AI summary by TwinMind
EUV Lithography. But With a Free Electron Laser
Asianometry
15m 34s
TSMC N3 Process Overview
- Two versions of N3 process exist: N3B and N3E
- N3B ("based") currently in high volume production
- Likely producing Apple chips since end of 2022
- No products released yet using this process
- N3E considered "real N3"
- Heading into high volume production later in 2023
- Entirely different from N3B
EUV Layer Differences Between N3B and N3E
- N3B has 80% more EUV layers than N5/N4 process nodes
- N3E scaled back EUV usage: 25 EUV exposures reduced to 19
- Strange decision given TSMC has more EUV machines than any other fab
- Theory: Current EUV approach hasn't reached promised potential
Current EUV Light Generation Method (LPP)
- Laser-produced plasma (LPP) fires high-intensity CO2 laser at tin droplets
- Droplets turn into plasma emitting 13.5nm EUV light
- Photons bounce off mirrors and photomask before reaching wafer
- Process suffers from stochastic effects causing print failures
- Broken lines, micro bridges, rough edges
- Different from defects (particle contamination, pattern collapse)
- Completely random, non-repeating failures
Power Requirements and Limitations
- Takes 14x more energy to output EUV photon vs 193nm photon
- 250W EUV source creates 14x fewer photons than 250W 193nm source
- Only small percentage of photons reach wafer due to losses
- ASML showed potential pathway to 600-800W in 2023
- Kioxia 2019 estimate: 1.5-2.8 kilowatts needed for 3nm and 2nm nodes
- Fundamental issues with tin contamination on mirrors
Free Electron Laser Basics
- Bound electron lasers use laser medium (e.g., neodymium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet)
- Electrons absorb energy, ascend to higher state, descend releasing light photons
- Free electron laser uses unbound electrons traveling near speed of light
Free Electron Laser Operation
- Electron gun creates electron beam
- Linear accelerator accelerates electrons to near light speed
- Alternating magnetic field (undulator) causes electrons to swerve
- Acceleration causes energy gain, later released as light
- Self-amplified spontaneous emission (SASE) intensifies light within undulator
- Electrons self-classify into buckets, creating coherent light emission
KEK Japan Proof of Concept
- Race track design with electron gun
- Two linear accelerators:
- Injector: adds 10 MeV kinetic energy
- Main: adds 800 MeV kinetic energy
- 200-meter undulator chain produces EUV light
- Beam recycled through second turn for deceleration
- Beam dump safely absorbs remaining energy
Free Electron Laser Advantages
- No tin contamination issues (no tin droplets)
- Single laser can serve multiple lithography machines
- 10kW for one machine or 1kW for 10 machines
- Adjustable wavelength (can go shorter than 13.5nm to 6nm)
- Cost advantage: ~$400M laser + $40M annual maintenance
- Fixed costs distributed across multiple bays
- Power efficiency: 0.7MW per 1kW EUV power vs 4.4MW per 1kW for LPP
- Electricity major variable cost for fabs
Historical Context and Development
- Free electron lasers invented 1971 by Stanford's John Mady
- Early machines only produced infrared/microwaves
- Early 2010s: seriously proposed as EUV source
- 2015: Global Foundries first serious proposal
- Research ongoing in Europe (Euro XFEL) and US (SLAC)
- Too late for early EUV development involvement
