AI summary by TwinMind

Has Protein Folding Been Solved?

Sabine Hossenfelder

12m 1s

Introduction to Protein Folding Problem

  • Protein folding = biggest problem in biochemistry, holy grail of drug development
  • Headlines proclaimed AI solved protein folding last year
  • Question: was it really solved and what does this mean?

What Are Proteins and Why They Matter

  • Proteins = major building blocks of living tissue (e.g., muscles)
  • Bewildering number of variants and functions throughout biology
  • Key functions:
    • Antibodies fighting infections
    • Organ communication
    • Tissue repair
    • Complex molecular pumping in/out of cells
    • Substance transport using walking-like motions

Protein Structure and Folding Mechanics

  • Proteins = chains of smaller molecules called amino acids
  • Long loose chains unstable → fold and curl into stable 3D shape
  • Protein folding problem = determining stable shape(s) of proteins
  • Function depends on shape
  • Mutations → amino acid sequence changes → wrong folding → loss of function → severe illness

Diseases Caused by Misfolded Proteins

  • Type 2 diabetes
  • Alzheimer's
  • Parkinson's
  • ALS (Stephen Hawking's disease)
  • Understanding folding essential for disease mechanisms and potential cures

Benefits of Understanding Protein Folding

  • Easier synthetic protein production with desired functions
  • Time and cost savings in research
  • Enable development of specialized proteins

The Computational Challenge

  • Hideously difficult problem due to exponential possibilities
  • Amino acid chains long with many folding directions
  • Cyrus Leventhal (1960s): typical protein could fold in >10^140 ways
  • Number depends on protein size:
    • Small proteins: ~10^50 possible foldings
    • Large proteins: mind-blowing 10^300 possible foldings
  • Trying all possibilities clearly not feasible

Key Scientific Discovery (1950s-1972)

  • Scientists found protein shape determined by amino acid sequence under controlled conditions
  • Usually true in natural environment too
  • Nobel Prize for Chemistry awarded 1972 for this discovery
  • Natural selection preferentially used molecules that reliably fold same way
  • Exceptions exist:
    • Prions (mad cow disease) have several stable shapes
    • Proteins can change shape when environment changes

Approaches to Solving Protein Folding

  • Two main approaches:
    • Top-down: model why proteins fold one way vs another
    • Bottom-up: observe large numbers of protein folding, extract regularities
  • Both require examples of folded protein structures

Experimental Methods for Protein Structure

  • X-ray crystallography:
    • Fire X-ray beams at crystallized proteins
    • Measure ray scattering patterns
    • Infer 3D shape from atomic positions
    • Problem: some proteins take months/years to crystallize
  • Cryo-electron microscopy:
    • Uses electron microscopy on deep frozen proteins
    • Recently much improved situation
    • Gives much better resolution

CASP Competition Overview

  • Founded 1994 to track protein folding prediction progress
  • Critical Assessment of Protein Structure Prediction (CASP)
  • Competition among research teams every 2 years
  • Teams given amino acid sequences, predict folding shapes
  • Uses experimentally measured but unpublished protein structures
  • Predictions compared with real shapes using Global Distance Test (GDT)
  • GDT scoring: 0% = total failure, 100% = perfect score
  • Each team gets average score across all predictions

CASP Competition Progress

  • First 20 years: slow progress
  • No one scored >40% until recent years
  • AI/deep learning teams emerged (about half of teams in recent competition)
  • Deep learning = neural networks trained on large datasets to recognize patterns

DeepMind's AlphaFold Breakthrough

  • DeepMind = British company acquired by Google 2014, now part of Alphabet
  • Same company behind AlphaGo (first to beat professional Go player 2015)
  • AlphaFold protein folding program results:
    • 2018: AlphaFold scored ~60% in CASP
    • 2020: AlphaFold 2 reached ~90%
  • Made big headlines, many outlets claimed protein folding "solved"

Criticisms and Limitations

  • 90% still significant failure rate
  • Struggles with most interesting cases:
    • Protein complexes (oligomers)
    • Cases where several amino acids interact
  • General AI limitation: can only learn patterns from training data
  • If entirely new functions don't appear in dataset, may remain undiscovered
  • Still needs experimental data/measurements to train AI

Future Implications and Applications

  • Remarkable achievement and amazing progress
  • May save scientists time-consuming and expensive experiments
  • Could help develop proteins with specific functions
  • Wish list applications:
    • Proteins stimulating immune system to fight cancer
    • Universal flu vaccine
    • Proteins that break down plastics

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome