AI summary by TwinMind

Hope Edelman | The Aftergrief: Finding Your Way Along the Long Arc of Loss | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

57m 21s

Introduction & Author Background

  • Hope Edelman author of 8 non-fiction books including bestsellers "Motherless Daughters" and "Motherless Mothers"
  • Recipient of 2020 Community Educator Award for Association for Deaf Education and Counseling
  • Certified Martha Beck life coach, facilitates motherless daughters retreats globally
  • Lives in Los Angeles and Iowa City
  • Mother died at age 42 from breast cancer when Hope was 17 (1981)
  • Father died when Hope was 40
  • New book: "The After Grief: Finding Your Way Along the Long Arc of Loss"

Defining After Grief vs Traditional Grief Models

  • Quote from Elizabeth Kubler-Ross: "Loss happens in time, in fact in a moment, but its aftermath lasts a lifetime"
  • Traditional grief (new grief): acute symptoms 6 months to 2 years - shock, numbness, horror, sleeplessness
  • After grief: long-term phase after acute grief ends, characterized by ebb/flow, expansion/contraction
  • Can last rest of our lives with periodic upswells/spikes/surges
  • No vocabulary existed for this long-term experience

Historical Context of "Getting Over It" Mentality

  • Early 20th century factors created linear grief model:
    • World War I mass carnage
    • Freud's influential 1917 paper
    • Spanish flu pandemic 1918-19
    • Women's suffrage movement
    • Victorian mourning rituals abandoned/contracted
  • Five stages of grief misapplied from Kubler-Ross's work
  • 1980s-1990s: therapists noticed "letting go" approach caused distress
  • Mid-late 90s: shift toward continuing bonds theory
  • Culture slow to adopt new understanding

Research Methodology & Approach

  • Northwestern journalism school background, minor in cultural anthropology
  • Master's in non-fiction writing, University of Iowa
  • Qualitative interviews vs quantitative data
  • 81 in-depth interviews for "The After Grief"
  • Multiple file cabinets of research articles
  • Ethnographic interview approach - people as experts of their own stories
  • Listened for patterns across interviews

Cultural & Individual Variations in Grief

  • Grief extremely culturally relative
  • Ranges from weeks-long funeral processes to cultures that stop saying deceased's name
  • Male vs female grieving patterns:
    • Female: emoting, reaching out, talking, connecting
    • Male: action-oriented, doing, building, problem-solving
  • Example: Hindu culture - men handle cremation/funeral tasks, women in designated mourning room with community support
  • Grief-prone personalities exist - more attuned to certain emotions, predisposed to anxiety/depression
  • Siblings respond differently even to same loss due to temperament

Personal Connection & Continuing Bonds

  • Hope keeps mother present through:
    • Day lilies in parents' wedding vase on dining room table
    • Wedding picture on kitchen wall
    • Living by values parents instilled
    • Sister has mother's picture in kitchen corner (based on medium's suggestion)
  • DNA connection with birth parents creates powerful bond
  • Adoptive parents provide years of values and experience
  • Impossible and harmful to "let go" completely

COVID-19 & Collective Grief

  • Book finished June 2020 during quarantine
  • Part of 90-person bereavement task force meeting weekly on Zoom
  • Mirror image of 1918-19 Spanish flu pandemic
  • Mourning rituals eliminated again - no funerals, memorials, bedside presence
  • Victorian elaborate rituals lost in 1918-19 never returned
  • Hope for hybrid model: in-person gatherings plus livestreaming for broader community access

Youth Bereavement Statistics & Characteristics

  • 1 in 7 American adults (14%, 30 million people) lost parent/sibling before age 20
  • Children mourn in bits and pieces over lifetime
  • Process different pieces as intellectual/emotional development occurs
  • 5-year-old doesn't understand future implications (wedding, graduation)
  • May have grief responses at ages 10-12, teenage years, when reaching age deceased was
  • Adults must connect dots for children - may not recognize delayed grief responses
  • Protracted grief normal for childhood losses

Types of Grief Classification

  • New grief: acute phase right after death, 6 months to 2 years
  • Old grief: response in present to loss in past (anniversaries, holidays, birthdays)
  • New old grief: experiencing old loss in completely new way after reaching milestone
    • Example: grieving mother's absence as grandmother only after having own children
    • Cannot pre-grieve these experiences

Three Rings of Grief Model

  • Developed when couldn't find long-term grief models
  • Target/bullseye visual:
    • Inner ring: tight circle of emotional pain during grief spikes
    • Middle ring: everyday optimal functioning
    • Outer ring: growth - knowledge, insight, wisdom, gratitude, appreciation
  • Can move between rings based on trigger events
  • Growth ring where people become better parents, start foundations, run races for causes
  • Post-traumatic growth concept: trauma becomes springboard for personal development

Difficult Relationships & Complicated Grief

  • 15% of population experiences complicated grief
  • Ambivalent relationships create ambivalent grief
  • Grieving loss of hope for relationship change/improvement
  • Loss of possibility person would get help for mental health/addiction
  • Important to accept yourself wherever you are in grief process
  • Trained counselors available for complicated grief
  • Some people don't cry - doesn't mean wrong grief style

Traumatic Grief (Suicide/Homicide)

  • Different from other grief forms - among hardest adjustments
  • Trauma around violence/sudden death
  • Trauma must be stabilized before grief processing
  • Story of death can overtake story of person's life
  • Reaffirming relationship meaning helps access grief work

Anticipatory Grief & Dementia

  • Process when knowing someone will die
  • Releasing attachments to future assumptions
  • Dementia: losing person before physical death
  • May feel relief/resignation at actual death after long anticipation
  • Finality still impactful despite preparation

Resilience & Personal Agency

  • Resilience: faith/hope to face each day knowing random bad things happen, believing you'll survive if they do
  • More choice in after grief phase than acute grief
  • Choice over meaning-making and purpose development
  • Agency over seeking support, therapy, community
  • Can choose how to show up in world as someone with loss experience

Practical Applications & Resources

  • Importance of revisiting/revising loss stories over time
  • Meaning changes at different life stages
  • Story development phase: piecing together what happened for emotional/intellectual completion
  • After grief community page on Facebook
  • Online programs and aftergrief.com resources
  • Modern Loss community literacy about long-term grief

Stephen Colbert Quote & Philosophy

  • Lost father and two older brothers at age 10 in plane crash
  • "Learning to love the thing you most wish had not happened"
  • Best example of post-traumatic growth and resilience
  • Takes time to settle into this understanding

Children & Modeling Grief

  • Important for children to see appropriate emotional expression
  • Models that sadness after death is normal
  • Balance needed - don't threaten children's security
  • Have adult support system for intense grief moments
  • Not one-and-done conversation - can revisit with children as they mature
  • Mistakes in grief parenting can be addressed later

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome