AI summary by TwinMind

How Airlines Decide Where to Fly

Wendover Productions

11m 55s

Airline Route Profitability Examples

  • British Airways London Heathrow to New York JFK route earns over $1 billion/year
    • More than any airline makes on any other route worldwide
  • American Airlines Chicago to Beijing route canceled
    • Losing tens of millions of dollars annually
    • Route between world's 50th and 7th largest cities
    • Used 787 Dreamliner (smallest possible plane for route)
    • $80 million away from annual revenue target

2015 Route Launch Analysis - Big Three US Airlines

  • American, Delta, United launched 101 new routes total
    • Range from 30-minute regional (Chicago-Kalamazoo) to trans-pacific (LA-Shanghai)
  • Delta: 70% of 2015 routes still operating
    • Failed routes: Orlando-São Paulo, New York-Manchester, Philadelphia-London
  • American: 76% survival rate
    • Failed routes: Dallas-Quito, Miami-Frankfurt, New York-Birmingham
  • United: 85% survival rate (highest)
    • Only 4 failed routes: Houston-Peoria, Newark-Newcastle, Dulles-Millane, Denver-San Jose

United Airlines Route Planning Success

  • Sole US airline serving multiple destinations:
    • Long-haul: Melbourne, Tahiti, Taipei, Chengdu, Delhi, Mumbai, Naples, Porto, Stockholm
  • Routes without non-stop competition:
    • Denver-Tokyo, Houston-Rio de Janeiro, DC-Zurich, Chicago-Edinburgh
  • Many risky routes survived for years

Route Planning Decision Factors

  • Two major factors per United:
    • How many people want to go there
    • How much they're willing to pay
  • Data sources for passenger demand:
    • Internal data from existing hub connections
    • Travel booking sites (Expedia, Google Flights, Skyscanner)
      • Sell search data to market research companies and airlines
  • Search volume examples from Skyscanner:
    • Birmingham-Hong Kong: 190,000 searches/year
    • Delhi-Auckland: 420,000 searches/year
    • Bangkok-Barcelona: 1.1 million searches/year
    • London-Kochi: 1.4 million searches/year

Pricing Competition Challenges

  • United LA-Singapore route (October 2017):
    • Airline's longest route ever
    • Only non-stop between cities
    • Canceled after exactly one year
    • Competing connecting flights: $444
    • United couldn't match competitor pricing
  • Similar issue with American Chicago-Beijing route
    • Couldn't compete with Asian airline low fares
    • Planes crossing Pacific empty

Route Profitability Analysis

  • United Singapore routes: $800 round-trip, 16-hour flight (4 planes used for 2 daily flights)
  • United DC-London: $800 round-trip, 6-hour flight
  • Airlines must consider opportunity cost of aircraft deployment

Market Dynamics - Australia-China Example

  • Australian airlines to mainland China: 3 routes
    • Qantas: Sydney-Beijing, Sydney-Shanghai
    • Jetstar: Melbourne-Zhengzhou
  • Chinese airlines to Australia: 43 routes
  • Imbalance due to:
    • Passenger preference for home country airlines
    • More Chinese traveling to Australia than vice versa
    • Chinese airlines' lower labor costs enabling lower fares

Competitive Route Strategy

  • Dallas-Reykjavik route announcements (September 2017):
    • WOW Air announced first (September 6)
    • Iceland Air followed (less than week later)
    • American Airlines announced (month later)
  • American's defensive strategy:
    • Protect Dallas fortress hub market share
    • Prevent customer loss to competitors for Europe connections
    • Route doesn't make independent financial sense
    • Requires east coast passengers to backtrack through Dallas
    • Both competitors eventually stopped Dallas service

Operational Requirements for New Routes

  • Aircraft availability:
    • From route cancellations
    • New aircraft deliveries
  • Example: United San Francisco-Tahiti
    • Required smallest long-haul plane (787-8 Dreamliner)
    • Became available when new 777-9 replaced older 777 on SF-Munich route
  • Gate space at busy airports
  • Government approval for international routes
  • Timeline: Usually years from analysis to first flight

Route Evaluation Process

  • Continuous cycle: planning → launching → evaluating
  • Performance measured by profitability
  • Keep profitable routes, cancel unprofitable ones
  • Reality always includes unforeseen variables
  • True test is actual flight operations

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome