AI summary by TwinMind
Forensic Dentistry | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
42m 49s
Introduction and Hosts
- Josh and Chuck hosting Stuff You Should Know podcast
- Jerry absent but "here in spirit"
- Chuck discussing dental implants - front four teeth replaced, initially too white, sent back for staining
- Implants don't stain like natural teeth, others continue staining naturally
Overview of Forensic Dentistry
- Two main divisions:
- Identification of deceased people from dental records (legitimate, widely accepted)
- Bite mark analysis (controversial, considered junk science by most experts)
- Teeth strongest part of body, survive fire, chemical exposure, explosions
- Can withstand heat up to 2,000 degrees Fahrenheit before popping like popcorn
- Tooth pulp/dental tissue very resistant to environmental attacks: incineration, immersion, trauma, decomposition
- DNA extraction from tooth pulp viable method
Historical Development of Bite Mark Analysis
- Before 1974: only used for disaster victim identification
- 1975: first bite mark analysis case in court
- Murder victim had bite on nose
- Three forensic dentists testified bite matched suspect
- Appeals court upheld conviction, setting legal precedent
- Exception became the rule for prosecuting cases
- Ted Bundy case (1978): famous success story
- Chi Omega sorority house murders at Florida State University
- Killed Lisa Levy and Margaret Bowman
- Bundy had extremely crooked front teeth
- Bite mark analysis instrumental in conviction
- Bundy admitted to killing 30 women, possibly up to 100
Dental Records and Identification Process
- Adults typically have 32 teeth: 4 incisors, 4 canines, 8 premolars, 12 molars, 4 wisdom teeth
- Dentists document: tooth variations, changes, chips, dental work (crowns, fillings, bridges, implants), periodontal disease, receding gums
- X-rays and tooth charts create comprehensive dental records
- By law, every state requires dentists to keep dental charts for set number of years
- Mass casualty events: forensic dentists get list of possible victims, compare records to identify remains
- Plane crashes particularly benefit from dental identification
Information Gleaned from Teeth
- Age estimation: teeth grow ~4 micrometers per day, development follows set patterns
- Under age 20-35: can determine age range based on tooth development stages
- Ethnicity indicators: some Native Americans and Asians have incisors with scooped-out backs
- Socioeconomic background: expensive restoration work indicates wealth
- Geographic location: different methods used in different parts of world
- Lifestyle indicators:
- Smoking patterns
- Pipe smoking creates distinctive curved wear pattern
- Bagpipe playing creates specific wear
- Taylor's Notch: dressmakers/tailors who hold pins in teeth develop small indentations
Black Death Study
- Medieval villagers' teeth studied for plague DNA
- Extracted DNA from tooth pulp of plague victims
- Definitively proved Yersinia pestis bacteria caused Black Death
- Bacteria carried by fleas on rats
- Excluded some falsely attributed plague deaths
- Oldest successful DNA extraction from tooth pulp: 6,000 years old (4,000 BCE, 2005)
- Mitochondrial DNA also useful when regular DNA unavailable
Bite Mark Evidence Collection Process
- Time-sensitive: bite marks change quickly
- Body deterioration affects bite mark location (skin slipping, shrinking)
- Bruising and lividity can obscure marks
- Must wait for bruising to heal or lividity to subside
- Specific photography with rulers required
- Cut out bite mark from skin, preserve in formalin, make silicone cast
Types of Bite Marks (Transfer Patterns)
- Abrasion: scraping damage
- Artifact: actual body part missing (like Evander Holyfield's earlobe from Mike Tyson)
- Avulsion: skin removed but not entire body part
- Contusion: bruising
- Hemorrhage: profuse bleeding
- Incision: clean, neat wound
- Laceration: puncture wound
Bite Mark Depth Categories
- Clear impression: significant pressure (lowest category)
- Obvious: medium pressure (middle category)
- Noticeable: violent pressure (highest category)
- Categories considered subjective and unscientific
Factors Affecting Bite Marks
- Successive biting vs. single clamp
- Tongue movement during bite
- Victim movement (dead victims don't move, affecting mark clarity)
- Tooth profile variations: missing teeth, crooked teeth, chips, braces, implants, bridges
Evidence Collection from Suspects
- Warrant required for dental molds
- Photographs of mouth opening, closing, biting
- Historical court testimony claimed 100% certainty matches
- Claim that each person's dental arrangement is unique (disputed)
Scientific Challenges to Bite Mark Analysis
- 2015 study: 39 board-certified forensic odontologists examined 100 bite mark photos
- Only 8% of photos achieved 90% expert consensus on human vs. animal origin
- Experts couldn't agree on most basic classifications
- Same experts shown identical photos 8 weeks later disagreed with their own previous assessments
NIST 2022 Report Findings
- National Institute of Standards and Technology declared bite mark analysis "not real science"
- Based on three faulty premises:
- Dental patterns are unique to each person
- Patterns can be accurately transferred to human skin
- Bite marks provide sufficient detail for positive identification
Uniqueness Studies
- 2013 UAE study: examined 2,000 high-quality dental charts
- Found 51% were unique, 49% identical to at least one other person
- Undermines claim of universal dental uniqueness
- Study used dental charts only, not actual bite impressions
Wrongful Convictions
- At least 26 people exonerated by DNA evidence after bite mark convictions
- Roy Brown case: convicted despite missing front tooth
- Forensic dentists claimed sawing motion could explain discrepancy
- Served 15 years (1992-2007), both forensic dentists later recanted testimony
- Roy Krone: expert testified to 100% match, served 10 years before exoneration
John Kunco Case
- Convicted 1991 for rape and assault
- Evidence: voice ID, party comment, bite mark on shoulder
- Voice ID made from police officer's imitation of Kunco's lisp
- Party comment not corroborated by other attendees
- Bite mark analyzed using "West Phenomenon"
Michael West and the West Phenomenon
- Mississippi forensic odontologist who made living as expert witness
- Claimed special goggles and UV light could "resurrect" healed bite marks years later
- Wouldn't share photographs, convicted people based solely on his testimony
- Technique completely fabricated, part of "junkiest junk science"
2016 Policy Changes
- Steven Cheney case in Texas led to major reforms
- Texas Court of Appeals (conservative court) released Cheney
- Texas Forensic Science Commission declared need to stop fraudulent bite mark evidence
- American Board of Forensic Odontology revised guidelines
- New standard limits testimony to three conclusions:
- Exclude: teeth could not have made the mark
- Not exclude: possible the person made the mark
- Inconclusive: cannot determine
Current Status and Opposition
- 2009 National Academy of Sciences report criticized bite mark analysis
- No scientific studies support positive identification claims
- Innocence Project actively opposes bite mark evidence in court
- Appears at trials to object when prosecutors attempt to introduce bite mark analysis
- Generally successful in blocking such evidence
Historical Note: Paul Revere
- Paul Revere was both blacksmith and dentist
- One of first forensic odontologists using dental records
- Identified Revolutionary War casualties including Dr. Joseph Warren
- Warren was the man who sent Revere on his famous "British are coming" ride
Listener Feedback
- ADHD episode follow-up from Steve
- Listener pulled over crying because life experiences explained
- Appreciated calling it "disorder" vs. other terms
- Emphasized importance of acceptance before attempting to help/change someone
- Advice: approach with love, not intent to "fix"
