AI summary by TwinMind
Exposing The Flaw In Our Phone System
Veritasium
31m 54s
Introduction & Blue Box History
- Linus from Linus Tech Tips phone network hacked remotely
- Intercepted phone calls and 2FA codes without touching device
- Could happen to anyone with phone number
- Steve Jobs & Steve Wozniak's first startup: blue box phone hacking device (1970s)
- Long-distance calls $25/minute (inflation adjusted, NYC to London)
- Blue box hacked telephone network for free calls
- Called Pope pretending to be Henry Kissinger
- Built from Radio Shack parts
- Jobs quote: "control billions of dollars worth of infrastructure"
Early Phone System Evolution
- Pre-1920s: no dialing capability
- 48 volts when phone on hook, 10 volts when lifted
- Voltage drop triggered light at exchange, operator manually connected calls
- 1910: predicted need for every working age woman as operator
- 1950: >1 million operators in US alone
- Rotary dial telephone automation
- Metal disc with ridges sent pulses matching numbers
- Number 2 = 2 pulses, number 3 = 3 pulses, etc.
- Zero at far end (10 pulses) instead of beside 1
- Pulses = control signals determining line connection
- Long-distance problem: capacitance/resistance distorted pulses
- Clear input signals became smoothed, couldn't trigger switching
- Made automating long-distance nearly impossible
Touch-Tone & SS7 Development
- Touch-tone/push-button phones introduced
- Used voice frequency range 300-3,400 Hz for control signals
- Each button uniquely identified by combination of 2 tones
- Horizontal and vertical axis frequencies
- SS7 (Signaling System Number 7) protocol created
- Separate digital line for control signals
- Prevented blue box attacks by removing voice line control
- Still broadly used today
- Introduced 1980 when mobile phones barely existed
Princess Latifa Case Study
- Princess Latifa Al Maktoum of Dubai escape attempt (February 2018)
- Fled with Finnish martial arts instructor Tina
- Sailed toward India on yacht captained by former French intelligence officer Hervé Jaubert
- March 4th: abducted by father's agents using laser sights
- Captain victim of coordinated SS7 attack
- Aimed to pinpoint location and find Princess
- Used same steps demonstrated on Linus
SS7 Attack Methodology - Three Steps
Step 1: Infiltrate SS7
- SS7 designed as "walled garden" - closed network with few barriers once inside
- 1980s: few large reputable operators with established relationships
- 2024: >1,200 operators and 4,500 networks need SS7 access
- Virtual network operators to mass tech services (Uber Eats notifications)
- Not all players trustworthy - can be bribed, hacked, sell services
- SS7 access cost: few thousand per month
- Valuable US-based GT leased illegally for $113,000/month
- Global titles (GTs) = addressing scheme (like IP addresses for internet)
- Roaming requires telcos to communicate, share membership via unique addresses
- Accessing trusted GT = access to all GTs with partnerships
Step 2: Gain Trust
- Need more than SS7 access and phone number
- Require IMEI: 15-digit unique identifier from SIM card
- International Mobile Subscriber Identity crucial for appearing trusted
- Send messages like "send routing info" to collect IMEI
- Networks have firewalls denying suspicious requests
Step 3: Attack
- Call interception demonstration on Linus
- James from Hacksmith called Linus's number
- Call went to Derek instead, Linus's phone never rang
- Exploited roaming scenario to rewrite called number
- Text message interception for 2FA codes
- Set up new Linus YouTube channel
- Intercepted SMS code: 82299
- Successfully hacked account using stolen 2FA
- Linus never knew messages were intercepted
Location Tracking Capabilities
- Third attack method: location tracking
- Doesn't rely on GPS (invented before GPS public use)
- Methods:
- Multiple cell towers: location narrowed to signal overlap areas
- Time measurement: signals from 3 towers calculate exact 2D location
- SS7 method: identifies connected cell tower (subtle approach)
- Urban areas: accurate to within 100m, know specific city block
- 2016: tracked US Congressman Ted Lieu in LA area
Real-World Attack Examples
Princess Latifa Attack Details
- 5-minute window attack sequence:
- 7+ separate requests for captain's IMEI from US operator
- 4+ location requests when IMEI requests failed
- Multiple GTs in different countries used
- Most requests blocked by firewalls, but 6th GT likely succeeded
- Investigative journalist: "textbook example of telco penetration risks"
- Combined with other tools: Pegasus spyware, spotter planes
Criminal Usage
- SS7 used to intercept SMS 2FA codes, empty millions from bank accounts
- NSO Group (Israeli cyber surveillance) acquired SS7 tracking company 2014
- Pegasus spyware: complete phone access, zero-click hacks cost $4 million+ per exploit
- SS7 provides basic data (device type, software version) before expensive targeted attacks
- Expert testing: 20-30 VIPs under constant surveillance including country's chief of cyber security
- 2.5+ million tracking attempts per year documented
Industry Response & Current State
- 2014: Carsten Nohl and Tobias Engel publicly exposed vulnerabilities
- German telcos immediately refused "anytime interrogation" requests
- 150+ other messages still need blocking for complete SS7 security
- SS7 remains backbone of 2G/3G communications
- EU cars since 2018: mandatory emergency call buttons using 2G/3G SIM cards
- 4G/5G still fall back to SS7 when connectivity drops
- 5G signaling protocol can stop attacks completely
- Network effects problem: no benefit being first adopter
- SS7 still de facto standard for inter-network call routing
- Estimated 10-20 years until SS7 networks finally switched off
Protection Recommendations
- Personal protection limited while having SIM card
- Location tracking unavoidable with SIM card
- Avoid SMS-based 2FA when possible
- Use authenticator apps or hardware tokens instead
- Phone call protection: use encrypted internet-based services
- Signal or WhatsApp for calls
- Mainly targets "people of interest" but millions of abuse cases monthly
- Privacy philosophical question: prerequisite for democracy vs "nothing to hide"
