AI summary by TwinMind

EUV Photoresists: The Next Generation?

Asianometry

22m 22s

Traditional Chemically Amplified Resists (CARs) Background

  • Dominated semiconductor industry for nearly 40 years
  • Critical to photolithography process using high-powered UV light exposure
  • Applied via spin coating, then post-exposure bake and development
  • Extremely delicate formulations, often custom mixed
  • TSMC contamination incident: killed 10,000-30,000 wafers, cost $500 million

CARs Technical Components and Process

  • Special chemical compounds with multiple components
  • Photo acid generator (PAG) activated by UV light
  • Generates acid that catalyzes dissolution inhibitor removal
  • Single PAG molecule can catalyze hundreds of reactions
  • Pioneered at IBM in early 1980s for KrF 248nm lithography
  • Market dominated by Japanese companies:
    • Tokyo Oka: ~30% market share
    • JSR: ~30% market share
    • Shin-Etsu: significant player

RLS Trade-off Performance Metrics

  • Resolution: pitch resolution (smallest printable distance between features) and feature resolution (finest details)
  • Line Edge/Width Roughness: measures displacement from ideal line, "shakiness" between edges
  • Sensitivity: dose needed to change resist behavior
  • Three metrics are coupled - improving one worsens others
  • RLS equation: resolution³ × line edge roughness² × dose = constant
  • More concerning as devices shrunk below 100nm

EUV Challenges for CARs

  • Resist materials absorb DUV at molecular level vs EUV at atomic level
  • Traditional CARs made from oxygen, carbon, hydrogen (low Z-numbers)
  • Poor at "stopping" EUV photons due to elemental composition
  • First generation EUV (2017-18, 7nm node) used modified 193nm CARs
  • Photon shot noise issues: ~30mJ/cm², 2,024 photons per 10nm² plot, 2.2% random variation
  • Solution: raised EUV exposure doses rather than increase sensitivity

CARs Evolution for EUV

  • Acid diffusion control strategies by JSR
  • Quenchers to restrain acid catalyst
  • New fluorinated PAGs more sensitive to EUV wavelengths
  • Metal-based sensitizers to boost existing PAGs
  • Photosensitized Chemically Amplified Resist (PSCAR) by Tokyo Electron and JSR:
    • Extra photosensitizer precursor (PP)
    • Additional post-exposure step with 365nm UV flood
    • Creates more acid at EUV photon impact sites

High-NA EUV Challenges

  • ASML's next-generation EUV machines with higher numerical aperture
  • Higher NA enables smaller features but creates problems:
    • Depth of focus inversely proportional to NA²
    • Thinner required resist layers
    • Concerns about proper image resolution and etch resistance
  • Expected to regularly print below 20nm pitch
  • Molecular concerns: CARs are 3-5nm polymer chains, leaving rough edges
  • Mechanical concerns: pattern collapse from liquid surface tension during development

Metal Oxide Resists Introduction

  • Direct change when hit by EUV photons (no chemical amplification)
  • Core materials: zinc or tin oxide attached to organic molecules
  • Higher Z-number metals: 4-5x more sensitive to EUV than CARs organics
  • Molecular rather than polymeric structure (smaller size)
  • Better resolution and line roughness performance
  • No unpredictable acid catalyst diffusion
  • Robust enough to skip hard mask deposition step

Key Players and Patent Disputes

  • Dr. Robert Brainard (University at Albany): pioneering work on metal-based EUV resists
  • Inpria Corporation (spun out of Oregon State University 2007):
    • Based on Professor Doug Keszler's work
    • Promoting tin metal oxide resists for ~decade
    • Funding rounds:
      • 2014: $7.3M Series A (Samsung Ventures lead, Intel, Applied Materials)
      • 2017: $23M Series B (Samsung lead, JSR joined)
      • 2020: $31M Series C (JSR lead, added SK Hynix, TSMC)
    • 2021: JSR acquired remaining 79% for >$500M
  • Patent lawsuits:
    • Oct 2022: Inpria sued Lam Research for patent infringement
    • Jan 2024: SUNY sued Inpria/JSR claiming original invention by Brainard in 2011

Lam Research's Dry Resist Technology

  • "Ether" dry EUV photo resist
  • Metal oxide resist applied via atomic layer deposition (ALD)
  • Dry development using plasma/non-plasma chemicals
  • Eliminates liquid development process
  • Reduces pattern collapse risk for small features
  • Challenges: requires high selectivity, risk of corner rounding
  • Ion beam post-exposure treatment to smooth patterns and reduce EUV dose

Implementation Challenges

  • Substantial retooling required for coater/developer systems
  • Fabs have 50-60 EUV machines requiring modification
  • Metal contamination concerns:
    • Surface anomalies on silicon wafers
    • Transistor gate oxide integrity degradation
    • Electron trapping in silicon
  • IMEC testing showed low contamination levels but concerns remain
  • Cost savings must justify substantial investments

Industry Outlook

  • Metal oxide resists offer benefits but require significant fab investment
  • Potential savings: reduced defects, lower EUV exposure costs, consolidated patterning passes
  • CARs industry (40-year dominance) developing intense countermeasures for high-NA EUV era
  • Competition between established CARs and emerging metal oxide technologies ongoing

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome