AI summary by TwinMind

How AI Models Steal Creative Work — and What to Do About It | Ed Newton-Rex | TED

TED

15m 7s

AI Development Resource Requirements

  • Three key resources needed for AI models: people, compute, data
    • Engineers to build models: up to $1M per engineer
    • GPUs for training: up to $1B per model
    • Training data: currently taken for free without permission

Current Unlicensed Training Practices

  • AI companies use web scrapers to gather content without licensing
  • Mozilla Foundation study (2019-2023): 47 large language models analyzed
    • 64% trained on Common Crawl dataset containing copyrighted works
    • 21% didn't reveal enough information to determine training sources
  • Training on copyrighted work without licenses now standard industry practice

Competition Between AI and Training Data

  • Generative AI directly competes with content it's trained on
  • Examples of competitive displacement:
    • Large language models trained on short stories create competing stories
    • AI music models create competing music for TV licensing
    • Ram Gopal Varma filmmaker switching to AI music for all projects
    • AI song reached #48 in German charts
    • Kelly McKernan artist: 33% income drop overnight after AI trained on their work
  • Upwork platform analysis post-ChatGPT:
    • 8% reduction in freelance writing demand
    • 18% reduction for lower-value writing tasks

Legal Framework and Fair Use Debate

  • Copyright law grants creators exclusive right to authorize copies
  • AI training involves copying copyrighted works
  • US AI companies claim fair use exception applies
  • Creators/rights holders strongly disagree with fair use interpretation
  • ~30 ongoing lawsuits between rights holders and AI companies
  • Legal outcomes still pending, creators suffering immediate harm

Arguments Against Licensing Requirements

  • Fair use legal exception claims
  • Human learning comparison argument
    • Humans learn from copyrighted work without licenses
    • Counter-argument: fundamental differences in scale and purpose
    • AI creates "highly scalable competitor" to copied content
    • AI image generators: 2.5M images/day estimated output
    • AI song generators: 10 songs/second output
  • Impracticality claims regarding licensing costs and feasibility

Available Licensing Solutions and Data Sources

  • Licensed data from media companies: 27 major deals in past year
  • Training data marketplaces
  • Public domain data: Common Corpus 500B-word dataset
  • Synthetic data created by AI models
  • Multiple companies successfully licensing all training data

Fairly Trained Certification Program

  • Nonprofit certifying AI companies that license all training data
  • Launched January 2024, 18 companies certified
  • Various licensing approaches:
    • Individual voice licensing for AI voice models
    • 40+ music catalog licenses for AI music models
    • Public domain-only training (government documents)
    • Upfront fees and revenue sharing models
  • Smaller startups leading licensing adoption, not just big companies

Web Closure Due to Unlicensed Training

  • Data Provenance Initiative study: 14,000 websites in AI training sets
  • Single year analysis of highest-value domains for AI training
  • Restriction increases: 3% to 20-33% via opt-outs/terms of service
  • Gradual web closure harming new AI models, researchers, consumers

Public Opinion on AI Training

  • AI Policy Institute poll (April):
    • 60% oppose training on publicly available data vs 19% support
    • 74% support compensating data providers vs 9% oppose
  • Consistent public support for permission and payment requirements
  • Rejection of "publicly available = fair game" notion

Creator Opposition Movement

  • "Statement on AI Training" launched: 11,000+ creator signatures
  • Signatories include Nobel authors, Academy Award actors, Oscar composers
  • Available at aitrainingstatement.org
  • Statement: "Unlicensed use of creative works for training generative AI is major, unjust threat to livelihoods...must not be permitted"

Path Forward for Industry Cooperation

  • Current state: many creators "straight-up hate generative AI"
  • Licensing enables mutually beneficial AI-creative industry relationship
  • Requires respect for work value and creator rights
  • Licensing slows short-term development but reaches same capability endpoints
  • Prevents publisher restrictions and creator antagonism
  • Potential for symbiotic coexistence between AI and human creativity

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome