AI summary by TwinMind
EVERY MOVIE EXPLAINED
The Deep Dive
14m 23s
Film Analysis Theory Introduction
- Eric Boss presents theory: all American movies follow one of two story archetypes
- Claims nearly all prominent American filmmakers tell stories modeled after The Wizard of Oz (1939) or Citizen Kane (1941)
- Theory explains why big studios like Marvel currently struggling
- Acknowledges this isn't universal rule but pattern in American cinema
The Two Archetypal Films
The Wizard of Oz (1939)
- Victor Fleming's adaptation of L. Frank Baum's novel
- Story: Kansas farm girl (Judy Garland) travels to magical world, murders two witches, learns "there's no place like home"
- Technical note: Judy Garland's body double painted sepia-toned to match set transition
- Represents "story of the traveler" archetype
Citizen Kane (1941)
- Orson Welles' morality tale about newspaper magnate
- Thinly veiled attack on William Randolph Hearst
- "Rosebud" reportedly Hearst's nickname for his mistress's clitoris
- Represents "story of the disrupter" archetype
- Both films ranked top 10 AFI's best 100 films ever made
Story Archetypes Defined
Wizard of Oz Type: "Story of the Traveler"
- Fairy tales that transport audiences out of their lives, invite dreaming
- Joseph Campbell's monomyth structure
- Character journey: goes on quest → meets people → realizes want ≠ need → pays price → returns home changed
- Reflects American identity as nation of immigrants seeking adventure/opportunity
- American dream as literal dream - something to wake up from
Characteristics:
- Stories about restless dreamers leaving home for adventure
- Hero reacts to extraordinary circumstances, adapts
- Adventure forces hero to assemble diverse team
- Hero loses grip on reality at some point
- Driven by compelling central mystery
- Audience meant to feel awe at spectacle
- Ends by suspending audience in dreamlike state
- Celebrates diversity of big wide world outside walls
Citizen Kane Type: "Story of the Disrupter"
- Morality plays that reflect lives, call audience to action
- Greek tragedy structure: character tries to fix world → pays price → reaches pathos
- Reflects American embrace of Industrial Revolution, workaholism culture
- Unchecked ambition corrupts heart, turns people cold
- Higher you climb, further from humanity
- Rooted in F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby themes
- Every American figure somewhat a con artist/self-reinvention
Characteristics:
- Morality plays about flawed innovator/entrepreneur/disrupter
- Focused on one character vs group
- Central character obsessive, alienated, turns obsession into profit/fame
- Short-term success at expense of long-term happiness/community
- Set in worlds resembling present/past reality
- Explore/satirize American society and institutions
- Structured out of sequence: flashbacks, shifting POV, unreliable narrators
- Instruct on how to live lives
- End with hero dying/accepting fate/realizing crimes/giving up obsession
Cultural Context and Influence
American-Specific Focus
- Directors from other countries work through different cultural experiences
- Bong Joon-ho's capitalism critiques distinctly Korean
- Martin McDonagh's films distinctly Irish
- Miyazaki's Spirited Away is Wizard of Oz type but much more
- Akira Kurosawa's Rashomon (1950) similar to Citizen Kane structure but Kurosawa hadn't seen it
Historical Timeline
- William Randolph Hearst censored Citizen Kane globally
- RKO sold TV rights 1955, film circulated on American TV late 50s/early 60s
- Film critics started calling it best film ever made around this time
- Influenced generation: Stanley Kubrick, Steven Spielberg, Martin Scorsese, George Lucas, Francis Ford Coppola, Brian De Palma
- These directors "taught to dream thematically by Wizard of Oz, taught ethics cinematically by Citizen Kane"
Modern Application Examples
Marvel Studios Analysis
- Best when leaning into one story type
- WandaVision and Loki: Wizard of Oz types
- Guardians Vol. 3: Citizen Kane type (Rocket's story through flashbacks)
- Problems when trying both: Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness started Wizard of Oz, shifted to Citizen Kane
- Shang-Chi started Citizen Kane (family/abuse themes), shifted to alternate dimensions
2023 Success Stories
- Barbie: Wizard of Oz story
- Oppenheimer: Citizen Kane story
- Both outperformed most other 2023 films
- Connected with American audiences through clear archetypal storytelling
Conclusion
- Not claiming only two types of movies exist
- Believes two types of stories American audiences always love
- Hollywood films better with clear expectations, straightforward intentions
- Avoids audience whiplash effect
- Framework for future film analysis discussions
