AI summary by TwinMind
Garett Jones - Immigration, National IQ, & Less Democracy
Dwarkesh Patel
1h 14m 1s
Introduction and Book Overview
- Garrett Jones, economist at George Mason University
- Author of three books: "Cultural Transplant" (how migrants make economies like their origin countries), "10% Less Democracy," and "Hive Mind"
- Cultural transplant as continuation of anti-democracy argument - migrants influence through voting and cultural presence
- Estimates 50/50 split between formal democratic influence vs cultural influence of migrants
National IQ and Elite Effects (Hive Mind Discussion)
- Upper tail (elite IQ) matters more than lower tail for national productivity
- Median voter theorem vs elite influence contrast
- Exceptions to mean IQ rule: Gulf States (Qatar, UAE, Bahrain) and South Africa - non-democracies where elite IQ predicts better
- Increasing IQ deviation would be beneficial if holding mean constant
- Innovation externalities from elites "swamp" negatives from lowest performers
Immigration and IQ Effects
- Low-skilled immigration simultaneously increases variance but lowers mean/median
- Hurting mean/median is "big cost" especially in democracies
- Institutions downstream of culture - "Spaghetti Theory" (cultural meeting in the middle)
- Example: Italians brought spaghetti to America, Americans changed too
Statistical Analysis Critique
- Criticized Powell/Nowrasteh "Wretched Refuse" study for not running change-on-change analysis
- Jones's analysis: migrants from corrupt countries → negative relationship with economic freedom changes
- Every statistical analysis showed negative relationships when properly tested
Historical Immigration Patterns
- New Deal/Great Society periods had historically low foreign-born populations
- Jones's focus: migrants bring cultural values, sometimes better/worse than destination
- Estimates 20-30% of world has cultural values equivalent/better than US average
Policy Preferences and Recommendations
- Supports increased immigration from countries with higher SAT scores (State history, Agricultural history, Technology scores from 1500)
- Prefers "best possible" over "equivalent" immigrants due to externality effects
- Suggests Iceland experiment for open borders advocates instead of US/major innovation centers
- Preserve "i7" countries (China, Japan, South Korea, US, Germany, UK, France) as innovation centers
Deep Roots Theory (SAT Scores)
- S: State history (thousands of years under organized states)
- A: Agricultural history (settled agriculture experience)
- T: Technology score (fraction of world's 1500 technology ancestors used)
- China poorest majority-Chinese country due to communism, not Deep Roots failure
- When including T-score, Deep Roots theory remains statistically significant for China/India
China and Development Strategy
- China as potential source for poor countries wanting Chinese migrants
- Risk of anti-Chinese backlash (Indonesia, Uganda examples)
- Chinese population large enough to make global impact
Effective Altruism and IQ Enhancement
- Flynn cycle: Public health interventions → higher test scores → more prosperity → more public health
- Brain health neglected in child development
- Environmental lead reduction, iodine, nutrition, healthcare for "health insults"
- Adoption studies: half IQ gap closes when moving from poor to rich countries (Sweden data)
Innovation and Migration Effects
- Anything lowering innovation in most innovative countries has negative planetary costs over 20-50 years
- Short-run vs long-run effects - libertarians/open borders advocates focus on short-run static effects
- European invasion of North America likely positive for global innovation
Ancestry and Current Performance
- Average skill level of voters and ancestral traits affect current productivity
- Income disparities between ethnic groups persist across generations
- Some traits (frugality, personal responsibility) have private returns, others are externalities
Optimal Intelligence Allocation
- Market signals "aren't terrible" but innovation involves market failures everywhere
- Supports STEM allocation, academic status games alongside corporate hierarchy
- Geographic agglomeration beneficial - being in same room important despite internet
- Increasing returns to National IQ (log-linear relationship)
Genetic Selection and AI
- Supports voluntary genetic selection for intelligence
- Amniocentesis already widespread form of genetic selection
- GPT-3/ChatGPT measured IQ around 85
- Concern for word-based professions and simple advice/problem-solving roles
Democracy and Institutional Design
- Fed works better than FDA/CDC due to guaranteed long terms and financial independence
- FDA/CDC creatures of Congress, lack real independence
- Prefers more Fed-like institutions with appointed experts and long terms
- Elite control beneficial in democracies, dangerous in non-democracies
European Union and Cultural Differences
- EU pulls Eastern European countries toward markets during accession process
- Europeans less market-friendly than Americans possibly due to selection effects
- Most market-oriented Europeans migrated to America historically
Bondholder Democracy
- Bondholders likely to win long-term through tax hikes and slower spending growth
- US has unused "superpower" of value-added tax
- Expects fiscal gap closure through hurting poor/middle class, not hyperinflation
- Liz Truss example shows bondholders pay attention to fiscal credibility
Mormon Economics and Social Trust
- Mormon wealth ($100+ billion) reflects frugality building capital stock
- High trust from Western Pioneer culture selection effects
- Multi-level marketing schemes exploit high social trust
- Frugality provides "invisible gift to future generations"
Immigration System Design
- Would launch 10-20 year research project to operationalize Deep Roots scores
- Currently like "Milton Friedman's monetarism in late 60s" - good ideas not policy-ready
- Might use as small plus factor in points system, never hard cutoffs
- Need further research before implementation
High IQ and Cooperation
- Smart people more cooperative due to "Machiavellian intelligence"
- Endogenous pro-sociality (calculated) not exogenous (inherent)
- Risk when society enters zero-sum mode with low growth
- High IQ fraud more dangerous when it occurs
- Nuclear weapons example - existential risks from smart people, not "sticks and stones"
