AI summary by TwinMind

How Companies Cheated Price Fixing Laws... With Math

How Money Works

11m 37s

Introduction to Algorithmic Price Control

  • Algorithms embedded in every app, website, business to influence user decisions and maximize spending
  • Amazon tests price increases competitor tracking, dynamic pricing ($40 more at 3am)
  • Flight prices fluctuate $150→$300→$150 via real-time pricing algorithms
  • Wendy's planned surge pricing for burgers based on time of day
    • CEO Kirk Tanner announced dynamic pricing system
    • $20 million investment planned before internet backlash
    • Mistake was announcing - dynamic pricing already widespread

Amazon's Market Manipulation Through Algorithms

  • "The Everything War" by Dana Mattioli (Wall Street Journal) details Amazon's pricing control
  • Amazon contractually required sellers list products at lowest price on platform
  • Sellers pay Amazon fulfillment costs (more expensive than regular shipping due to same/next day emphasis)
  • Example: $20 product + $5 Amazon costs = $25 needed, but can't charge more than other retailers
  • Result: Businesses raise prices at Walmart, Target, own websites to maintain Amazon pricing
  • 2019 FTC pressure ended formal agreements
  • Current system: Algorithm detects non-competitive prices, buries products on pages 2-3
  • Algorithm provides company separation from direct price manipulation

Rental Market Price Fixing

  • FTC released statement: algorithmic price fixing still illegal
  • "Rent Maximizer" software marketed to landlords/real estate agents
  • Used to determine rental prices for tens of millions of families
  • Uses market data + proprietary systems for highest confident rental price
  • Incorporates data from other area property managers to avoid undercutting
  • FTC concluded this constitutes illegal price fixing
  • Price fixing: 2+ businesses agree to raise prices, maximize revenue without competing
  • Especially damaging for essential goods (food, water, housing)
  • Average rents increased 30%+ since 2020
  • Harvard study: 12+ million households spend >50% total income on housing alone (before taxes, transport, food)

Food Industry Algorithmic Collusion

  • Justice Department sued meat processors using price-setting algorithms
  • Companies controlled:
    • 90% broiler chicken sales
    • 80% pork sales
    • 90% turkey sales across America

Healthcare Algorithm Manipulation

  • "Multiplan" algorithm used by large health insurers
  • Cuts payments to doctors, increases patient billing
  • Dominant in pricing out-of-network care nationwide
  • Algorithm determines insurer vs patient payment responsibility
  • Consistently minimizes insurer responsibility, maximizes patient costs
  • Insurers use lowest Multiplan estimates knowing competitors do same
  • Claims to protect from outrageous provider bills, but dumps excess costs on patients
  • Smaller healthcare providers hurt more than large hospital chains
  • Rural doctor closed practice after Multiplan rate slashes
  • Patients now travel 2.5 hours for covered provider
  • Major insurers bragged about technology embedding in claims processing
  • FTC remains quiet on healthcare industry price fixing

Employment Algorithm Control

  • Job applications processed through Indeed, LinkedIn, company sites
  • 98% Fortune 500 companies use Application Tracking Software (ATS)
  • Average corporate job opening: 250 resumes → 4-6 interviews → 1 hire
  • Algorithmic resume screening creates services where programs write resumes for programs
  • Same tools used for wage negotiation with new hires/existing staff
  • Companies estimate replacement costs via algorithms when employees demand raises
  • No cost benefit = no pay increase granted
  • Companies have access to thousands of applications + proprietary ATS data
  • Regular employees lack comparable market data access

Broader Implications

  • All done to maximize shareholder value
  • Upcoming article on tax/welfare detection algorithms with "deadly consequences"
  • Algorithms as tools can be good/evil, but profit-focused companies use for profit maximization
  • Creates "algorithmic-ification" of all interactions
  • Makes everything expensive "all the time"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome