough
      • Hurts imaging resolution

Transition to Dry Etching

  • Undercutting became serious issue at 5 micrometer process node for 16K DRAM
  • Industry decided wet etch alone cannot achieve resolution for next node (3 micrometer/64K DRAM)
  • 1967: Steve Irving at Signetics demonstrated gas plasma to strip photoresist from silicon surface
    • Process called "ashing" - reduces things to ash
    • Concept borrowed from using gas plasma to ash organic parts of animal tissue for testing
    • Purchased plasma equipment from Tracer Lab (LFE Corporation subsidiary)
    • Successfully removed photoresist without destroying crystal structure

Plasma Technology Fundamentals

  • Plasma is fourth state of matter
  • Semiconductor plasmas are ionized (gas atoms become charged by losing/gaining electrons)
  • Created by exposing gas to powerful RF field (usually 13.56 MHz) rather than high temperatures
  • Low temperature plasmas: 50-250°C, materials react at lower temperatures/energies than gas/liquid states
  • Example: CF4 (carbon tetrafluoride) etching silicon
    • Normal gaseous CF4 cannot etch strong silicon-silicon bonds
    • Plasma state breaks carbon-fluoride bonds into fluorine, CF3, CF2
    • Ion bombardment weakens silicon bonds
    • Result: silicon tetrafluoride gas + carbon layer
    • Oxygen pumped in reacts with carbon to create CO2

Early Plasma Equipment Development

  • 1971: Steve Irving received patent for gas plasma vapor etching
  • Left Signetics for International Plasma Corporation, developed first plasma etch for silicon nitride (LED screens)
  • First equipment were crossovers from other industries
  • 1972: First specialized plasma etching equipment - Barrel type reactors
    • Barrel-shaped plasma chamber with external RF coils (prevent contamination)
    • Wafers loaded like dishes in dishwasher
  • 1975: Market only $1.6 million - customers thought plasma etching was for healthcare, not semiconductors

Barrel Etcher Limitations

  • Performed well only for photoresist stripping (still used today)
  • Poor performance for actual etching:
    • No good temperature control
    • Non-uniform etching across wafer
    • Radiation damage to wafers
    • Still isotropic - disqualified as credible wet etch replacement

Parallel Plate Reactor Innovation

  • 1973: Alan Reinberg at Texas Instruments developed parallel plate reactor (also called radial flow reactor)
  • Inspired by chemical vapor deposition work
  • Design: wafers on platter with RF electrode underneath, hole at center for gas flow
  • Second set of electrodes above wafers
  • RF electrode accelerates plasma ions downward, physically bombarding wafers
  • Triggers chemical reaction between etchant plasma and substrate
  • Key benefit: anisotropic etch - chemical reaction selectiveness while guiding etch in single direction
  • Evolved into reactive ion etch (RIE) system

Market Breakthrough

  • 1975: IBM team led by Dr. Hua Nanu produced 8 kilobit memory with 1-1.5 micrometer line dimensions
  • Used cutting-edge technologies:
    • Electron beam lithography for pattern transfer
    • Reactive ion etch and ion implantation for chip features and electrical properties
  • Demonstration showed future potential, manufacturers quickly transitioned from wet to dry etch

Dry Etching Challenges

  • Plasma damage: Silicon substrate damage and residual metal impurities
    • Solution: post-etch cleaning step
    • Methods: oxygen/hydrogen plasma blast + wet acid + hot bake, or lasers
  • Equipment speed: Too slow compared to barrel batch processing
    • Early RIE machines processed one wafer at a time very slowly
    • Tools cost over $1 million each
    • Poor throughput made economic justification difficult

Plasma Density Enhancement Efforts (Early 1980s)

  • Magnetically Enhanced RIE (MARIE):
    • Added magnetic field to intensify plasma and enhance etch
    • Problem: magnetic fields parallel to wafer created non-uniform plasma
    • Rotating magnet damaged wafer - became dead end
  • Electron Cyclotron Resonance (ECR):
    • 1950s: Oak Ridge National Lab invented for fusion research
    • Uses microwaves and magnetics to produce high density plasma in separate chamber
    • 1982: NTT filed patent, licensed to Hitachi
    • Hitachi rebranded as "microwave plasma etching" for 4 megabit DRAM at 800nm node
    • Late 1980s-early 1990s: Sematech funded Oak Ridge commercialization efforts
    • Problems: too complicated, huge magnetic coil, non-uniform etch rates

Inductively Coupled Plasma (ICP)

  • Late 1980s modification of ECR
  • Magnetic coil at top of chamber produces high density plasma using electromagnetic induction
  • Became industry's dominant way to do RIE with high density plasma
  • Applied Materials, Lam Research, other vendors continue advancing plasma density without wafer damage

Deep Reactive Ion Etching (DRIE)

  • Descended from RIE, developed in MEMS world
  • MEMS artists needed complex geometries in silicon (deep holes for tether beams)
  • Existing methods produced v-shaped holes
  • 1990s: German company Bosch developed DRIE (Bosch process)
  • Process: Cycles through two steps (few seconds each)
    1. Fire high density plasma mix of etchant and ions (creates round crater)
    2. Apply inhibitor (Teflon-like) coating to crater, nullifies acid
    3. Fire etchant+ion plasma again - ions break through inhibitor at bottom only
    4. Side walls protected by untouched inhibitor
  • Result: Deep hole with characteristic scallop sidewall
  • Applications:
    • Through Silicon Vias (TSVs) for die-stacked chips like Nvidia AI accelerators
    • Thin, deep trenches for leading-edge DRAM chips

Future Challenges and Atomic Layer Etching

  • Moore's Law progression requires smaller, more precise, and fast etching
  • Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) builds layers atom by atom
  • Atomic Layer Etching (ALE) tears down thin layers atom by atom
  • ALD widely used on fab floors, ALE still working through quirks
  • Sign that etch (lithography's unheralded sibling) has vibrant future ahead

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome