AI summary by TwinMind
Google’s New Deal With Reddit
Theo - t3․gg
15m 6s
Reddit-Google Exclusive Deal Background
- Google announced deal with Reddit in February 2024 worth ~$60M/year
- Reddit data used for training Google's AI models
- More prominent Reddit results in Google search
- Deal amount comparison context:
- Google pays Mozilla $400-450M/year for Firefox default search
- Google pays Apple $20B for Safari default search on iPhones
- Reddit deal is 1/10th of Mozilla payment, 1/333rd of Apple payment
- Reddit desperately seeking revenue amid fierce competition from TikTok, Meta
- Average Reddit user heavily uses ad-blocking
- Reddit struggles with monetization compared to other platforms
Reddit's Search Engine Blocking Implementation
- Reddit updated robots.txt file to block non-Google search engines
- Prevents indexing of posts and content
- Affects Bing, DuckDuckGo, Mojeek, Qwant
- Only Google maintains access through paid deal
- Kagi (paid search engine) still has limited access by purchasing Google search index
- Bing shows zero results when searching "site:reddit.com"
- Reddit's justification: "believes in open internet but not misuse of public content"
Historical Context of Reddit's User-Hostile Policies
- 2023 API changes that killed third-party apps like Apollo, Narwhal
- Reddit blamed AI companies for API abuse
- Real motivation: IPO preparation and revenue generation
- Massive developer and user backlash
- User protests and subreddit blackouts
- Reddit removed protesting moderators
- Replaced mod teams with Reddit-controlled ones
- Forced subreddits to reopen
Content Ownership and User Rights Issues
- Users never consented to exclusive search engine deals
- Reddit restoring deleted/edited comments after users tried to remove content
- Users deleted content to prevent AI training use
- Reddit restored content to maintain data value
- Analogy: like library charging for access to donated books
- EU potentially could sue for restoring deleted content under privacy laws
Impact on Search Competition
- Creates effective monopoly for Reddit content access through Google
- Other search engines cannot properly index recent Reddit content
- Hurts competition in search engine market
- May create antitrust issues for Google despite their reluctance
- Google likely didn't anticipate Reddit would block competitors
Platform Quality Degradation
- Reddit continues rewriting website (15th rewrite mentioned)
- Old Reddit still preferred by many users
- Platform described as "dump of old data from last decade"
- Loss of third-party apps made platform less usable
- Reddit prioritizing stock market value over user experience
