AI summary by TwinMind
Farmer's Almanac: Literature to Poop To | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
48m 6s
Podcast Introduction and Personal Connection
- Josh Clark hosts with Charles "Chuck" Bryant and Jerry
- Josh commissioned episode after putting Old Farmer's Almanac in outhouse at his camp
- Has composting toilet with solar panel-powered fan for aerobic composting
- Placed almanac there as traditional bathroom reading material
- Common practice in the South growing up
- Chuck's grandmother Bryant was backyard farmer who relied on Farmer's Almanac
- Yumi surprisingly read Farmer's Almanac as child
- Chuck ordered 2024 edition, arrives August 30th
What is a Farmer's Almanac
- Books containing:
- Planting advice and cattle tips
- Astronomical charts (sunrise/sunset times, moon phases)
- Recipes, jokes, poetry
- Long-range weather forecasts (80% claimed accuracy)
- Mix of folksy entertainment and practical farming data
- Big draw: weather forecasts for entire US/Canada a year in advance
- 18 regions in US, 6 in Canada covered
Historical Origins
- Word "almanac" invented by medieval French astronomers (13th century)
- Claimed it was Arabic word meaning "calendar of the heavens" (actually made up)
- Medieval almanacs were handwritten before printing press
- Among first things printed when printing press arrived
- People lived their lives by these publications
Benjamin Franklin's Poor Richard's Almanac (1732-1758)
- Parody almanac written under pseudonym Richard Saunders
- Satirized traditional almanacs while providing useful information
- Created famous phrases still used today:
- "Haste makes waste"
- "Fish and visitors smell after three days"
- "Early to bed, early to rise, makes a man healthy, wealthy and wise"
- Inspired by European almanac called "Poor Robins"
- Kicked off almanac craze in late 18th century
Robert Bailey Thomas and the Old Farmer's Almanac
- Massachusetts farmer from educated family with large library
- Background: school teacher, book binder, studied at Osgood Carlton School of Mathematics in Boston
- Founded Old Farmer's Almanac in 1792 (first edition for 1793)
- Oldest continuously published periodical in North America
- Never missed an edition in 230+ years
- Original 46 pages (slimmer than modern versions)
- First cover described "large number of astronomical calculations and Farmer's calendar for every month"
- Thomas edited 53 editions before dying in 1846 while editing next edition
- Success due to Thomas being good writer with witty, clever style
- Example: cider-making instructions written as story with humor
The "Old" Addition and Cover Design
- "Old" added in 1832 (35 years after founding) to distinguish from competition
- John Jenks introduced current cover design in 1851
- Same yellow cover with Four Seasons imagery still used today
- Features portraits of Ben Franklin and Robert Thomas
- Cover slogan unchanged for 230 years
Rival Publication: The Farmer's Almanac
- Founded 1818 (26 years after Old Farmer's Almanac)
- Orange/more modern-looking cover
- Different distribution strategy:
- Originally sold through businesses (banks, insurance offices) with custom branding
- Only sold in retail stores since 1994-95
- Still offers business branding option
- Ray Geiger ran it 1934-1994 (60 years)
- Called himself "most interviewed man in America" (18,000+ interviews)
- Created national campaigns for attention
- Successful campaign: prevented USPS from replacing place names with numerical codes on postmarks
Almanac Lore and Cultural Impact
- Hole in top left corner of both almanacs
- Both claim to have originated it
- Customers were hammering nails through almanacs to hang them
- Publishers started pre-drilling holes with string for hanging
- Farmer's Almanac specifically marketed for outhouse use
Lincoln's Almanac Trial
- Abraham Lincoln defended friend's son accused of murder
- Prosecution witness claimed to see defendant at 11 PM by bright moonlight
- Lincoln used almanac to prove moon wasn't bright that night
- Won case using almanac evidence
- Both almanacs claim it was their publication (actually Jane's Almanac)
- Client was likely guilty; Lincoln later helped release wrongly convicted accomplice
Weather Forecasting Methods and Accuracy
- Combined sales: 10-12 million copies annually
- Old Farmer's Almanac: 3-5 million
- Farmer's Almanac: ~6 million
- Both claim 80% accuracy using "secret formulas"
- Old Farmer's Almanac: supposedly Robert Thomas's formula in black box (actually just handwritten notes)
- Farmer's Almanac: pseudonymous "Caleb Weatherby" uses founder's formula
- Modern methods include:
- Historical climate normals (30-year averages)
- Sunspot activity consideration
- General predictions (hotter/cooler, wetter/drier than average)
- No specific daily forecasts
Scientific Scrutiny of Weather Predictions
- Meteorologists skeptical - NOAA 90-day forecasts only 60% accurate
- Independent studies show lower accuracy:
- Jan Null (Golden Gate Weather Service): 40% precipitation, 6% temperature accuracy (2021-22 winter)
- University of Illinois: 50-52% accuracy generally
- Confirmation bias: people remember correct predictions, forget wrong ones
- Tim Clark (Old Farmer's Almanac writer, 4 decades): "People want us to be right"
Cultural Significance and Modern Role
- Represents connection to agrarian past
- Provides respite from modern world
- Focuses attention on nature and seasonal cycles
- Value beyond weather accuracy - folksy charm, poetry, jokes
- Longest-standing periodical in North America deserves preservation
- Reminder of traditional ways of thinking and being
