AI summary by TwinMind

Ethical Investing is BAD Investing... Here's Why - How Money Works

How Money Works

10m 26s

Introduction to Ethical Investing

  • Ethical investing extremely popular in recent years
  • Promise: invest in companies that don't harm environment, exploit workers, or engage in bad business practices
  • Theory: denying bad companies investment access prevents growth and harmful practices
  • Big investment names claim ethical investing offers higher returns than traditional strategies
  • Reality: ethical investing almost certainly can't deliver higher returns

Core Problem with Ethical Investing

  • Effectively rebrands biggest investing mistake: lack of diversification
  • May not have positive world impact as expected
  • Video sponsored by channel members/patrons for controversial content

How Ethical Investing Works

  • Focus on ethical investment management funds and ethical index funds
  • Examples: Chamath Palihapitiya's Social Capital, BlackRock and Vanguard indices
  • Actively managed funds problems: after management fees, only tiny percent consistently outperform market
  • Analysis focuses on ethical index funds (more common for regular investors, larger market share)
  • Ignoring higher fees on ethically branded variants for fair comparison

Index Fund Structure

  • Made of tiny slices of different securities bundled into index
  • Sold as new security with inbuilt diversification
  • Buying capitalization-weighted share for every S&P 500 stock costs hundreds of thousands
  • Some individual shares worth more than average person's entire portfolio
  • SPY index funds much more suitable alternative

Two Methods for Ethical Index Creation

Omission Method (Most Common)

  • Start with base index of companies
  • Remove companies from certain industries (fossil fuels, tobacco)
  • Problem: bad players fall through cracks
  • Example: Nestle (snack company) wouldn't be omitted despite questionable moral practices

Inclusion Method

  • Investment companies individually pick companies adhering to ethical framework
  • Inclusion funds: companies trying to make world better
  • Omission funds: companies that aren't completely terrible

Major Problem 1: Reduced Diversification

  • Active stock selection = less diversification
  • Casino analogy: games with 10% house edge
  • Coin flip example: lose bet or win $1.80 (maintaining 10% house edge)
  • Player strategy: bet on as few flips as possible (50% chance of making money)
  • Casino strategy: want players to play as many games as possible
  • Player splitting money over 50 hands almost guaranteed to lose
  • Vegas card games have table limits to spread gameplay

Stock Market Application

  • American stock market historically returns ~10% per year
  • Investors have house edge advantage
  • Statistically better to spread money as much as possible
  • Ethical ETFs intentionally forego benefit of playing maximum hands
  • Often omit entire industries altogether

Diversification Risk Example

  • Scenario: lithium ion batteries cause cancer
  • Devastating for electric vehicle companies
  • Great for fossil fuel industry
  • Well-diversified portfolio: losses in EVs mitigated by fossil fuel gains
  • Ethical-only exposure: feel all pain directly
  • Believing ethical businesses are future is speculation, not investing

Major Problem 2: Limited Real-World Impact

  • Almost all ethical fund stocks purchased from secondary market
  • Money goes to previous shareholders, not companies themselves
  • Tesla investment doesn't fund new electric cars more than BP investment funds environmental damage
  • Money just goes to random previous investor

Counter-Argument: Shareholder Value Theory

  • Company managers obligated to maximize shareholder value
  • Theory: unpopular "tainted" shares lose value, forcing management changes
  • Reality: ethical fund dumps oil/gas holdings → share prices drop → better value for morally indifferent investors
  • Discounted stocks offer higher dividends (5%, 10%, 15%)
  • Increased earnings per share drives demand, counteracting ethical sell-off
  • People engage in stock market for profits, not ethics

Better Alternatives

  • Invest wisely and donate extra profits to causes you believe in
  • Purchase products from companies doing good
  • Don't expect to be "saint of Wall Street" through ethical investing
  • One index generating great returns over 1-2 years = gambler on lucky streak
  • Respect statistics for wise investing
  • Want money to do good for world: spend it in ways that do good

Conclusion

  • Ethical investing provides "warm fuzzies" but misses the point
  • Separate investing (invest well) from doing good (spend well)
  • Don't mix financial gain with moral virtue expectations

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome