AI summary by TwinMind
Good Companies Should Not Last Forever.
How Money Works
12m 52s
Going Concern Accounting Concept & Investment Misconceptions
- Going concern = accounting term for businesses with resources to continue operating for foreseeable future
- Assumption useful for accounting but overrated in investing
- Investors tend to assume successful companies will exist indefinitely
- Examples of century-old companies: Johnson & Johnson, General Electric, Coca-Cola (100+ years)
- JPMorgan Chase traces roots to 1799 through bank mergers across 3 centuries
- Early investments in these companies would create wealth but investor would be dead
- Recent industry report: biggest investor mistake = overvaluing company longevity
- Warren Buffett frequently discusses $5 Coca-Cola investment historical value
World's Oldest Businesses Reality Check
- Oldest businesses globally = NOT huge financial successes
- Mostly small family-owned operations from Europe/Japan
- Run continuously for hundreds of years without expansion or major risks
- Operate in traditional industries: hospitality, construction
- Congo Gumi (oldest business globally):
- Started 578 AD building temples
- Passed through family/non-family successors until 2006
- Fell on hard times, purchased by Takamatsu Construction Group (publicly traded)
- Still operates constructing event halls/libraries but no longer independent
- Acquisition rumors suggest purchase for cultural significance, not business fundamentals
Hot Hand Fallacy in Investment Decisions
- Hot hand fallacy = psychological predisposition to see patterns where none exist
- Basketball analogy: consecutive free throws don't guarantee next shot success
- Odds unchanged by past record, only affected by player skill and distance
- Most investments include disclaimer: "past performance ≠ indication of future results"
- 100-year-old company no less likely to go bankrupt than 10-year-old company with same fundamentals
- Company history meaningless like basketball shot history
- Older companies have advantages: brand awareness, customer base, established operations
- Same advantages can box in business as much as defend from competition
- Investors should assess companies case-by-case, not assume longevity = future success
Business Life Cycle Analysis
- All businesses follow predictable life cycle:
- Foundation - struggles to gather first customers/investors
- Rapid growth phase
- Plateau after accessing all potential customers
- Either launch new offering for growth OR decline and close
- Plateau period can theoretically last forever
- World's oldest companies: modest size, little growth pressure
- No debt/outside investors demanding consistent returns
Meta/Facebook Case Study
- Currently at "pointy end" of business cycle
- Founded → grew to largest social media company → plateau (ran out of new users)
- Lost control of destiny: content creators leaving for TikTok with fandoms
- Metaverse = new product offering to avoid becoming "next Myspace"
- So far not huge success but attempt to stay on right side of business cycle
Management vs. Shareholder Interest Conflicts
- Zuckerberg wants to maintain CEO role of world's largest personal information repository
- Investors want maximum money return
- If given choice, investors wouldn't independently invest in "cumbersome motion sickness generators and dystopian virtual worlds"
- Forced indirect investment through Facebook ownership
- Alternative: maintain current operations, reduce costs, maximize dividends until shutdown/acquisition
- Zuckerberg owns controlling shares = majority shareholders can't vote him out
- Story of desperate business reinvention not unique to Facebook
Research on Company Age vs. Performance
- Patrick Boyle referenced McKinsey & Company report
- Most largest US companies founded recently: Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, Google, Facebook
- S&P 500 with only 60+ year companies would perform 33% lower
- Research suggests long-history companies significantly worse than young companies
Corporate Baggage Accumulation
- Reason 1: Old companies acquire corporate baggage over time
- General Electric (130 years) = 130 years of outdated processes, agreements, problems
- Accumulation extends to negative company history as acceptable standards change
- Bayer no longer sells heroin but remembered for marketing it for flu treatment
- Facebook transformation: trendy college platform → "angry Boomer convention"
- Large companies inevitably involved in scandals, fraud, risky behaviors
- Examples of legitimate businesses turned fraudulent: Enron, Worldcom, Wirecard, Lehman Brothers
- Businesses like machines eventually wear out, more costly to maintain than replace
Operational Bloat in Aging Companies
- Reason 2: Old businesses become bloated with unfocused staff/operations
- Large companies spend more time managing themselves than improving products/services
- Carl Icahn (billionaire investor) made money finding bloated businesses
- Stripped redundant managers and side projects to restore profitability
- Earned "corporate raider" reputation due to layoffs following acquisitions
ACF American Car and Foundry Example
- 207-year-old business building/renting train cars
- Simple business theory but stock selling for same price as total assets
- Operations valued at effectively $0 by other investors
- Manhattan head office: 12 floors of analysts/managers
- Worked on overcomplicated financial systems instead of railcar operations
- Plant manager told Icahn factory would run better if head office didn't exist
- Spent more time creating reports for Manhattan than running plant
- Icahn laid off all 12 floors of head office
- ACF wouldn't have survived without activist intervention
Investment Time Frame Considerations
- Endless operation scopes cloud investing decisions over reasonable time frames
- Only tiny fraction of companies last 100+ years
- Only tiny fraction worth $1+ billion
- Congo Gumi returned less in 1400 years than Amazon in <30 years
- Investors should have clear idea of investment return mechanism
- New companies need roadmap with clear schedule for returns
- After covering base, continued business existence just "gravy"
- Older companies rarely held to same scrutiny
- Easy assumption of perpetual existence
- Strategy of dividends + selling to other investors works "until it doesn't"
Investment Strategy Recommendations
- Good investing about diversification = only reliable way to gain exposure to next high-return companies
- Diversification means both investing broadly AND regularly
- Alternative: bet against Jim Cramer with specialized ETF
