AI summary by TwinMind

Farmer's Almanac: Literature to Poop To | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

48m 6s

Podcast Introduction and Personal Connection

  • Josh Clark hosts with Charles "Chuck" Bryant and Jerry
  • Josh commissioned episode after putting Old Farmer's Almanac in outhouse at his camp
    • Has composting toilet with solar panel-powered fan for aerobic composting
    • Placed almanac there as traditional bathroom reading material
    • Common practice in the South growing up
  • Chuck's grandmother Bryant was backyard farmer who relied on Farmer's Almanac
  • Yumi surprisingly read Farmer's Almanac as child
  • Chuck ordered 2024 edition, arrives August 30th

What is a Farmer's Almanac

  • Books containing:
    • Planting advice and cattle tips
    • Astronomical charts (sunrise/sunset times, moon phases)
    • Recipes, jokes, poetry
    • Long-range weather forecasts (80% claimed accuracy)
    • Mix of folksy entertainment and practical farming data
  • Big draw: weather forecasts for entire US/Canada a year in advance
  • 18 regions in US, 6 in Canada covered

Historical Origins

  • Word "almanac" invented by medieval French astronomers (13th century)
  • Claimed it was Arabic word meaning "calendar of the heavens" (actually made up)
  • Medieval almanacs were handwritten before printing press
  • Among first things printed when printing press arrived
  • People lived their lives by these publications

Benjamin Franklin's Poor Richard's Almanac (1732-1758)

  • Parody almanac written under pseudonym Richard Saunders
  • Satirized traditional almanacs while providing useful information
  • Created famous phrases still used today:
    • "Haste makes waste"
    • "Fish and visitors smell after three days"
    • "Early to bed, early to rise, makes a man healthy, wealthy and wise"
  • Inspired by European almanac called "Poor Robins"
  • Kicked off almanac craze in late 18th century

Robert Bailey Thomas and the Old Farmer's Almanac

  • Massachusetts farmer from educated family with large library
  • Background: school teacher, book binder, studied at Osgood Carlton School of Mathematics in Boston
  • Founded Old Farmer's Almanac in 1792 (first edition for 1793)
  • Oldest continuously published periodical in North America
  • Never missed an edition in 230+ years
  • Original 46 pages (slimmer than modern versions)
  • First cover described "large number of astronomical calculations and Farmer's calendar for every month"
  • Thomas edited 53 editions before dying in 1846 while editing next edition
  • Success due to Thomas being good writer with witty, clever style
  • Example: cider-making instructions written as story with humor

The "Old" Addition and Cover Design

  • "Old" added in 1832 (35 years after founding) to distinguish from competition
  • John Jenks introduced current cover design in 1851
  • Same yellow cover with Four Seasons imagery still used today
  • Features portraits of Ben Franklin and Robert Thomas
  • Cover slogan unchanged for 230 years

Rival Publication: The Farmer's Almanac

  • Founded 1818 (26 years after Old Farmer's Almanac)
  • Orange/more modern-looking cover
  • Different distribution strategy:
    • Originally sold through businesses (banks, insurance offices) with custom branding
    • Only sold in retail stores since 1994-95
    • Still offers business branding option
  • Ray Geiger ran it 1934-1994 (60 years)
    • Called himself "most interviewed man in America" (18,000+ interviews)
    • Created national campaigns for attention
    • Successful campaign: prevented USPS from replacing place names with numerical codes on postmarks

Almanac Lore and Cultural Impact

  • Hole in top left corner of both almanacs
    • Both claim to have originated it
    • Customers were hammering nails through almanacs to hang them
    • Publishers started pre-drilling holes with string for hanging
    • Farmer's Almanac specifically marketed for outhouse use

Lincoln's Almanac Trial

  • Abraham Lincoln defended friend's son accused of murder
  • Prosecution witness claimed to see defendant at 11 PM by bright moonlight
  • Lincoln used almanac to prove moon wasn't bright that night
  • Won case using almanac evidence
  • Both almanacs claim it was their publication (actually Jane's Almanac)
  • Client was likely guilty; Lincoln later helped release wrongly convicted accomplice

Weather Forecasting Methods and Accuracy

  • Combined sales: 10-12 million copies annually
    • Old Farmer's Almanac: 3-5 million
    • Farmer's Almanac: ~6 million
  • Both claim 80% accuracy using "secret formulas"
  • Old Farmer's Almanac: supposedly Robert Thomas's formula in black box (actually just handwritten notes)
  • Farmer's Almanac: pseudonymous "Caleb Weatherby" uses founder's formula
  • Modern methods include:
    • Historical climate normals (30-year averages)
    • Sunspot activity consideration
    • General predictions (hotter/cooler, wetter/drier than average)
    • No specific daily forecasts

Scientific Scrutiny of Weather Predictions

  • Meteorologists skeptical - NOAA 90-day forecasts only 60% accurate
  • Independent studies show lower accuracy:
    • Jan Null (Golden Gate Weather Service): 40% precipitation, 6% temperature accuracy (2021-22 winter)
    • University of Illinois: 50-52% accuracy generally
  • Confirmation bias: people remember correct predictions, forget wrong ones
  • Tim Clark (Old Farmer's Almanac writer, 4 decades): "People want us to be right"

Cultural Significance and Modern Role

  • Represents connection to agrarian past
  • Provides respite from modern world
  • Focuses attention on nature and seasonal cycles
  • Value beyond weather accuracy - folksy charm, poetry, jokes
  • Longest-standing periodical in North America deserves preservation
  • Reminder of traditional ways of thinking and being

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome