AI summary by TwinMind
How Companies Cheated Price Fixing Laws... With Math
How Money Works
11m 37s
Introduction to Algorithmic Price Control
- Algorithms embedded in every app, website, business to influence user decisions and maximize spending
- Amazon tests price increases competitor tracking, dynamic pricing ($40 more at 3am)
- Flight prices fluctuate $150→$300→$150 via real-time pricing algorithms
- Wendy's planned surge pricing for burgers based on time of day
- CEO Kirk Tanner announced dynamic pricing system
- $20 million investment planned before internet backlash
- Mistake was announcing - dynamic pricing already widespread
Amazon's Market Manipulation Through Algorithms
- "The Everything War" by Dana Mattioli (Wall Street Journal) details Amazon's pricing control
- Amazon contractually required sellers list products at lowest price on platform
- Sellers pay Amazon fulfillment costs (more expensive than regular shipping due to same/next day emphasis)
- Example: $20 product + $5 Amazon costs = $25 needed, but can't charge more than other retailers
- Result: Businesses raise prices at Walmart, Target, own websites to maintain Amazon pricing
- 2019 FTC pressure ended formal agreements
- Current system: Algorithm detects non-competitive prices, buries products on pages 2-3
- Algorithm provides company separation from direct price manipulation
Rental Market Price Fixing
- FTC released statement: algorithmic price fixing still illegal
- "Rent Maximizer" software marketed to landlords/real estate agents
- Used to determine rental prices for tens of millions of families
- Uses market data + proprietary systems for highest confident rental price
- Incorporates data from other area property managers to avoid undercutting
- FTC concluded this constitutes illegal price fixing
- Price fixing: 2+ businesses agree to raise prices, maximize revenue without competing
- Especially damaging for essential goods (food, water, housing)
- Average rents increased 30%+ since 2020
- Harvard study: 12+ million households spend >50% total income on housing alone (before taxes, transport, food)
Food Industry Algorithmic Collusion
- Justice Department sued meat processors using price-setting algorithms
- Companies controlled:
- 90% broiler chicken sales
- 80% pork sales
- 90% turkey sales across America
Healthcare Algorithm Manipulation
- "Multiplan" algorithm used by large health insurers
- Cuts payments to doctors, increases patient billing
- Dominant in pricing out-of-network care nationwide
- Algorithm determines insurer vs patient payment responsibility
- Consistently minimizes insurer responsibility, maximizes patient costs
- Insurers use lowest Multiplan estimates knowing competitors do same
- Claims to protect from outrageous provider bills, but dumps excess costs on patients
- Smaller healthcare providers hurt more than large hospital chains
- Rural doctor closed practice after Multiplan rate slashes
- Patients now travel 2.5 hours for covered provider
- Major insurers bragged about technology embedding in claims processing
- FTC remains quiet on healthcare industry price fixing
Employment Algorithm Control
- Job applications processed through Indeed, LinkedIn, company sites
- 98% Fortune 500 companies use Application Tracking Software (ATS)
- Average corporate job opening: 250 resumes → 4-6 interviews → 1 hire
- Algorithmic resume screening creates services where programs write resumes for programs
- Same tools used for wage negotiation with new hires/existing staff
- Companies estimate replacement costs via algorithms when employees demand raises
- No cost benefit = no pay increase granted
- Companies have access to thousands of applications + proprietary ATS data
- Regular employees lack comparable market data access
Broader Implications
- All done to maximize shareholder value
- Upcoming article on tax/welfare detection algorithms with "deadly consequences"
- Algorithms as tools can be good/evil, but profit-focused companies use for profit maximization
- Creates "algorithmic-ification" of all interactions
- Makes everything expensive "all the time"
