AI summary by TwinMind
How Airlines Decide Where to Fly
Wendover Productions
11m 55s
Airline Route Profitability Examples
- British Airways London Heathrow to New York JFK route earns over $1 billion/year
- More than any airline makes on any other route worldwide
- American Airlines Chicago to Beijing route canceled
- Losing tens of millions of dollars annually
- Route between world's 50th and 7th largest cities
- Used 787 Dreamliner (smallest possible plane for route)
- $80 million away from annual revenue target
2015 Route Launch Analysis - Big Three US Airlines
- American, Delta, United launched 101 new routes total
- Range from 30-minute regional (Chicago-Kalamazoo) to trans-pacific (LA-Shanghai)
- Delta: 70% of 2015 routes still operating
- Failed routes: Orlando-São Paulo, New York-Manchester, Philadelphia-London
- American: 76% survival rate
- Failed routes: Dallas-Quito, Miami-Frankfurt, New York-Birmingham
- United: 85% survival rate (highest)
- Only 4 failed routes: Houston-Peoria, Newark-Newcastle, Dulles-Millane, Denver-San Jose
United Airlines Route Planning Success
- Sole US airline serving multiple destinations:
- Long-haul: Melbourne, Tahiti, Taipei, Chengdu, Delhi, Mumbai, Naples, Porto, Stockholm
- Routes without non-stop competition:
- Denver-Tokyo, Houston-Rio de Janeiro, DC-Zurich, Chicago-Edinburgh
- Many risky routes survived for years
Route Planning Decision Factors
- Two major factors per United:
- How many people want to go there
- How much they're willing to pay
- Data sources for passenger demand:
- Internal data from existing hub connections
- Travel booking sites (Expedia, Google Flights, Skyscanner)
- Sell search data to market research companies and airlines
- Search volume examples from Skyscanner:
- Birmingham-Hong Kong: 190,000 searches/year
- Delhi-Auckland: 420,000 searches/year
- Bangkok-Barcelona: 1.1 million searches/year
- London-Kochi: 1.4 million searches/year
Pricing Competition Challenges
- United LA-Singapore route (October 2017):
- Airline's longest route ever
- Only non-stop between cities
- Canceled after exactly one year
- Competing connecting flights: $444
- United couldn't match competitor pricing
- Similar issue with American Chicago-Beijing route
- Couldn't compete with Asian airline low fares
- Planes crossing Pacific empty
Route Profitability Analysis
- United Singapore routes: $800 round-trip, 16-hour flight (4 planes used for 2 daily flights)
- United DC-London: $800 round-trip, 6-hour flight
- Airlines must consider opportunity cost of aircraft deployment
Market Dynamics - Australia-China Example
- Australian airlines to mainland China: 3 routes
- Qantas: Sydney-Beijing, Sydney-Shanghai
- Jetstar: Melbourne-Zhengzhou
- Chinese airlines to Australia: 43 routes
- Imbalance due to:
- Passenger preference for home country airlines
- More Chinese traveling to Australia than vice versa
- Chinese airlines' lower labor costs enabling lower fares
Competitive Route Strategy
- Dallas-Reykjavik route announcements (September 2017):
- WOW Air announced first (September 6)
- Iceland Air followed (less than week later)
- American Airlines announced (month later)
- American's defensive strategy:
- Protect Dallas fortress hub market share
- Prevent customer loss to competitors for Europe connections
- Route doesn't make independent financial sense
- Requires east coast passengers to backtrack through Dallas
- Both competitors eventually stopped Dallas service
Operational Requirements for New Routes
- Aircraft availability:
- From route cancellations
- New aircraft deliveries
- Example: United San Francisco-Tahiti
- Required smallest long-haul plane (787-8 Dreamliner)
- Became available when new 777-9 replaced older 777 on SF-Munich route
- Gate space at busy airports
- Government approval for international routes
- Timeline: Usually years from analysis to first flight
Route Evaluation Process
- Continuous cycle: planning → launching → evaluating
- Performance measured by profitability
- Keep profitable routes, cancel unprofitable ones
- Reality always includes unforeseen variables
- True test is actual flight operations
