AI summary by TwinMind

Good Companies Should Not Last Forever.

How Money Works

12m 52s

Going Concern Accounting Concept & Investment Misconceptions

  • Going concern = accounting term for businesses with resources to continue operating for foreseeable future
  • Assumption useful for accounting but overrated in investing
  • Investors tend to assume successful companies will exist indefinitely
  • Examples of century-old companies: Johnson & Johnson, General Electric, Coca-Cola (100+ years)
  • JPMorgan Chase traces roots to 1799 through bank mergers across 3 centuries
  • Early investments in these companies would create wealth but investor would be dead
  • Recent industry report: biggest investor mistake = overvaluing company longevity
  • Warren Buffett frequently discusses $5 Coca-Cola investment historical value

World's Oldest Businesses Reality Check

  • Oldest businesses globally = NOT huge financial successes
  • Mostly small family-owned operations from Europe/Japan
  • Run continuously for hundreds of years without expansion or major risks
  • Operate in traditional industries: hospitality, construction
  • Congo Gumi (oldest business globally):
    • Started 578 AD building temples
    • Passed through family/non-family successors until 2006
    • Fell on hard times, purchased by Takamatsu Construction Group (publicly traded)
    • Still operates constructing event halls/libraries but no longer independent
    • Acquisition rumors suggest purchase for cultural significance, not business fundamentals

Hot Hand Fallacy in Investment Decisions

  • Hot hand fallacy = psychological predisposition to see patterns where none exist
  • Basketball analogy: consecutive free throws don't guarantee next shot success
  • Odds unchanged by past record, only affected by player skill and distance
  • Most investments include disclaimer: "past performance ≠ indication of future results"
  • 100-year-old company no less likely to go bankrupt than 10-year-old company with same fundamentals
  • Company history meaningless like basketball shot history
  • Older companies have advantages: brand awareness, customer base, established operations
  • Same advantages can box in business as much as defend from competition
  • Investors should assess companies case-by-case, not assume longevity = future success

Business Life Cycle Analysis

  • All businesses follow predictable life cycle:
    1. Foundation - struggles to gather first customers/investors
    2. Rapid growth phase
    3. Plateau after accessing all potential customers
    4. Either launch new offering for growth OR decline and close
  • Plateau period can theoretically last forever
  • World's oldest companies: modest size, little growth pressure
  • No debt/outside investors demanding consistent returns

Meta/Facebook Case Study

  • Currently at "pointy end" of business cycle
  • Founded → grew to largest social media company → plateau (ran out of new users)
  • Lost control of destiny: content creators leaving for TikTok with fandoms
  • Metaverse = new product offering to avoid becoming "next Myspace"
  • So far not huge success but attempt to stay on right side of business cycle

Management vs. Shareholder Interest Conflicts

  • Zuckerberg wants to maintain CEO role of world's largest personal information repository
  • Investors want maximum money return
  • If given choice, investors wouldn't independently invest in "cumbersome motion sickness generators and dystopian virtual worlds"
  • Forced indirect investment through Facebook ownership
  • Alternative: maintain current operations, reduce costs, maximize dividends until shutdown/acquisition
  • Zuckerberg owns controlling shares = majority shareholders can't vote him out
  • Story of desperate business reinvention not unique to Facebook

Research on Company Age vs. Performance

  • Patrick Boyle referenced McKinsey & Company report
  • Most largest US companies founded recently: Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, Google, Facebook
  • S&P 500 with only 60+ year companies would perform 33% lower
  • Research suggests long-history companies significantly worse than young companies

Corporate Baggage Accumulation

  • Reason 1: Old companies acquire corporate baggage over time
  • General Electric (130 years) = 130 years of outdated processes, agreements, problems
  • Accumulation extends to negative company history as acceptable standards change
  • Bayer no longer sells heroin but remembered for marketing it for flu treatment
  • Facebook transformation: trendy college platform → "angry Boomer convention"
  • Large companies inevitably involved in scandals, fraud, risky behaviors
  • Examples of legitimate businesses turned fraudulent: Enron, Worldcom, Wirecard, Lehman Brothers
  • Businesses like machines eventually wear out, more costly to maintain than replace

Operational Bloat in Aging Companies

  • Reason 2: Old businesses become bloated with unfocused staff/operations
  • Large companies spend more time managing themselves than improving products/services
  • Carl Icahn (billionaire investor) made money finding bloated businesses
  • Stripped redundant managers and side projects to restore profitability
  • Earned "corporate raider" reputation due to layoffs following acquisitions

ACF American Car and Foundry Example

  • 207-year-old business building/renting train cars
  • Simple business theory but stock selling for same price as total assets
  • Operations valued at effectively $0 by other investors
  • Manhattan head office: 12 floors of analysts/managers
  • Worked on overcomplicated financial systems instead of railcar operations
  • Plant manager told Icahn factory would run better if head office didn't exist
  • Spent more time creating reports for Manhattan than running plant
  • Icahn laid off all 12 floors of head office
  • ACF wouldn't have survived without activist intervention

Investment Time Frame Considerations

  • Endless operation scopes cloud investing decisions over reasonable time frames
  • Only tiny fraction of companies last 100+ years
  • Only tiny fraction worth $1+ billion
  • Congo Gumi returned less in 1400 years than Amazon in <30 years
  • Investors should have clear idea of investment return mechanism
  • New companies need roadmap with clear schedule for returns
  • After covering base, continued business existence just "gravy"
  • Older companies rarely held to same scrutiny
  • Easy assumption of perpetual existence
  • Strategy of dividends + selling to other investors works "until it doesn't"

Investment Strategy Recommendations

  • Good investing about diversification = only reliable way to gain exposure to next high-return companies
  • Diversification means both investing broadly AND regularly
  • Alternative: bet against Jim Cramer with specialized ETF

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome