AI summary by TwinMind
Google Pixel 8/8 Pro Review: We'll Fix It In Post!
Marques Brownlee
16m 17s
Design & Build Quality
- Familiar design similar to past few years of Pixel
- Camera circles combined into one big circle (iPhone Dynamic Island-style)
- Pro models now have completely flat display (no curved edges)
- Satin back in every color - excellent at hiding fingerprints
- Dust still accumulates under/above camera bar
- Metal rails, clickiness of buttons improved
- Hardware package feels flagship-level alongside Xiaomi, Samsung
Display Improvements
- Pixel 8: 6.2" 1080P OLED, slightly smaller than last year
- Perfectly thin even bezels all around (no more chin)
- 120Hz display upgrade
- 2,000 nits max brightness
- Called "Actua Display"
- Not LTPO - turn off always-on display for battery savings
- Pixel 8 Pro: 6.7" display
- LTPO technology
- Close to 1440p resolution
- 2,400 nits max brightness ("Super Actua Display")
- Among brightest displays ever seen on smartphone
- Auto brightness behavior improved
Security & Biometrics
- Single front-facing camera with software improvements for secure unlock
- Works for banking apps, login authentication
- Software-based solution instead of additional hardware (IR camera, dot projector, radar)
- Fingerprint reader unchanged - still optical, not ultrasonic
- Slower than high-end flagships like Samsung
- Less accurate with wet conditions
- Not bigger in size
Camera Hardware & Software
- 50MP primary sensor shared across both models
- f/1.7 aperture, OIS
- Sharp photos, tons of dynamic range, fast autofocus
- Shallow depth of field with close-up subjects
- Heavy software processing:
- Multiple exposures blended into HDR
- Strategic relighting of faces
- Extra noise reduction (sometimes watercolor-like details)
- Tendency to over-HDR images
AI Camera Features
- Magic Eraser: Remove background objects/people
- Face Unblur: Fix blurry faces from motion/camera shake
- Best Take: Select best face from burst photos for each person in group shots
- Works with any photo in Google Photos library (not just Pixel-shot)
- Automatically recognizes photo bursts
- Surprisingly impressive accuracy
- Audio Eraser for videos:
- Separate different sound layers (nature, voices, background, wind)
- Drag sliders to adjust levels
- Works okay with small disruptions
- Cannot handle major noise (studio wind, V8 exhaust sounds)
Video Quality & Processing
- Improved over last year - less noisy in shadows
- Nice shallow depth of field with quick autofocus
- Entire Corvette Z06 video shot on Pixel 8 Pro
- Artificial face brightening processing visible
- Processed sharpening throughout footage
- Excellent color quality in video
- Would pick Pixel 8 Pro for stills from video over other smartphones
Artificial Software Limitations
- Same Tensor G3 chip in both models
- Same image signal processor
- Same primary and selfie cameras
- Pro Controls only available on Pro model (artificial limitation)
- 50MP shots only on Pro (non-Pro always bins pixels)
- $300 price difference for software locks
- Features already ported to Pixel 6 by developers
Upcoming Pro-Exclusive Features
- Zoom Enhance: Generative fill version of Super Res Zoom (coming later 2023)
- Improved Magic Eraser with generative fill (8 Pro only)
Magic Editor
- Available on both phones
- Wildest feature Google has made
- UI: Rainbow magic editor button in photo edit
- Capabilities:
- Select and remove/move/resize objects
- Move people up/down in frame
- Switch scenes to Golden Hour
- Replace entire sky
- Takes seconds to process, provides 4 edit options
- Quality: Decent for regular people when zoomed out
- Not professional photographer level (visible edges on close inspection)
- Lowers barrier to entry for photo manipulation
- Occasional blocks for gen AI terms violations
- Allows watermark removal (concern for photographers)
Battery Life & Performance
- Cannot "AI your way out" of 2,400 nit screen power consumption
- Pixel 8 Pro: 6-8 hours screen-on-time regularly
- Decent standby time
- Concern about long-term battery degradation based on Pixel history
- Question whether performance will maintain over months/years
Software Features & Android 14
- Call screening, Google Assistant integration
- Google stock apps improvements
- Android 14 breathing life into older Pixels
- Primary bug: Twitter notifications take extra time to open
- Chrome web page summarization via Google Assistant
- 3-4 bullet point summaries
- Follow-up question cards
- Limited to Chrome (app developers must opt-in)
- Even Google News app doesn't support it
Overall Quality & Support
- Excellent haptics
- High-quality phone calls
- Flagship fit and finish
- 7 years software updates
- 7 years feature drops
- 7 years security updates
- 7 years spare parts availability
Pricing & Recommendations
- Pixel 8: $700 starting price - worth the new price tag
- 120Hz, brighter screen improvements justify cost
- No problem recommending Pixel 8
- Pixel 8 Pro: $300 extra - harder to recommend
- Pro differences: telephoto camera, bigger screen/battery, temperature sensor
- Feature parity makes Pro premium difficult to justify for most people
