AI summary by TwinMind
Has the U.S. Presidency Become a Dictatorship? (Update) | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
47m 0s
Introduction and Context
- Steven Dubner introduces two-part series on Presidential Power
- Episode recorded autumn 2016, end of Obama's second term, months before Trump-Clinton election
- Features University of Chicago legal scholar Eric Posner
- Part two to include new conversation about past 8 years of presidency and election betting markets
Constitutional Framework and Founding Intentions
- Founding fathers' goal: powerful government for protection/commerce while preventing power abuse
- James Madison's vision: three-branch system with checks and balances
- Constitution extremely vague on presidential role - only mentions "executive power" without definition
- Founders drew from Roman Republic model but wanted to avoid emperor/dictator outcome
- System designed to allow decisive executive action while blocking excessive power accumulation
Historical Evolution of Presidential Power
Early Presidents Setting Precedents
- George Washington: expected to set precedents given constitutional vagueness
- Thomas Jefferson: Louisiana Purchase - widely regarded as unconstitutional, even by Jefferson himself
- Abraham Lincoln:
- Suspended habeas corpus (only Congress constitutionally allowed to do this)
- Impounded funds inappropriately
- Ruled much of country under martial law during Civil War
- Actions justified by wartime emergency but created lasting precedents
Modern Presidential Expansion
- Theodore Roosevelt: introduced "bully pulpit" concept, president as primary domestic policy figure
- Woodrow Wilson:
- Believed parliamentary systems superior to presidential systems
- Initiated modern administrative state
- Expanded bureaucratic rule-making under presidential control
- Franklin Roosevelt:
- Served more than two terms (violated Washington precedent)
- Vastly expanded federal bureaucracy through New Deal
- Created "delegations of power" - Congress passing laws telling president to "figure out" implementation
- Essentially functioned as dictator during WWII
- Changes became permanent post-war
Modern Administrative State
- Executive branch grew from "basically a post office" to 3 million employees
- Congress delegated much lawmaking authority to presidential agencies
- Congress too small/fragmented to exert consistent control over executive agencies
- Environmental laws example: Congress said "do something about pollution" rather than specific mandates
- Supreme Court initially resisted but eventually acquiesced to this system
Post-WWII Foreign Policy Powers
- Presidents gained broad unilateral authority over CIA (coups in Iran, Guatemala, Congo, Dominican Republic, South Vietnam, Chile)
- All wars since WWII conducted without formal Congressional declarations
- 1973 War Powers Act passed over Nixon's veto but largely ineffective
- Every president since has called War Powers Act unconstitutional
- Presidents regularly deploy military without Congressional authorization (Reagan in Grenada/Lebanon, Bush in Panama/Somalia, Clinton in Serbia/Somalia/Afghanistan, Obama in Libya)
Obama's Specific Expansions of Power
Prosecutorial Discretion Innovation
- Used enforcement discretion on unprecedented scale
- Immigration: attempted to provide legal status to ~5 million illegal immigrants
- Justified as presidential discretion in law enforcement
- Blocked by Texas court, upheld by Supreme Court
Policy Achievements Through Administrative Power
- Economic stimulus/financial regulation: obtained Congressional laws but used questionable administrative powers for crisis response
- Healthcare (ACA): got Congressional statute but aggressively used administrative powers for implementation, delayed rollouts for political reasons
- Carbon emissions: failed to get Congressional statute, used existing Clean Air Act for regulations
- Counterterrorism: used Bush-era Congressional authorizations, expanded drone strikes including against American citizens
Executive Orders and Congressional Bypass
- Obama averaged 14 executive orders per 4-year term
- Used administrative powers when Congress turned hostile
- Saturday Night Live parodied this with "I'm an executive order and I pretty much just happen"
Constitutional vs Political Constraints
- Traditional constitutional constraints (Congress, courts) largely ineffective
- Congress has acquiesced to presidential power expansion
- Courts highly deferential on important issues
- Real constraints come from:
- Leading three different groups: country, party, executive branch
- Need for subordinate cooperation
- Requirement for popular support
- Party cooperation needs
- Example: Guantanamo Bay closure blocked by both parties despite presidential desire
Dodd-Frank and ACA as Power Expansions
- Both laws gave president "enormous discretionary authority" over financial and health sectors
- Future policy decisions shift from Congress to presidential persuasion
- Madison wouldn't have recognized this system
- Founders specifically rejected administrative government models (like France)
Democrats vs Republicans on Presidential Power
- Democrats wrong about Obama being stymied - he accomplished "huge amount"
- Obama got most of what he wanted through statutes + administrative powers
- Could have been more ambitious (public option, stronger Dodd-Frank) but realistic given political constraints
- Carter considered weak partly for being "too scrupulous about law and constitution"
Trump's Potential Powers (2016 Predictions)
- Immigration: could ban Muslims using existing statutory authority giving president power to block entry for "national interest"
- Trade: can tear up treaties unilaterally
- Military alliances: could abandon NATO, refuse to defend allies
- Could create new alliances (e.g., with Russia) without Senate involvement
- Obama made Iran agreement and Paris climate accord without Senate despite constitutional treaty requirements
- Limited by inability to affect Americans' domestic rights/obligations
Dictatorship Question
- Posner agrees presidency moving toward dictatorship but prefers term "presidential primacy"
- Different from Hitler-style dictatorship because president still needs:
- Political support
- Subordinate cooperation
- Press/public support
- More like Roman dictator (temporary emergency powers) than modern totalitarian dictator
- Administrative state headed by president but with continuing political constraints
Future Implications
- Obama worried about expanding presidential power for future presidents but did it anyway for immediate objectives
- Risk that precedents could be misused (e.g., if Trump refused to enforce corporate taxes)
- System depends on political backlash preventing extreme actions
- Presidents can "destroy the world" or make "crazy alliances" until impeached or replaced
