AI summary by TwinMind

How Apple Changed TSMC

Asianometry

12m 5s

Apple's Semiconductor Strategy Origins

  • Apple = American company, products assembled China/India, supply chain heart in Taiwan
  • 5 top electronic suppliers in Taiwan, including 2 closest: Foxconn and TSMC
  • Foxconn = one of several assembly partners (alongside Pegatron, Wistrom)
  • TSMC = sole supplier of device semiconductors, most critical component
  • 2008: Apple acquired PA Semi for $276M to design system-on-chips
  • 2010: Steve Jobs unveiled A4 chip in first iPad, first custom semiconductor

Samsung Foundry Relationship & Departure

  • First A4 chip fabbed at Samsung foundry
  • Samsung provided microprocessors for iPhone, 3G, 3GS + screens
  • Samsung's mobile phone entry chilled relationship
  • Apple sued Samsung for IP theft
  • Apple hated Samsung using component profits to compete in mobile phones
  • Sought supply chain diversification

TSMC Partnership Formation

  • TSMC business principle: never compete with customers
  • Sept 2014: iPhone 6s A8 processor on TSMC 20nm process
  • Parties talking since 2010 (Jeff Williams & Morris Chang dinner in Taiwan)
  • Took several years to finalize deal
  • Exception: A9 dual-sourced from TSMC + Samsung
    • Media alleged Samsung chips had worse battery life
    • Apple claimed real-life differences negligible
  • Single sourcing for every Apple processor since

TSMC's Extraordinary Accommodations for Apple

Financial Investment

  • TSMC invested $9B, deployed 6,000 people in Tainan for Apple-specific fab
  • Comparison: SMIC raised $7.6B in 2020 Shanghai IPO
  • Samsung announced 10-year $116B foundry plan
  • TSMC spends $16-17B capex in 2020 alone

R&D Strategy Alignment

  • TSMC crafted entire R&D/tech rollout to match Apple's annual iPhone cycle
  • Previously: TSMC rolled out new nodes when ready
  • Apple needs new, better, high-yielding process annually
  • TSMC cannot afford to miss annual cycle = "TSMC equivalent of Moore's Law"

Half-Step Process Strategy

  • Intel's tick-tock strategy failed (stuck at 14nm for 4 years)
  • TSMC created incremental 10-20% performance/power improvement yearly
  • vs. ambitious jumps every 2 years
  • Example: A12 on N7 (7nm), A13 on N7P (half-step improvement)
  • Note: nanometer measurements = marketing terms, not physical dimensions

EUV Technology Adoption

  • TSMC progressively adopted EUV technology step-by-step
  • Different approach from Intel/Samsung
  • First foundry to ship full EUV chips at high yield (2020)
  • Reliability/predictability more important than risky new tech

N3 Node Strategy

  • N3 (next after N5) won't use Gate All Around (GAA) technique
  • Reason: Apple cannot afford risk of technique failing annual iPhone cycle
  • N5 used for A14, N5P for A15 (next year)

Business Impact & Revenue

  • Apple = TSMC's single biggest customer
  • 2019: Apple represented 23% of TSMC annual revenue (~$8.2B)
  • Huawei = second largest customer ($5B revenue)
  • 2014: Major revenue jump visible when partnership began
  • 2020: TSMC celebrated 1B chips shipped on 7nm process (2 years old)

Premium Pricing Model

  • Apple one of few companies wanting/affording cutting-edge processes
  • TSMC 5nm wafer costs $17,000 each
  • Each chip costs $20-30 with good yield
  • For $1,000 phone, $20-30 chip cost not significant
  • Traditional customers (MediaTek, Qualcomm) sell chips directly, cost-sensitive
  • Samsung's cheaper prices attractive to cost-conscious customers

Current Market Position

  • Huawei no longer able to book TSMC orders
  • Apple now unquestionably TSMC's most important customer
  • Apple booked TSMC's entire N5 capacity
  • Relationship secure and mutually beneficial
  • No legitimate substitute for TSMC's capabilities
  • TSMC needs Apple's revenue for cutting-edge R&D investment

Why Apple Won't Buy TSMC

Financial Constraints

  • TSMC market cap: $389B (9th largest company globally)
  • Similar size to Tesla, Visa, Nvidia
  • Apple cash on hand: $190B
  • Apple debt: $100B (taken against cash for stock buybacks)

Business Model Destruction

  • TSMC's value = neutral third party that doesn't compete with customers
  • Apple ownership would destroy this value proposition
  • Would eliminate $400B+ investment value

Geopolitical Barriers

  • TSMC = Taiwan's flagship company (Taiwan in company name)
  • Taiwanese government would block transaction (even from US ally)
  • China tried buying TSMC for years, failed
  • TSMC represents 50% of Taiwan's entire R&D spending
  • Sale would cause political uproar, heads would roll
  • Control not for sale at any price

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome