AI summary by TwinMind

How Big Banks Stack Up to Silicon Valley Bank - Are Big Unrealized Losses a Risk?

The Plain Bagel

18m 21s

Bank Size Comparison

  • Big 4 US banks (JP Morgan, Bank of America, Citigroup, Wells Fargo) deposits: 1.3-2.3 trillion dollars
  • ~10x larger than Silicon Valley Bank at midpoint
  • All labeled as G-SIBs (Global Systemically Important Banks)
  • Failure would have significant global financial system implications

Liquidity Risk Assessment

  • High Quality Liquid Assets (HQLA) - Basel III standardized measure
    • Tiers assets by liquidity/ease of sale without discount
    • Cash = 100% value included
    • Less liquid assets = up to 50% haircut from fair value
    • Incorporates discount for possible fire sale situations
  • Big 4 banks: 25-42% of deposits backed by HQLA
  • Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR) - HQLA divided by expected 30-day stressed withdrawals
    • Required to stay above 100%
    • Big 4 banks: ~120% across board (JP Morgan: 112% firm-wide, 151% banking operations)
    • Assumed withdrawal rates: 15-36% of total deposits over 30-day stress period

Silicon Valley Bank Comparison Issues

  • Regional banks not required to disclose same Basel III information
  • SVB didn't disclose standardized HQLA measure or LCR ratio
  • Conflicting estimates for SVB's LCR - exact figures unknown due to missing regulatory filing details

Solvency Analysis - CET1 Ratios

  • Common Equity Tier 1 Capital divided by risk-weighted assets
  • CET1 = common equity + retained earnings (first line of defense against losses)
  • Risk-weighted assets: cash/treasuries have 0% weighting, riskier assets weighted higher
  • Big 4 banks: all above 10% (meet minimums)
  • SVB reported CET1: ~12% (higher than peer group)
    • Regional banks can exclude AOCI (accumulated other comprehensive income)
    • SVB opted out of standard including losses from available-for-sale securities
    • Adjusted SVB CET1: 10.4% (still comparable to peer group)

Securities Classifications & Accounting

  • Trading Securities: held for trading, reports to net income
  • Available for Sale: bank interested in selling, unrealized gains/losses flow through AOCI
  • Held to Maturity: debt securities held until maturity
    • Recorded at amortized cost (purchase price + amortization adjustment)
    • Don't reflect current market value
    • Forced sale could cause unrealized gains/losses not reflected in CET1 ratio

Unrealized Losses on Held to Maturity Assets

  • SVB unrealized losses: $15.2 billion (more than their CET1 capital)
  • Big 4 banks unrealized losses (dollar amounts):
    • Bank of America: >$100 billion (largest amount, -17% value drop)
    • All banks have losses on held-to-maturity portfolios
  • Losses relative to CET1 capital:
    • Bank of America: 60% of CET1 capital
    • Not as severe as SVB but still significant

Maturity Profile Analysis

  • Longer maturity = higher price sensitivity to rising rates
  • Bank of America: vast majority of held-to-maturity assets in 10+ year securities
  • JP Morgan: ~42% in 10+ year securities
  • SVB: 94.2% in 10+ year maturities
  • Most yielding ~2% for next 10 years, can't be sold without massive loss

Risk Management Differences

  • SVB poorly managed from risk perspective
    • No chief risk officer for 8 months
    • Derivatives portfolio: $5.65 billion notional value (~2.7% of total assets)
    • Hedging derivatives: $550 million notional (~0.3% of total assets)
  • Big 4 banks derivatives (interest rate specific):
    • Bank of America: $24.3 trillion notional (8x total assets)
    • All large banks: tens of trillions in notional values
    • Citigroup/Wells Fargo hedging: 11-14% of total assets vs SVB's 0.2%

Risk Mitigation Factors

  • Held-to-maturity losses only issue during bank runs
  • If held to maturity, no actual loss realized (get face value back)
  • Big 4 banks lower bank run risk than SVB:
    • Much larger size (requires significant population withdrawal)
    • More diversified (SVB focused on VC/startup space in California)
    • Higher FDIC insurance coverage
      • SVB: 95.5% deposits uninsured
      • Citigroup: ~85% uninsured (highest among Big 4)
      • Bank of America: 37.3% uninsured (lowest)

Federal Reserve Lending Program

  • Banks can borrow up to 1 year using par value of assets as collateral
  • Avoids selling bonds at loss during rapid withdrawals
  • Borrow against assets at par value without recognizing unrealized loss

Interest Rate Impact

  • Banks benefit from rising rates long-term
  • All banks except JP Morgan show positive impact from 100 basis point parallel rate shift
  • Volatility affects short-term profitability but improves long-term margins

Remaining Risks

  • Bank runs can destroy even healthiest institutions
  • Risk depends on depositor trust
  • Unknown factors may surface (as with SVB)
  • Regional banks still face elevated risk
    • Higher-yielding alternatives to bank accounts
    • May not be deemed "too big to fail"
    • Still face pressure from heightened withdrawals

Sponsor Content

  • Blinkist sponsorship
  • Book recommendation: "The Spider Network" about Tom Hayes/LIBOR manipulation
  • 25% off premium membership + 7 days free
  • Blinkist Connect: share premium membership between two accounts

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome