AI summary by TwinMind
Google Drive hates developers now
Theo - t3․gg
23m 56s
Google Drive API Policy Changes Impact
- Google changed API policy couple months ago, revoking access for many apps
- New requirements include expensive annual security audits (CASAS - Cloud Application Security Assessment)
- Third-party vendor audits required through companies like KPMG
- Costs amount to 1-2 months revenue for indie developers
- Annual recurring expense creates ongoing financial burden
iA Writer Android App Shutdown
- 7 years of Android development ending due to Google restrictions
- App "frozen in carbonite" - can't update without losing Google Drive access
- Google initially offered only read-only access to writing app (absurd restriction)
- 5 months, 55 updates, passport scans required for verification
- Google kept "altering the deal" with shifting requirements
- Team estimates costs at 1-2 months revenue annually
- Reddit user reported 60-80 hours, 3-4 months, 25-30 back-and-forth requests for similar process
- Decision made to take Android app offline rather than comply
- Existing users keep access, but no new features
- Considering B2B model as alternative path forward
Android Development Challenges Beyond Google Drive
- 12,000 different device types using iA Writer in 2017
- Fragmentation across Android versions and manufacturer UIs (One UI, MIUI, OxygenOS, Pixel Experience)
- Rampant piracy issues with minimal Google support
- Play Store search performance problems
- Inconsistent policy enforcement compared to Apple App Store
- Need to buy specific devices to debug issues
- Fake review manipulation required to compete
VLC Also Affected
- March 2024: VLC couldn't update Android app for 6 months
- Required either giving Google private signing keys or stopping old Android TV support
- Most Android TVs run old versions, never get updates
- Eventually found workaround after 6 months of back-and-forth
Panic Transmit Drops Google Drive Support
- Panic: game publisher (Firewatch, Untitled Goose Game), makes Playdate console, Mac dev tools
- Transmit: popular SFTP/FTP client for Mac
- 2019: Google announced additional security checks
- 2020: Access restored after months of waiting, internal Google contacts needed
- Nova text editor never got approval
- December 2023: Disabled again, required CASAS review
- March 2024: Reapproved but told annual reviews now required
- Google's Docker image for code scanning didn't work - took week to fix
- Scanner found no issues, benefited no one except security lab
- Google then removed self-scanning option, required paid third-party audits
- No maximum price guarantee, only discounted minimum
- Risk of user account bans from workarounds
- Decision made not to renew Google Drive access
Broader Implications
- Power consolidation toward large companies who can afford compliance
- Small developers and open-source projects excluded
- Synology (large NAS company) likely unaffected due to existing security infrastructure
- Individual developers like Terraria creator faced account bans affecting personal data
- Policy appears driven by incompetence rather than malice
- Creates arms race of fake reviews and security theater
