AI summary by TwinMind
Heroku Is Dead, Here's What I Recommend
Theo - t3․gg
11m 58s
Heroku's Demise and Impact
- Heroku killed free tier entirely, making it no longer viable for new applications
- Was first easy server deployment solution - take code, throw at them, runs for free
- Before Heroku: required extensive systems knowledge just to run code elsewhere
- Created whole new level of hobbyist developers, essential for many starting developers
- Still regularly recommended for new apps (shouldn't be, but was)
- Heroku's goals no longer align with improving new greenfield application development
Three Main Heroku Use Cases
- Running Docker images (most common)
- Hosting websites
- Database hosting
Docker Image Hosting Solutions
Easy Tier
- Railway (speaker's favorite, closest to standard Heroku replacement)
- Super fast deployment: point at GitHub repo
- Auto-detects: Node.js, Next.js, Docker images
- Free tier: 500 hours/month box running
- Developer tier: $5/month free credit
- Running box whole month: ~$2/month
- Speaker's go-to for quick box spinning
Medium Tier
- Render (render.com)
- All-in-one approach: website hosting + static deployment + images
- Specialty: hosting images
- Jack-of-all-trades mindset
- Somewhere between Heroku and AWS in complexity
- Fly.io
- Focus: crazy infrastructure + region management
- Easy multi-region deployment worldwide
- Best for: Postgres clustering with global replicas, images spinning globally
- Calls it "edge" (still region-based, not true edge)
- Better cold start times than Lambda (but not much better)
Hard Tier
- AWS, GCP for self-hosting
- More work to figure out
- Higher risk of accidental charges
- Lower costs (other solutions built on top of AWS with markup)
Website Hosting Solutions
Easy Tier
- Vercel (easiest by far)
- Netlify
- GitHub Pages (limited but works)
Medium Tier
- Render (less valuable/viable in this space)
- Cloudflare (torn between medium/hard classification)
Hard Tier
- AWS, GCP for self-hosting
Database Solutions
Easy Tier
- Railway (click once, get started)
- Demo: Created Postgres database without even signing in
- Free DB created instantly with connection URL
- Easiest database spin-up
Medium Tier
- PlanetScale (speaker's top recommendation)
- Cockroach (speaker's top recommendation)
- Supabase (less scalable than others)
- Atlas (not super scalable)
Hard Tier
- AWS, GCP for self-hosting
Additional Considerations
- WebSockets: Not ideal Heroku use case, falls under Docker image category
- Alternatives: Pusher, Ably, LiveBlocks (promising)
- Deno Deploy: Good if already using Deno ecosystem, otherwise feels weird
- DigitalOcean: Fine option but speaker prefers newer alternatives
- Flight Control: Interesting but very early stage
Overall Philosophy
- Website hosting: okay to outsource since infra hard but not core focus
- Treat Heroku's death as opportunity to explore new solutions rather than crisis
- Many awesome new options available for full-stack applications
