AI summary by TwinMind

Garett Jones - Immigration, National IQ, & Less Democracy

Dwarkesh Patel

1h 14m 1s

Introduction and Book Overview

  • Garrett Jones, economist at George Mason University
  • Author of three books: "Cultural Transplant" (how migrants make economies like their origin countries), "10% Less Democracy," and "Hive Mind"
  • Cultural transplant as continuation of anti-democracy argument - migrants influence through voting and cultural presence
  • Estimates 50/50 split between formal democratic influence vs cultural influence of migrants

National IQ and Elite Effects (Hive Mind Discussion)

  • Upper tail (elite IQ) matters more than lower tail for national productivity
  • Median voter theorem vs elite influence contrast
  • Exceptions to mean IQ rule: Gulf States (Qatar, UAE, Bahrain) and South Africa - non-democracies where elite IQ predicts better
  • Increasing IQ deviation would be beneficial if holding mean constant
  • Innovation externalities from elites "swamp" negatives from lowest performers

Immigration and IQ Effects

  • Low-skilled immigration simultaneously increases variance but lowers mean/median
  • Hurting mean/median is "big cost" especially in democracies
  • Institutions downstream of culture - "Spaghetti Theory" (cultural meeting in the middle)
  • Example: Italians brought spaghetti to America, Americans changed too

Statistical Analysis Critique

  • Criticized Powell/Nowrasteh "Wretched Refuse" study for not running change-on-change analysis
  • Jones's analysis: migrants from corrupt countries → negative relationship with economic freedom changes
  • Every statistical analysis showed negative relationships when properly tested

Historical Immigration Patterns

  • New Deal/Great Society periods had historically low foreign-born populations
  • Jones's focus: migrants bring cultural values, sometimes better/worse than destination
  • Estimates 20-30% of world has cultural values equivalent/better than US average

Policy Preferences and Recommendations

  • Supports increased immigration from countries with higher SAT scores (State history, Agricultural history, Technology scores from 1500)
  • Prefers "best possible" over "equivalent" immigrants due to externality effects
  • Suggests Iceland experiment for open borders advocates instead of US/major innovation centers
  • Preserve "i7" countries (China, Japan, South Korea, US, Germany, UK, France) as innovation centers

Deep Roots Theory (SAT Scores)

  • S: State history (thousands of years under organized states)
  • A: Agricultural history (settled agriculture experience)
  • T: Technology score (fraction of world's 1500 technology ancestors used)
  • China poorest majority-Chinese country due to communism, not Deep Roots failure
  • When including T-score, Deep Roots theory remains statistically significant for China/India

China and Development Strategy

  • China as potential source for poor countries wanting Chinese migrants
  • Risk of anti-Chinese backlash (Indonesia, Uganda examples)
  • Chinese population large enough to make global impact

Effective Altruism and IQ Enhancement

  • Flynn cycle: Public health interventions → higher test scores → more prosperity → more public health
  • Brain health neglected in child development
  • Environmental lead reduction, iodine, nutrition, healthcare for "health insults"
  • Adoption studies: half IQ gap closes when moving from poor to rich countries (Sweden data)

Innovation and Migration Effects

  • Anything lowering innovation in most innovative countries has negative planetary costs over 20-50 years
  • Short-run vs long-run effects - libertarians/open borders advocates focus on short-run static effects
  • European invasion of North America likely positive for global innovation

Ancestry and Current Performance

  • Average skill level of voters and ancestral traits affect current productivity
  • Income disparities between ethnic groups persist across generations
  • Some traits (frugality, personal responsibility) have private returns, others are externalities

Optimal Intelligence Allocation

  • Market signals "aren't terrible" but innovation involves market failures everywhere
  • Supports STEM allocation, academic status games alongside corporate hierarchy
  • Geographic agglomeration beneficial - being in same room important despite internet
  • Increasing returns to National IQ (log-linear relationship)

Genetic Selection and AI

  • Supports voluntary genetic selection for intelligence
  • Amniocentesis already widespread form of genetic selection
  • GPT-3/ChatGPT measured IQ around 85
  • Concern for word-based professions and simple advice/problem-solving roles

Democracy and Institutional Design

  • Fed works better than FDA/CDC due to guaranteed long terms and financial independence
  • FDA/CDC creatures of Congress, lack real independence
  • Prefers more Fed-like institutions with appointed experts and long terms
  • Elite control beneficial in democracies, dangerous in non-democracies

European Union and Cultural Differences

  • EU pulls Eastern European countries toward markets during accession process
  • Europeans less market-friendly than Americans possibly due to selection effects
  • Most market-oriented Europeans migrated to America historically

Bondholder Democracy

  • Bondholders likely to win long-term through tax hikes and slower spending growth
  • US has unused "superpower" of value-added tax
  • Expects fiscal gap closure through hurting poor/middle class, not hyperinflation
  • Liz Truss example shows bondholders pay attention to fiscal credibility

Mormon Economics and Social Trust

  • Mormon wealth ($100+ billion) reflects frugality building capital stock
  • High trust from Western Pioneer culture selection effects
  • Multi-level marketing schemes exploit high social trust
  • Frugality provides "invisible gift to future generations"

Immigration System Design

  • Would launch 10-20 year research project to operationalize Deep Roots scores
  • Currently like "Milton Friedman's monetarism in late 60s" - good ideas not policy-ready
  • Might use as small plus factor in points system, never hard cutoffs
  • Need further research before implementation

High IQ and Cooperation

  • Smart people more cooperative due to "Machiavellian intelligence"
  • Endogenous pro-sociality (calculated) not exogenous (inherent)
  • Risk when society enters zero-sum mode with low growth
  • High IQ fraud more dangerous when it occurs
  • Nuclear weapons example - existential risks from smart people, not "sticks and stones"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome