AI summary by TwinMind
How Bad Data Traps People in the US Justice System | Clementine Jacoby | TED
TED
6m 11s
Personal Experience & System Discovery
- Speaker's friend sent back to prison after few months
- Experience led to conversations with researchers, advocates, prison system operators
- Universal agreement across political spectrum: change slowed by bad data
- Data problems: scattered, stale, incomplete
- Makes it impossible to know what's working
- Hundreds of thousands stuck in prison/probation/parole unnecessarily
Case Study: Kate's Story
- 2018: Kate sentenced to 4 years probation for drug charge
- Judge said sentence could be cut in half if doing well
- Current status: sober, employed, stable housing, kids doing great
- Completed all requirements but still on probation
- Demonstrates how people fall through cracks
Parole Officer Challenges: Allison's Experience
- Idaho parole officer for 6 years, excellent at job but job "impossible"
- Responsible for 90 people
- Each person needs to complete 21 requirements for release
- Requirements tracked in 5 different databases
- Bad phone reception in offices requires parking lot trips to access systems
- Must manually check 90 people daily across multiple systems
- Impossible to efficiently track who's completed requirements
System Origins & Growth
- Fragmented system developed from rapid growth starting 1970s
- Runaway growth at all levels: state prisons, county jails, city police departments
- Each entity running separate databases that don't communicate
- Bipartisan efforts passed common sense laws allowing successful people to earn release
- Data needed to enact laws still scattered across different systems
Solution: Recidivists Organization
- Non-profit engineering team
- Built tool for officers like Allison answering 3 questions:
- Who is eligible for release right now?
- Who's almost eligible but needs one more thing (e.g., pay stub photo)?
- Who needs help with treatment, jobs, housing?
- Simple tool enables officers to help people who need it most
- Allows others to return to their lives
Idaho Implementation Results
- Tool launched 6 months ago
- Kate released within weeks
- Within months: 5% of probation/parole population either moved to lower supervision or exited system entirely
- Scaling 5% improvement to all 50 states would impact 200,000 people
Broader Vision & Impact
- Better data needed at every Criminal Justice level
- Enable corrections leaders to identify effective treatment programs
- Help supervisors find/fix broken processes pulling people back
- Allow policymakers to see which laws hold people back
- Leaders tasked with reducing incarceration, racial disparities, saving taxpayer dollars while maintaining safety
Conclusion & Future
- Data can't fix entire US justice system
- Can help 200,000 stuck people
- Shows which strategies work
- Provides confidence that reform laws help intended beneficiaries
- Started as software engineering contribution
- Now recognized as promising strategy for system transformation
- Current status: 3 years, 8 states, thousands of people impacted
- "Just getting started"
