AI summary by TwinMind
Google Pixel 9 Pro Review - Redemption Time!?
Mrwhosetheboss
18m 8s
Build Quality and Design
- Best built Pixel ever, feels almost exactly like iPhone 15 Pro Max
- Similar dimensions, flat sides with slight curve, same weight down to the gram
- Intentional similarity to entice Apple fans switching to Android
- Grippier sides than previous phones, classy appearance
- Thinner, completely even screen bezels
- Most solidly constructed Google phone, doesn't flex at all
- Passed JerryRig durability test
- Redesign signals Google's continued commitment to smartphone market
Case Quality
- Addictively soft material, shows no fingerprints or light scratches
- Gently swoops around camera module with soft lip for fingers
- Nice felt interior, metal logo and buttons matching phone
- Perfect fit with exactly centralized cutouts
Hardware Improvements
- Ultrasonic fingerprint scanner (replacing optical)
- Fires sound waves instead of light to map finger ridges
- 3D understanding of prints, more reliable
- No signal issues reported
- 2.5 hour Nottingham to London trip: flitted between 4G and 5G almost entire time
- Only two 5-minute bursts of no signal
- New modem performing well
Performance and User Experience
- Flawless general feel, best Pixel experience
- Every animation has accompanying vibration motor feedback
- Gentle hum when sliding brightness up/down
- Zero bugs - most stable Pixel launch in history
- Vapor chamber finally added (like competitors)
- Screen doesn't dim on hot days
- Camera records continuously without stuttering
- Games don't slow down with persistent play
Performance Benchmarks
- 3D Mark extreme stress test results:
- Galaxy S24 Ultra: 57% stability after 30 minutes
- Pixel 9 Pro: 71.7% stability
- Pixel starts with much lower performance, never beats S24 Ultra at any point
- Tensor G4 chip still noticeably slower than Samsung, Apple, OnePlus flagships
- Storage speed significantly slower than Samsung in sequential read/write
- Takes split second for full resolution image to load when zooming
- $1,100 price point makes performance gap less acceptable (vs previous $900)
Gaming Performance
- Better than expected, played Zenless Zone Zero for 1 hour on max settings
- Only issue: slightly toasty side rails
- 16GB RAM by default (up from previous)
- AI tasks 50% faster than previous generation
Battery Life
- 6.5 hours screen time on smaller Pro
- 7 hours on XL model
- Less than Samsung but adequate for most users
- Overheating problem resolved with vapor chamber
AI Features Overview
- Most AI features feel "half-baked"
- Three standout features identified
Add Me Feature
- Takes separate shots of people, merges into group photo
- Technically impressive but limited practical use
- Reviewer prefers asking someone to take photo for authentic moment
- Risk of AI processing not turning out as expected
Pixel Studio App
- Generates images from scratch based on prompts
- Nothing new or better than existing solutions
- Requires Wi-Fi despite claiming on-device processing
- Extremely limited and fiddly for existing photos
- Dysfunctional selection tool
- Key options limited to adding captions or stickers
Assistant Integration
- Default assistant is Gemini (more AI-powered, smarter)
- Limitations with app interactions
- Doesn't do basic things Google Assistant used to do
- Clumsy middle phase with both assistants available
- User can switch between them depending on needed features
Magic Editor Improvements
- Auto-framing feature: zooms out of already-taken photos
- AI understands context (wooden beams, steps, trees, sky)
- Execution is impressive even if concept isn't new
- Reimagine photos feature: very powerful and convincing
- Successfully changed cat into dog in demo
- Cannot be used on photos of people (major limitation)
Pixel Screenshots App
- Separate app for managing screenshots
- Different search needs than regular gallery browsing
- One layer more intelligent than typical phone search
- Uses AI to understand screenshot meaning, not just content
- Better findability based on vague descriptions
Gemini Live
- Free-flowing AI conversation without trigger buttons/words
- Can talk over AI, natural conversation flow
- AI reduces volume and listens when user wants to speak
- Powerful bouncing board tool
- Example: Planned complete Pokémon-themed dinner menu through conversation
Camera Hardware
- Rear cameras almost identical to last year:
- 50MP main
- 48MP ultra-wide
- 48MP 5x optical zoom
- Front camera upgraded to 42MP (reason for large cutout)
- Can go super wide for group shots
- Improved 4K video capability
Camera Performance
- Base photo quality similar to last year
- Good color reproduction, strong HDR handling
- Detail levels comparable to Galaxy S24 Ultra
- Night mode good but softer than Samsung
- Portrait mode falls behind competition (poor edge detection)
Camera Frustrations (Carried Over)
- Zooming in/out still very laggy, feels unpolished
- Camera preview can get grainy even when final photos aren't
- Transition between lenses feels jumpy
- Cannot use 5x zoom lens for portraits or slow-mo
- Uses poor quality digital zoom instead
- Cinematic blur mode limited to 1080p only
Video Boost Feature
- Works on rear cameras only
- Keeps footage unprocessed initially
- Uploads to cloud via Wi-Fi for enhanced processing by Google data centers
- Improves colors, dynamic range, stabilization
- Can rescue grainy low-light footage
- Can upgrade resolution to 8K
Video Boost Costs and Concerns
- 8K boosted content requires ~800MB per minute of Google Cloud Storage
- Phone automatically uses any detected Wi-Fi for processing
- Risk of burning through others' mobile hotspot data unknowingly
- Reviewer experienced 10GB data usage on someone else's hotspot
Super Res Zoom Performance
- 30x zoom shots already 95% as good as Samsung S24 Ultra
- New Zoom Enhance AI feature makes Samsung "absolutely murdered"
- AI invents detail, not completely consistent
- Texture created may not be completely real
- Raises questions about authenticity vs. preferred image quality
Panorama Mode
- Best phone for taking panoramas
- Easy to take, super detailed
- Extremely seamless stitching between photos
Google's Strategic Motivation
- Pixel success drives all Google services adoption
- Best portal to funnel users to Google Photos and Gemini AI
- Only company shipping flagship Pro with just 128GB base storage
- $100 extra charge to upgrade to 256GB described as "diabolical"
Software Benefits
- 7 years of Android updates promised
- Classic Google software experience described as "joyous"
Overall Assessment
- Improves or fixes ~70% of issues from past Pixels
- Improvements across cameras, performance, AI
- Key cons: $1,200 effective price for XL (due to storage), still slower than competition
- Phone charged to 67% after 1 hour of continuous use during review
