AI summary by TwinMind
How Biden Could Bypass Congress to Avoid a Default | WSJ
The Wall Street Journal
7m 5s
Current Debt Ceiling Crisis
- Democrats and Republicans must agree to raise debt ceiling by early June to avoid economic/financial catastrophe
- Negotiations ongoing with no agreement, parties still apart
- Biden claims he's "done my part"
- If Congress doesn't address debt limit, no good options exist for Treasury/government
- All alternatives highly risky, highly unlikely but being considered
Option 1: Trillion Dollar Platinum Coin
- Based on 1990s bill allowing Treasury Secretary to mint platinum coins in any denomination
- Concept: Mint $1 trillion coin to avoid taking on more debt
- Jason Furman (Obama's top economist) considers this "most unlikely"
- 2011 anecdote: Furman asked Tim Geithner about platinum coin, Geithner called it "crazy"
- Current Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen calls it "really a gimmick"
- Technical challenges:
- Treasury can't automatically start spending after minting
- Need money in checking account held at Federal Reserve
- Would require Fed to accept trillion dollar coin and credit government account
- Unclear if Federal Reserve would accept the coin
- Fed Chair Powell: "No rabbits to be pulled out of hats here"
Option 2: Premium Bonds
- Slightly more likely than platinum coin option
- Background on bond mechanics:
- Treasury takes on debt by selling bonds
- Example: $1,000 ten-year bond with 3% coupon rate pays $30/year for 10 years
- Actually worth $1,300 total
- Interest payments are regular government expenses
- Default occurs if Treasury can't pay when debt ceiling isn't raised by X date (~June 1st)
- Premium bond strategy:
- When debt ceiling hit, can't issue new bonds but can re-issue old bonds
- Could reissue with higher coupon rate (e.g., 10% instead of 3%)
- 10% bond worth $2,000 over ten years, brings more money at auction
- Technically not new debt
- Risks:
- Launching new high-coupon bond type during financially turbulent period
- Would create "real recipe for financial market chaos"
- Comparison of "different forms of poison" vs. going past X date
Option 3: 14th Amendment Approach
- Described as "most likely" or "least unlikely" option
- Constitutional basis:
- Article 1: Congress has power to pay US debts
- 14th Amendment: "validity of public debt shall not be questioned"
- Could interpret debt limit itself as unconstitutional
- Strategy: Continue issuing debt without inventing new instruments
- White House actively considering: "I've been considering the 14th Amendment"
- Challenges:
- Would require litigation
- If financial markets believe good chance of prevailing, would continue lending (buying time)
- Courts might support 14th Amendment theory
- Risk: Courts might rule opposite, creating chaos and back to drawing board
- Biden considering for future battles: "thinking about taking a look at this...months down the road"
Alternative Congressional Path: Discharge Petition
- House Democrats (not White House) could use discharge petition
- If Speaker McCarthy refuses clean debt ceiling raise, majority could bring to floor
- Process limitations:
- Lengthy process, can take more than a month
- Don't have more than a month to resolve
- Discharge petitions rarely succeed
- Currently in the works but not highly likely
Expert Consensus
- Financial system leaders say only one way forward: Congress must raise debt ceiling
- "Only good outcome is one in which Congress acts to raise the debt ceiling"
- US government must pay all obligations when due
