AI summary by TwinMind

Google Pixel 9/Pro Review: Gimmick or Good?

Marques Brownlee

24m 5s

Hardware Overview

  • New squared-off design similar to iPhones/Samsung
  • Brighter displays: 2,700 nits (Pixel 9), 3,000 nits (9 Pro models)
  • Even bezels all around with wrapped OLED panel edges
  • New ultrasonic fingerprint reader - faster/more reliable than previous optical versions
    • Limitation: requires always-on display or power button press to unlock (unlike Samsung's always-active hotspot)
  • Improved haptics
  • New camera visor design - less visor, more "shelf island"
  • New size option: Pro without XL
  • Battery capacities unchanged: 4,700mAh (smaller), 5,000mAh (XL)
  • A-minus battery life on XL: 5+ hours screen time consistently

Hardware Limitations

  • Slow charging speeds: 37W max on XL, slower on smaller models
  • Mixed materials: matte sides with glossy back (preference for full matte)
  • Storage starts at 128GB on $1,000 phone
  • Base model starts at $799, higher than previous generation

Camera System

  • Pixel 9 and 9 Pro share same primary camera and ultra-wide
  • Pro models add 5X telephoto zoom
  • Primary camera essentially same as last year
  • New 48MP ultra-wide (bins to 12MP)
  • Highly processed "Pixel look" - lots of HDR, contrast, dynamic range, sharpening
  • Less natural than competitors, more punchy for social media
  • New selfie camera on Pro shows biggest improvement in detail/color
  • Video quality good but heavily processed with visible segmentation/lighting adjustments

Software and Android Experience

  • Ships with Android 14 (not latest Android 15)
  • 7 years promised software updates
  • Pixel-exclusive features:
    • Call screening (superior to Samsung's Bixby version)
    • Now Playing ambient song recognition
    • Call Notes (records, transcribes, summarizes calls)
    • New Pixel Weather app with rearrangeable tiles
    • Updated panorama UI
    • Temperature sensor now works on people (Pros only)

Tensor G4 and AI Performance

  • Tensor G4 not significantly more powerful than G3 for regular tasks
  • New NPU dedicated to AI tasks with much more power
  • Significant RAM portion reserved for AI processing
  • Boot animation: Google logo transforms to Gemini logo

Gemini Integration

  • Deep integration as primary assistant
  • Conversational, remembers context, generally accurate
  • Rapidly improving capabilities over past weeks
  • Confusing coexistence with Google Assistant:
    • Two different assistants on same phone
    • Home screen widget still uses old Google Assistant
    • Gemini shows Google Assistant logo when using certain features
  • Gemini Extensions allow integration with Google services (Docs, Drive, Calendar)
  • Gemini Live: full conversational mode for complex queries
  • Gemini available on other Android phones (not Pixel-exclusive)

AI Features Assessment

Useful Features

  • Gemini assistant overall - quick, accurate
  • Call Notes - convenient recording/transcription/summarization
  • Video Boost - noticeable improvement in video quality
  • Add Me - combines two photos to include photographer in group shots
    • Works well despite some fuzzy edges when pixel-peeping
    • Question whether people will actually use vs. traditional selfies

Mediocre Features

  • Weather summaries - AI-generated descriptions of weather conditions
  • Magic Editor Reimagine - transform parts of images into different objects/settings
    • Refuses to modify people
    • Raises questions about photo authenticity
  • Screenshots app - organizes screenshots with search, reminders, web linking
    • Functionality already exists in Samsung Photos
    • Questionable need for separate app vs. Google Photos integration

Gimmicky Features

  • Zoom Enhance - adds clarity filter and fake texture, doesn't truly enhance detail
  • Pixel Studio - on-device image generation in 3 seconds
    • Works well technically but limited practical use beyond entertainment

Overall Assessment

  • Represents Google's smartest smartphone in quality hardware
  • Follows 2024 smartphone meta: incremental improvements + AI features
  • AI features optional - can use phone without engaging with them
  • Maintains traditional Pixel strengths while adding flagship-level hardware
  • Pricing reflects premium positioning but storage options remain limited

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome