AI summary by TwinMind
How China Finally Ended Foot Binding
Asianometry
8m 5s
Historical Origins and Development
- Ancient Chinese tradition of forced deformity passed mother to daughter
- Origins unclear, records dating back Han dynasty (2,800 years ago) show cultural preference for smaller feet
- Tang dynasty (7th-10th centuries): scholar writes of small-footed dancers spreading practice countrywide
- Song dynasty (10th century): Prince Lee Yoo had fetish for small feet, made concubine Yao Nyang toe dance with bound feet
- Well-established practice by 14th century
- Italian friar O'dorek (1300s) documented: mothers bind newborn girls' feet tightly to prevent growth
Practice Description and Methods
- Early form: made feet pointier/narrower, shaped like modern heels
- Later form: attempted arched shape
- Process begins before age 10 (usually 5-7 years)
- Later binding method:
- Fold 2nd-5th toes underneath sole
- Bring front of foot close to heel
- Achieved through bone growth inhibition, ligament/tendon alteration, angle direction changes
- NOT by breaking bones (common misconception)
- Foot wrapped in bandages, requires washing/rebandaging for life
Benefits vs. Consequences
- Benefits: sexual fetish appeal, higher status image
- Drawbacks: pain, disability, deformity, immobility, isolation, open wounds, septicemia, arthritis, gangrene, skin infections, paralysis, rotten flesh
- 10% death rate in girls undergoing process
Prevalence and Social Distribution
- Peak prevalence: higher and middle classes
- Peasant/servant women bound feet except where farming required wet feet (rice paddies)
- Estimated 50% of Han society women practiced it
- 1929 village survey (1,736 women, 515 families):
- 99% of women 40+ had bound feet
- 95% of women 30+ had bound feet
Dynastic Attitudes
- Yuan dynasty (Mongols): advocated for practice
- Ming dynasty: palace women didn't bind feet but allowed subjects to practice
- Qing dynasty (Manchu): never practiced, abhorred tradition, actively tried to ban
- Shenzhen emperor issued edict against it in 2nd year
- Kangxi emperor tried again 1662, gave up after 6 years, withdrew ban
- Manchu could make Chinese men shave heads but failed to stop women's foot binding
Anti-Foot Binding Movement Origins
- Late 1800s: China's "century of humiliation"
- Qing defeat in 1842 Opium War and First Sino-Japanese War triggered societal reflection
- Western foreigners initiated anti-foot binding movement
- Movement driven by Christian missionaries, similarities to abolition movement
- First recorded organization founded 1874 in Xiamen
- Chinese reformer Kang Youwei started organization in Guangzhou 1883
Natural Foot Society
- 1895: Alicia Little (wife of British writer Archibald Little) founded Natural Foot Society
- Not specifically Christian (Alicia held low views of religion)
- Unaffiliated nature helped dodge Western infiltration issues
- Focused solely on foot binding practice
- Attracted leading Chinese reformers
Three-Pronged Abolition Strategy
- Education campaign with two main messages:
- Other countries didn't bind women's feet, China losing international face
- Emphasized advantages of natural feet
- Large events showing raw photos/x-rays of bound feet
- Name "Tianzu Hui" implied natural feet essentially better
- Established hundreds of grassroots natural societies
- Members promised not to practice foot binding, not allow sons to marry bound-feet women
Rapid Decline and Elimination
- Movement worked with cultural openness to new ideas
- After Qing fall, leadership passed from Western missionaries to Chinese
- 1915: Republic of China government began issuing fines for violations
- Same village statistics:
- 99% bound feet (born 1889)
- 95% bound feet (born 1899)
- 0% bound feet (born 1919)
- Practice persisted in isolated areas through 1930s but essentially eliminated
- Estimated 2 billion women had feet bound over the years (949-1950)
Historical Significance
- Tradition lasted 1,000 years, died out in just 20 years
- Rare documented success during time when Chinese society had little to celebrate
- Western missionaries initiated abolition, but rapid elimination showed popular readiness to abandon practice
