AI summary by TwinMind
Ethical Investing is BAD Investing... Here's Why - How Money Works
How Money Works
10m 26s
Introduction to Ethical Investing
- Ethical investing extremely popular in recent years
- Promise: invest in companies that don't harm environment, exploit workers, or engage in bad business practices
- Theory: denying bad companies investment access prevents growth and harmful practices
- Big investment names claim ethical investing offers higher returns than traditional strategies
- Reality: ethical investing almost certainly can't deliver higher returns
Core Problem with Ethical Investing
- Effectively rebrands biggest investing mistake: lack of diversification
- May not have positive world impact as expected
- Video sponsored by channel members/patrons for controversial content
How Ethical Investing Works
- Focus on ethical investment management funds and ethical index funds
- Examples: Chamath Palihapitiya's Social Capital, BlackRock and Vanguard indices
- Actively managed funds problems: after management fees, only tiny percent consistently outperform market
- Analysis focuses on ethical index funds (more common for regular investors, larger market share)
- Ignoring higher fees on ethically branded variants for fair comparison
Index Fund Structure
- Made of tiny slices of different securities bundled into index
- Sold as new security with inbuilt diversification
- Buying capitalization-weighted share for every S&P 500 stock costs hundreds of thousands
- Some individual shares worth more than average person's entire portfolio
- SPY index funds much more suitable alternative
Two Methods for Ethical Index Creation
Omission Method (Most Common)
- Start with base index of companies
- Remove companies from certain industries (fossil fuels, tobacco)
- Problem: bad players fall through cracks
- Example: Nestle (snack company) wouldn't be omitted despite questionable moral practices
Inclusion Method
- Investment companies individually pick companies adhering to ethical framework
- Inclusion funds: companies trying to make world better
- Omission funds: companies that aren't completely terrible
Major Problem 1: Reduced Diversification
- Active stock selection = less diversification
- Casino analogy: games with 10% house edge
- Coin flip example: lose bet or win $1.80 (maintaining 10% house edge)
- Player strategy: bet on as few flips as possible (50% chance of making money)
- Casino strategy: want players to play as many games as possible
- Player splitting money over 50 hands almost guaranteed to lose
- Vegas card games have table limits to spread gameplay
Stock Market Application
- American stock market historically returns ~10% per year
- Investors have house edge advantage
- Statistically better to spread money as much as possible
- Ethical ETFs intentionally forego benefit of playing maximum hands
- Often omit entire industries altogether
Diversification Risk Example
- Scenario: lithium ion batteries cause cancer
- Devastating for electric vehicle companies
- Great for fossil fuel industry
- Well-diversified portfolio: losses in EVs mitigated by fossil fuel gains
- Ethical-only exposure: feel all pain directly
- Believing ethical businesses are future is speculation, not investing
Major Problem 2: Limited Real-World Impact
- Almost all ethical fund stocks purchased from secondary market
- Money goes to previous shareholders, not companies themselves
- Tesla investment doesn't fund new electric cars more than BP investment funds environmental damage
- Money just goes to random previous investor
Counter-Argument: Shareholder Value Theory
- Company managers obligated to maximize shareholder value
- Theory: unpopular "tainted" shares lose value, forcing management changes
- Reality: ethical fund dumps oil/gas holdings → share prices drop → better value for morally indifferent investors
- Discounted stocks offer higher dividends (5%, 10%, 15%)
- Increased earnings per share drives demand, counteracting ethical sell-off
- People engage in stock market for profits, not ethics
Better Alternatives
- Invest wisely and donate extra profits to causes you believe in
- Purchase products from companies doing good
- Don't expect to be "saint of Wall Street" through ethical investing
- One index generating great returns over 1-2 years = gambler on lucky streak
- Respect statistics for wise investing
- Want money to do good for world: spend it in ways that do good
Conclusion
- Ethical investing provides "warm fuzzies" but misses the point
- Separate investing (invest well) from doing good (spend well)
- Don't mix financial gain with moral virtue expectations
