AI summary by TwinMind
How America Got Hooked On Useless Corporate Consulting
How Money Works
13m 11s
Introduction: Consultant vs Civil Servant Incentives
- Consultants operate on business/profit logic vs civil servants' public service logic
- Private consulting firms prioritize profits over public good
- Impact on inequality - "eating at the soul of this country"
- Old saying: "people who can't do teach, people who can't teach consult"
Types of Consultants
- Legitimate specialized consultants: narrow expertise (e.g., payment processing systems)
- Set up specific systems, train company staff, leave
- Often cheaper with less downtime than internal hiring
- May not call themselves "consultants" depending on specialization
- Management consultants: the problematic group
- Big Three: Bain, Boston Consulting Group, McKinsey & Company
- Make billions annually advising executives/government leaders
- Senior management challenges always unique, firms may lack real expertise
Management Consulting Process
- Brought in short-term to fix problems, launch projects, streamline operations
- Given access to company operations, interview employees/customers
- Deliver recommendations via slide decks with graphs/data
- Final product: recommendations, not completed projects
Three Core Problems with Management Consulting
Problem 1: Lack of Real Experience
- Management consultants have no actual experience in areas they consult on
- Regular consultants typically have long careers before consulting
- Senior managers rare, expensive, looking toward retirement not consulting
- Big Three hiring practices:
- Hire almost exclusively from universities/graduate programs
- Top students from prestigious colleges fight for acceptance
- Young graduates become analysts doing "grunt work"
- Managing directors/partners promoted from within
- "Up or out" policy: analysts not promoted after 3 years must leave
- Result: bulk of consulting done by people with no senior management or big company experience
- Cultural reasons for continuing this practice:
- Partners don't want Real World Experience challenging their expertise
- Graduates much cheaper to hire
- Management consulting based on billable hours
- McKinsey analyst compensation:
- First-year salaries: $90,000-$110,000
- Expected 80-hour weeks with stress, little job security
- Lower than investment banking/private equity/fintech alternatives
- Take jobs for exit opportunities - become highly demanded for management roles
Problem 2: Accept Any Assignment Regardless of Preparedness
- Bain, McKinsey, BCG accept no direct liability for wrong recommendations
- Worst consequence: reputational damage
- Little incentive for profit-motivated partners to refuse lucrative contracts
- Culture of overselling "infallible business acumen," figure out job after landing it
- Brexit example (2019-2020):
- British government spent ~£1 billion ($1.3 billion) on Brexit strategy consulting
- Nobody had Brexit experience - firms surveyed businesses, created reports
- Added nothing that couldn't/shouldn't have been done by elected public servants
Problem 3: Costs Much More Than Expected
- Government examples:
- British: £1.3 billion on Brexit consulting
- French: scandals involving overly generous consulting contracts
- US healthcare.gov: 55+ consulting contractors and subcontractors
- Government hired consultants who hired their own consultants
- Corporate costs: some managers spend 10% of operating budget on consultants
- Indirect costs: prevent development of in-house capabilities
- If consultants solve all problems, no need for internal teams
- Consultants reduce headcount, fire people who fix problems
- When problems arise, just hire more consultants
Three Reasons Leaders Keep Hiring Management Consultants
Reason 1: Career Benefits for Hirers
- Politicians: #1 career move after office is consulting
- Average partner salary at Bain: $527,000, some earn $1M+
- Much more than politicians make in office
- Build relationships with firms by using services while in office
- "Political corporate revolving door" - not corruption if no direct hiring understanding
- Only way politicians can monetize position without corruption charges
Reason 2: Leaders Don't Know What They're Doing
- Senior positions don't always go to most deserving people
- Consultants can tell them how to do their jobs
- Prevents exposure of being unqualified
Reason 3: Ass-Covering Tool
- "Nobody ever got fired for hiring McKinsey"
- Executives facing tough decisions hire consultants to confirm decisions
- Covers executive if decision goes badly - can't blame for insufficient due diligence
- Shareholders told poor performance due to "extenuating market conditions"
- Executives already made up minds, bring consultants to silence critics
- If successful: executive gets credit; if failed: blame consultants
- Consultants won't oppose hiring executive's vision (less likely to be rehired)
- Consultants present research, not make decisions
- Information-dense presentations open to interpretation
- Advice only worth something if it changes someone's mind
