AI summary by TwinMind

Forensic Dentistry | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

42m 49s

Introduction and Hosts

  • Josh and Chuck hosting Stuff You Should Know podcast
  • Jerry absent but "here in spirit"
  • Chuck discussing dental implants - front four teeth replaced, initially too white, sent back for staining
  • Implants don't stain like natural teeth, others continue staining naturally

Overview of Forensic Dentistry

  • Two main divisions:
    • Identification of deceased people from dental records (legitimate, widely accepted)
    • Bite mark analysis (controversial, considered junk science by most experts)
  • Teeth strongest part of body, survive fire, chemical exposure, explosions
  • Can withstand heat up to 2,000 degrees Fahrenheit before popping like popcorn
  • Tooth pulp/dental tissue very resistant to environmental attacks: incineration, immersion, trauma, decomposition
  • DNA extraction from tooth pulp viable method

Historical Development of Bite Mark Analysis

  • Before 1974: only used for disaster victim identification
  • 1975: first bite mark analysis case in court
    • Murder victim had bite on nose
    • Three forensic dentists testified bite matched suspect
    • Appeals court upheld conviction, setting legal precedent
  • Exception became the rule for prosecuting cases
  • Ted Bundy case (1978): famous success story
    • Chi Omega sorority house murders at Florida State University
    • Killed Lisa Levy and Margaret Bowman
    • Bundy had extremely crooked front teeth
    • Bite mark analysis instrumental in conviction
    • Bundy admitted to killing 30 women, possibly up to 100

Dental Records and Identification Process

  • Adults typically have 32 teeth: 4 incisors, 4 canines, 8 premolars, 12 molars, 4 wisdom teeth
  • Dentists document: tooth variations, changes, chips, dental work (crowns, fillings, bridges, implants), periodontal disease, receding gums
  • X-rays and tooth charts create comprehensive dental records
  • By law, every state requires dentists to keep dental charts for set number of years
  • Mass casualty events: forensic dentists get list of possible victims, compare records to identify remains
  • Plane crashes particularly benefit from dental identification

Information Gleaned from Teeth

  • Age estimation: teeth grow ~4 micrometers per day, development follows set patterns
  • Under age 20-35: can determine age range based on tooth development stages
  • Ethnicity indicators: some Native Americans and Asians have incisors with scooped-out backs
  • Socioeconomic background: expensive restoration work indicates wealth
  • Geographic location: different methods used in different parts of world
  • Lifestyle indicators:
    • Smoking patterns
    • Pipe smoking creates distinctive curved wear pattern
    • Bagpipe playing creates specific wear
    • Taylor's Notch: dressmakers/tailors who hold pins in teeth develop small indentations

Black Death Study

  • Medieval villagers' teeth studied for plague DNA
  • Extracted DNA from tooth pulp of plague victims
  • Definitively proved Yersinia pestis bacteria caused Black Death
  • Bacteria carried by fleas on rats
  • Excluded some falsely attributed plague deaths
  • Oldest successful DNA extraction from tooth pulp: 6,000 years old (4,000 BCE, 2005)
  • Mitochondrial DNA also useful when regular DNA unavailable

Bite Mark Evidence Collection Process

  • Time-sensitive: bite marks change quickly
  • Body deterioration affects bite mark location (skin slipping, shrinking)
  • Bruising and lividity can obscure marks
  • Must wait for bruising to heal or lividity to subside
  • Specific photography with rulers required
  • Cut out bite mark from skin, preserve in formalin, make silicone cast

Types of Bite Marks (Transfer Patterns)

  • Abrasion: scraping damage
  • Artifact: actual body part missing (like Evander Holyfield's earlobe from Mike Tyson)
  • Avulsion: skin removed but not entire body part
  • Contusion: bruising
  • Hemorrhage: profuse bleeding
  • Incision: clean, neat wound
  • Laceration: puncture wound

Bite Mark Depth Categories

  • Clear impression: significant pressure (lowest category)
  • Obvious: medium pressure (middle category)
  • Noticeable: violent pressure (highest category)
  • Categories considered subjective and unscientific

Factors Affecting Bite Marks

  • Successive biting vs. single clamp
  • Tongue movement during bite
  • Victim movement (dead victims don't move, affecting mark clarity)
  • Tooth profile variations: missing teeth, crooked teeth, chips, braces, implants, bridges

Evidence Collection from Suspects

  • Warrant required for dental molds
  • Photographs of mouth opening, closing, biting
  • Historical court testimony claimed 100% certainty matches
  • Claim that each person's dental arrangement is unique (disputed)

Scientific Challenges to Bite Mark Analysis

  • 2015 study: 39 board-certified forensic odontologists examined 100 bite mark photos
  • Only 8% of photos achieved 90% expert consensus on human vs. animal origin
  • Experts couldn't agree on most basic classifications
  • Same experts shown identical photos 8 weeks later disagreed with their own previous assessments

NIST 2022 Report Findings

  • National Institute of Standards and Technology declared bite mark analysis "not real science"
  • Based on three faulty premises:
    1. Dental patterns are unique to each person
    2. Patterns can be accurately transferred to human skin
    3. Bite marks provide sufficient detail for positive identification

Uniqueness Studies

  • 2013 UAE study: examined 2,000 high-quality dental charts
  • Found 51% were unique, 49% identical to at least one other person
  • Undermines claim of universal dental uniqueness
  • Study used dental charts only, not actual bite impressions

Wrongful Convictions

  • At least 26 people exonerated by DNA evidence after bite mark convictions
  • Roy Brown case: convicted despite missing front tooth
  • Forensic dentists claimed sawing motion could explain discrepancy
  • Served 15 years (1992-2007), both forensic dentists later recanted testimony
  • Roy Krone: expert testified to 100% match, served 10 years before exoneration

John Kunco Case

  • Convicted 1991 for rape and assault
  • Evidence: voice ID, party comment, bite mark on shoulder
  • Voice ID made from police officer's imitation of Kunco's lisp
  • Party comment not corroborated by other attendees
  • Bite mark analyzed using "West Phenomenon"

Michael West and the West Phenomenon

  • Mississippi forensic odontologist who made living as expert witness
  • Claimed special goggles and UV light could "resurrect" healed bite marks years later
  • Wouldn't share photographs, convicted people based solely on his testimony
  • Technique completely fabricated, part of "junkiest junk science"

2016 Policy Changes

  • Steven Cheney case in Texas led to major reforms
  • Texas Court of Appeals (conservative court) released Cheney
  • Texas Forensic Science Commission declared need to stop fraudulent bite mark evidence
  • American Board of Forensic Odontology revised guidelines
  • New standard limits testimony to three conclusions:
    1. Exclude: teeth could not have made the mark
    2. Not exclude: possible the person made the mark
    3. Inconclusive: cannot determine

Current Status and Opposition

  • 2009 National Academy of Sciences report criticized bite mark analysis
  • No scientific studies support positive identification claims
  • Innocence Project actively opposes bite mark evidence in court
  • Appears at trials to object when prosecutors attempt to introduce bite mark analysis
  • Generally successful in blocking such evidence

Historical Note: Paul Revere

  • Paul Revere was both blacksmith and dentist
  • One of first forensic odontologists using dental records
  • Identified Revolutionary War casualties including Dr. Joseph Warren
  • Warren was the man who sent Revere on his famous "British are coming" ride

Listener Feedback

  • ADHD episode follow-up from Steve
  • Listener pulled over crying because life experiences explained
  • Appreciated calling it "disorder" vs. other terms
  • Emphasized importance of acceptance before attempting to help/change someone
  • Advice: approach with love, not intent to "fix"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome