AI summary by TwinMind

How America Got Hooked On Useless Corporate Consulting

How Money Works

13m 11s

Introduction: Consultant vs Civil Servant Incentives

  • Consultants operate on business/profit logic vs civil servants' public service logic
  • Private consulting firms prioritize profits over public good
  • Impact on inequality - "eating at the soul of this country"
  • Old saying: "people who can't do teach, people who can't teach consult"

Types of Consultants

  • Legitimate specialized consultants: narrow expertise (e.g., payment processing systems)
    • Set up specific systems, train company staff, leave
    • Often cheaper with less downtime than internal hiring
    • May not call themselves "consultants" depending on specialization
  • Management consultants: the problematic group
    • Big Three: Bain, Boston Consulting Group, McKinsey & Company
    • Make billions annually advising executives/government leaders
    • Senior management challenges always unique, firms may lack real expertise

Management Consulting Process

  • Brought in short-term to fix problems, launch projects, streamline operations
  • Given access to company operations, interview employees/customers
  • Deliver recommendations via slide decks with graphs/data
  • Final product: recommendations, not completed projects

Three Core Problems with Management Consulting

Problem 1: Lack of Real Experience

  • Management consultants have no actual experience in areas they consult on
  • Regular consultants typically have long careers before consulting
  • Senior managers rare, expensive, looking toward retirement not consulting
  • Big Three hiring practices:
    • Hire almost exclusively from universities/graduate programs
    • Top students from prestigious colleges fight for acceptance
    • Young graduates become analysts doing "grunt work"
    • Managing directors/partners promoted from within
    • "Up or out" policy: analysts not promoted after 3 years must leave
  • Result: bulk of consulting done by people with no senior management or big company experience
  • Cultural reasons for continuing this practice:
    • Partners don't want Real World Experience challenging their expertise
    • Graduates much cheaper to hire
    • Management consulting based on billable hours
  • McKinsey analyst compensation:
    • First-year salaries: $90,000-$110,000
    • Expected 80-hour weeks with stress, little job security
    • Lower than investment banking/private equity/fintech alternatives
    • Take jobs for exit opportunities - become highly demanded for management roles

Problem 2: Accept Any Assignment Regardless of Preparedness

  • Bain, McKinsey, BCG accept no direct liability for wrong recommendations
  • Worst consequence: reputational damage
  • Little incentive for profit-motivated partners to refuse lucrative contracts
  • Culture of overselling "infallible business acumen," figure out job after landing it
  • Brexit example (2019-2020):
    • British government spent ~£1 billion ($1.3 billion) on Brexit strategy consulting
    • Nobody had Brexit experience - firms surveyed businesses, created reports
    • Added nothing that couldn't/shouldn't have been done by elected public servants

Problem 3: Costs Much More Than Expected

  • Government examples:
    • British: £1.3 billion on Brexit consulting
    • French: scandals involving overly generous consulting contracts
    • US healthcare.gov: 55+ consulting contractors and subcontractors
    • Government hired consultants who hired their own consultants
  • Corporate costs: some managers spend 10% of operating budget on consultants
  • Indirect costs: prevent development of in-house capabilities
    • If consultants solve all problems, no need for internal teams
    • Consultants reduce headcount, fire people who fix problems
    • When problems arise, just hire more consultants

Three Reasons Leaders Keep Hiring Management Consultants

Reason 1: Career Benefits for Hirers

  • Politicians: #1 career move after office is consulting
  • Average partner salary at Bain: $527,000, some earn $1M+
  • Much more than politicians make in office
  • Build relationships with firms by using services while in office
  • "Political corporate revolving door" - not corruption if no direct hiring understanding
  • Only way politicians can monetize position without corruption charges

Reason 2: Leaders Don't Know What They're Doing

  • Senior positions don't always go to most deserving people
  • Consultants can tell them how to do their jobs
  • Prevents exposure of being unqualified

Reason 3: Ass-Covering Tool

  • "Nobody ever got fired for hiring McKinsey"
  • Executives facing tough decisions hire consultants to confirm decisions
  • Covers executive if decision goes badly - can't blame for insufficient due diligence
  • Shareholders told poor performance due to "extenuating market conditions"
  • Executives already made up minds, bring consultants to silence critics
  • If successful: executive gets credit; if failed: blame consultants
  • Consultants won't oppose hiring executive's vision (less likely to be rehired)
  • Consultants present research, not make decisions
  • Information-dense presentations open to interpretation
  • Advice only worth something if it changes someone's mind

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome