AI summary by TwinMind

Google Pixel 9 Pro Review - Redemption Time!?

Mrwhosetheboss

18m 8s

Build Quality and Design

  • Best built Pixel ever, feels almost exactly like iPhone 15 Pro Max
    • Similar dimensions, flat sides with slight curve, same weight down to the gram
    • Intentional similarity to entice Apple fans switching to Android
  • Grippier sides than previous phones, classy appearance
  • Thinner, completely even screen bezels
  • Most solidly constructed Google phone, doesn't flex at all
  • Passed JerryRig durability test
  • Redesign signals Google's continued commitment to smartphone market

Case Quality

  • Addictively soft material, shows no fingerprints or light scratches
  • Gently swoops around camera module with soft lip for fingers
  • Nice felt interior, metal logo and buttons matching phone
  • Perfect fit with exactly centralized cutouts

Hardware Improvements

  • Ultrasonic fingerprint scanner (replacing optical)
    • Fires sound waves instead of light to map finger ridges
    • 3D understanding of prints, more reliable
  • No signal issues reported
  • 2.5 hour Nottingham to London trip: flitted between 4G and 5G almost entire time
    • Only two 5-minute bursts of no signal
  • New modem performing well

Performance and User Experience

  • Flawless general feel, best Pixel experience
  • Every animation has accompanying vibration motor feedback
  • Gentle hum when sliding brightness up/down
  • Zero bugs - most stable Pixel launch in history
  • Vapor chamber finally added (like competitors)
    • Screen doesn't dim on hot days
    • Camera records continuously without stuttering
    • Games don't slow down with persistent play

Performance Benchmarks

  • 3D Mark extreme stress test results:
    • Galaxy S24 Ultra: 57% stability after 30 minutes
    • Pixel 9 Pro: 71.7% stability
    • Pixel starts with much lower performance, never beats S24 Ultra at any point
  • Tensor G4 chip still noticeably slower than Samsung, Apple, OnePlus flagships
  • Storage speed significantly slower than Samsung in sequential read/write
  • Takes split second for full resolution image to load when zooming
  • $1,100 price point makes performance gap less acceptable (vs previous $900)

Gaming Performance

  • Better than expected, played Zenless Zone Zero for 1 hour on max settings
  • Only issue: slightly toasty side rails
  • 16GB RAM by default (up from previous)
  • AI tasks 50% faster than previous generation

Battery Life

  • 6.5 hours screen time on smaller Pro
  • 7 hours on XL model
  • Less than Samsung but adequate for most users
  • Overheating problem resolved with vapor chamber

AI Features Overview

  • Most AI features feel "half-baked"
  • Three standout features identified

Add Me Feature

  • Takes separate shots of people, merges into group photo
  • Technically impressive but limited practical use
  • Reviewer prefers asking someone to take photo for authentic moment
  • Risk of AI processing not turning out as expected

Pixel Studio App

  • Generates images from scratch based on prompts
  • Nothing new or better than existing solutions
  • Requires Wi-Fi despite claiming on-device processing
  • Extremely limited and fiddly for existing photos
  • Dysfunctional selection tool
  • Key options limited to adding captions or stickers

Assistant Integration

  • Default assistant is Gemini (more AI-powered, smarter)
  • Limitations with app interactions
  • Doesn't do basic things Google Assistant used to do
  • Clumsy middle phase with both assistants available
  • User can switch between them depending on needed features

Magic Editor Improvements

  • Auto-framing feature: zooms out of already-taken photos
  • AI understands context (wooden beams, steps, trees, sky)
  • Execution is impressive even if concept isn't new
  • Reimagine photos feature: very powerful and convincing
  • Successfully changed cat into dog in demo
  • Cannot be used on photos of people (major limitation)

Pixel Screenshots App

  • Separate app for managing screenshots
  • Different search needs than regular gallery browsing
  • One layer more intelligent than typical phone search
  • Uses AI to understand screenshot meaning, not just content
  • Better findability based on vague descriptions

Gemini Live

  • Free-flowing AI conversation without trigger buttons/words
  • Can talk over AI, natural conversation flow
  • AI reduces volume and listens when user wants to speak
  • Powerful bouncing board tool
  • Example: Planned complete Pokémon-themed dinner menu through conversation

Camera Hardware

  • Rear cameras almost identical to last year:
    • 50MP main
    • 48MP ultra-wide
    • 48MP 5x optical zoom
  • Front camera upgraded to 42MP (reason for large cutout)
  • Can go super wide for group shots
  • Improved 4K video capability

Camera Performance

  • Base photo quality similar to last year
  • Good color reproduction, strong HDR handling
  • Detail levels comparable to Galaxy S24 Ultra
  • Night mode good but softer than Samsung
  • Portrait mode falls behind competition (poor edge detection)

Camera Frustrations (Carried Over)

  • Zooming in/out still very laggy, feels unpolished
  • Camera preview can get grainy even when final photos aren't
  • Transition between lenses feels jumpy
  • Cannot use 5x zoom lens for portraits or slow-mo
  • Uses poor quality digital zoom instead
  • Cinematic blur mode limited to 1080p only

Video Boost Feature

  • Works on rear cameras only
  • Keeps footage unprocessed initially
  • Uploads to cloud via Wi-Fi for enhanced processing by Google data centers
  • Improves colors, dynamic range, stabilization
  • Can rescue grainy low-light footage
  • Can upgrade resolution to 8K

Video Boost Costs and Concerns

  • 8K boosted content requires ~800MB per minute of Google Cloud Storage
  • Phone automatically uses any detected Wi-Fi for processing
  • Risk of burning through others' mobile hotspot data unknowingly
  • Reviewer experienced 10GB data usage on someone else's hotspot

Super Res Zoom Performance

  • 30x zoom shots already 95% as good as Samsung S24 Ultra
  • New Zoom Enhance AI feature makes Samsung "absolutely murdered"
  • AI invents detail, not completely consistent
  • Texture created may not be completely real
  • Raises questions about authenticity vs. preferred image quality

Panorama Mode

  • Best phone for taking panoramas
  • Easy to take, super detailed
  • Extremely seamless stitching between photos

Google's Strategic Motivation

  • Pixel success drives all Google services adoption
  • Best portal to funnel users to Google Photos and Gemini AI
  • Only company shipping flagship Pro with just 128GB base storage
  • $100 extra charge to upgrade to 256GB described as "diabolical"

Software Benefits

  • 7 years of Android updates promised
  • Classic Google software experience described as "joyous"

Overall Assessment

  • Improves or fixes ~70% of issues from past Pixels
  • Improvements across cameras, performance, AI
  • Key cons: $1,200 effective price for XL (due to storage), still slower than competition
  • Phone charged to 67% after 1 hour of continuous use during review

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome