AI summary by TwinMind
Harsha Bhogle Previews India vs Australia Test in Adelaide
Harsha Bhogle
8m 19s
India's Return to Adelaide
- Back to Adelaide Oval with positive memories despite past defeats
- Key victories referenced:
- 2015 World Cup win
- 2018 Pujara century and Test match victory (start of "Pujara phenomenon")
- 2003/4 Dravid double century (Australia scored 550 first innings but lost)
- 36 all-out incident led to greatest comeback in Test cricket history
- Set up aura for 2021 Border-Gavaskar Trophy series
India's Current Position and Momentum
- 295-run victory in Perth described as "staggering win"
- India appears more settled than Australia compared to Perth preparation issues
- Key player returns and form:
- Rohit Sharma back from absence
- Shubman Gill returning
- Kohli scored century, strong record in Adelaide (2012, 2014, 2015)
- Yashasvi Jaiswal emerged as much better player
- KL Rahul showed capability in both innings
- Rishabh Pant came in at 73/6, helped build partnership to 150
- Nitish Reddy "played like he belonged" (bowling not tested enough)
- All bowlers performed magnificently
Batting Order Permutations Analysis
- Not combination issue but permutation question
- Positions 8, 9, 10, 11 pick themselves
- Positions 5-6 relatively settled (Kohli at 4)
- Key decision: Rohit Sharma opening position
- Philosophy: When you sign up as opener, you commit to all conditions/preparedness levels
- Normal protocol: Replacement goes back to original position when regular returns
- Standard approach: Rohit opens, Gill at 3, Rahul back to 6, Pant at 5
- Alternative if Rohit considered "undercooked":
- Rohit at 5, Pant at 6, Rahul continues opening
- Creates potential problems if Rahul fails and Rohit succeeds in middle order
- Unfair to Rahul who was asked to open (difficult job) after being told career lies at number 6
- Other suggested combinations:
- Jayprakash Duminy suggestion: Rahul at 3, Gill at 5
- Recommendation: India needs firm decisions on batting order for entire series
Bowling Analysis
- Statistics from Perth: India far more successful when bowling straight and attacking stumps compared to Australia
- Bowling unit looking after itself well
Australia's Psychological State
- Staggered by some responses to Perth defeat
- Josh Hazlewood comments not concerning (straight talker, "batters need to score runs, I'm doing my job")
- Bigger concern: Comments about Kohli and Bumrah suggesting awe/fear
- Travis Head quote: "When I retire I can tell my grandchildren I had encounters against Bumrah"
- Contrasted with past Australian legends (Border, Waugh, Ponting, Clarke) who respected opposition but didn't express awe
- Australia not sounding like traditional Australia - potentially spooked mentally
- Very un-Australian behavior if true
Australia's Team Issues
- Key batsmen need runs: Steve Smith, Usman Khawaja
- Fifth bowler problem:
- Historically played with four bowlers in their prime
- Need fifth bowler if can't dismiss opposition quickly
- Mitch Marsh not bowling effectively
- Question: Does Marsh merit top-six place purely as batsman?
- Alternative: Bring in Webster as like-for-like (better bowler than Marsh, can score runs)
Adelaide Conditions and Factors
- Australia has fantastic record at Adelaide Oval
- Australia understands day-night conditions better than anyone
- Scott Boland has fantastic record there
- Hazlewood's absence will be missed enormously - could be defining factor
Series Implications
- Pre-Perth: Australia were overwhelming favorites
- Current assessment: If India wins Adelaide, series likely decided
- India victory would secure place in World Test Championship final
- India currently on the ascendancy
- Warning: India must not allow Australia to do what India did in 2021 after 36 all-out
- India going into game as favorites, but recent cricket shows that means nothing
