AI summary by TwinMind

Hongxin: China’s Billion Dollar Semiconductor Failure

Asianometry

13m 25s

China's Semiconductor Dependency & National Response

  • China imports $300B+ semiconductors annually
  • Reliant on chip technology imports for high-tech products
  • Recognized as potential economic weakness
  • 2014: Launched $20B national fund for domestic chip industry development
  • Government goal: cutting-edge chip manufacturing within few years
  • Willing to spend "almost whatever it takes" for homegrown industry

HSMC Company Formation & Ambitious Claims

  • Founded November 2017 as Wuhan Hongxing Semiconductor Manufacturing (HSMC/Hong Shin)
  • Target: 30,000 wafers/month capacity
    • 14nm process node initially
    • 7nm process node planned
  • Capacity would match TSMC mega fabs in scale
  • Comparison: TSMC Fab 18 produces 100,000 wafers/month, built in 2.5 years

Key Credibility Moves

  • July 2019: Hired Chang Shan Yi as CEO
    • Former TSMC R&D VP, 75 years old
    • Independent director at SMIC 2016-2019
    • Legitimate chip manufacturing expert
  • December 2019: Purchased ASML TwinScan XT 1980 DUV lithography scanner
    • Cost: 581M RMB ($87M USD)
    • Theoretically enables 10nm chip etching
    • Claimed only device in China for 7nm chips (false claim)
    • One month later: Used as collateral for bank loan
    • Bank statement: Device "new and never used"

Government Funding & Investment

  • September 2018: Wuhan featured 33 high-tech manufacturing projects
  • Total Wuhan investment: $16B across projects
  • HSMC + one other company received 80% of $16B
  • HSMC received largest portion from Wuhan:
    • 636 acres of land
    • 636,000 sq meter building under construction
    • Total project cost: 128B RMB ($20B USD)
    • Promised 3,000 high-value jobs
  • End 2019: Received $2B from Wuhan city government
  • 2020: Expected additional $1B
  • Never received full $20B as planned

Talent Acquisition Strategy

  • Joined race for Taiwanese semiconductor talent
  • Offered 2-2.5x market rate salaries for TSMC R&D employees
  • Poached ~100 people from TSMC

Financial Problems Begin

  • July 2020: Construction subcontractor Wuhan Juanyu Foundation Engineering
    • Accused HSMC of not paying $5M in bills
    • Took company to court for payment

Ownership Structure Revealed

  • HSMC 90% owned by shell company
  • Controlled by two individuals:
    • Lee Shi Yen: No semiconductor experience
      • Owns Chinese liquor retailer, catering companies, medical companies
    • Tao Shen
  • Shell company invested no money into HSMC
  • Funding sources:
    • Local Wuhan government
    • Loans from construction subcontractors

Escalating Financial Crisis

  • Wages not being paid
  • Job offers rescinded/delayed
  • Bank accounts frozen
  • Provincial court reclaimed 300 acres land usage rights due to unpaid bills

Financial Discrepancies

  • Claimed billions received from Wuhan government
  • Unable to pay $5M to construction subcontractor
  • $87M TwinScan machine immediately remortgaged
  • Unclear where $3B+ funding actually went

Business Model Analysis

  • "Silicon Valley bootstrap" approach using other people's money
  • Strategy: String along based on hype and local government cash
  • Local officials easily "bamboozled with fancy words"
  • Promise of having TSMC equivalent in their city
  • Similar to Wisconsin Foxconn situation
  • Local governments lack sufficient cash, only provide:
    • Land usage rights (not liquid cash)
    • Small grants
  • Goal: Access central government's national semiconductor fund

Company Collapse

  • December 2019 court case prevented national semiconductor fund application
  • COVID-19 pandemic ended project completely
  • Plants fell through

Founder's Next Ventures

  • Tao Shen exited HSMC, started new companies:
    • Zhuhai Yi Shin Integrated Technology
    • Hired ex-TSMC person Xia Jingcho as CEO
    • Set up Quanxing Integrated Circuit Manufacturing
    • Set up Yunxin International Integrated Circuit Manufacturing
  • Same model repeated with different local governments
  • Pattern: Promise TSMC equivalent to different cities for funding

Other Chinese Semiconductor Failures

  • 2019: Hwai Semiconductor (Jiangsu Province)
    • Collapsed under unpaid wages and lawsuits
    • $700M investment, $14M+ debt
  • July 2020: Dakema (Nanjing) bankruptcy
    • Raised $3B from investors including municipal government
    • Built indigenous image sensors
    • Result: Two unfinished buildings, zero wafers produced

China's Tech Market Fever Pattern

  • Historical precedents: Ride-sharing wars (Uber vs DD), bike-sharing wars
  • Similar fever rolling over semiconductor manufacturing
  • SMIC public listing: 100% stock price explosion first day
  • Building campuses with Korean/Taiwan accommodations for poached engineers
  • Hundreds of chip engineers planned to be poached from Samsung/TSMC

Industry Analysis & Recommendations

  • Semiconductor manufacturing requires:
    • Serious national-level resources
    • "Mount Kilimanjaro" of cash
    • Base of expertise
    • Infinite patience
    • Extensive talent building
  • Timeline: Not achievable in 2, 5, or even 10 years
  • Singapore case study: Government lost interest, foundry industry stagnated
  • China should study Singapore's lessons
  • Common failure theme: Founders want fast in-and-out results
  • Example: Pinduoduo (founded 2015/2016, $1B company in 2 years, CEO retired after 4 years)
  • Fast approach causes mistakes, acceptable for many industries but not semiconductors
  • Formula for fast failure in semiconductor manufacturing

Conclusion Assessment

  • Uncertain if HSMC was fraud or legitimate failure
  • Possible scenarios:
    • Took $500M, hired people, built PR, attempted building, kept $1.5B
    • Legitimately tried rapid growth and failed
  • Chinese government claims increased focus on vetting
  • Result: Wasted taxpayer money, lost time, hype leading to nothing

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome