AI summary by TwinMind

How Data Happened | Chris Wiggins & Matthew L. Jones | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

43m 19s

Introduction and Book Overview

  • Sonia Suban (Google software engineer) introduces Dr. Chris Wiggins (Columbia Applied Mathematics) and Dr. Matthew L Jones (Columbia Faculty of Arts & Sciences)
  • Discussion of book "How Data Happened: A History from the Age of Reason to the Age of Algorithms"
  • 45-minute session format with audience Q&A via chat

Book Genesis and Motivation

  • Collaboration began decade ago, formal class creation started 2015
  • Originally focused on history of data science, evolved based on student feedback
  • Designed for interdisciplinary audience: engineers and humanistic students
  • Class became foundation for book after identifying novel material for both technical and non-technical backgrounds

Book Structure - Three Parts

Part One: Pencil and Paper Era

  • Data analysis for understanding truth using manual methods
  • Covers ~200-year span to illuminate current political/ethical challenges

Part Two: Digital Computation Era

  • Begins at Bletchley Park with digital computation creation
  • Integration of hardware, diverse communities, technical skills
  • Industrial scale data processing emergence

Part Three: Present Day

  • Current milieu analysis (not chronological)
  • Corporate data use rise
  • Understanding powers constraining/guiding data-empowered algorithms in daily life

Data Collection and Decision-Making Blind Spots

  • Only some facets of data collected, creating worldview-shaped understanding
  • Stephen J. Gould's "scientific racism" concept discussed
  • Example: Insurance industry vs. sociologist Du Bois debate on insurability data analysis (late 19th/early 20th century)
    • Hoffman (insurance): data showed essential differences between groups
    • Du Bois: data revealed historical causes of stratification
  • Danger: numbers create false objectivity, masking subjective design choices in data collection

Bayes' Theorem in Cryptography and Philosophy

  • Chapter 6 focuses on Bayes' theorem importance in WWII codebreaking
  • Distinction: "being philosophical about Bayes vs. using Bayes' Rule formula"
  • COVID diagnosis example: sensitivity/specificity vs. probability of illness given test results
  • Bletchley Park reintroduced Bayes' Rule for practical code-breaking applications
  • NSA declassified papers showed practical Bayesian attitudes contradicting contemporary philosophical/statistical positions
  • Direct line from cryptographic mass data analysis to modern computational statistics

Social Physics Concept

  • Belgian statistician Quetelet (creator of BMI) working post-French Revolution
  • Applied Newtonian physics tools to human behavior data
  • Argued social phenomena followed patterns (normal curve)
  • Characterized human activity (divorce rates, criminality) as physics with mechanics/dynamics
  • Focus on group behavior rather than individual choice

Correlation vs. Causation Historical Example

  • Yule's 1899 paper "On the Causes of Pauperism in England"
  • Performed multivariate regression (supervised learning equivalent)
  • Inferred positive coefficient between welfare recipients and poor population
  • Concluded welfare causes poverty (political statement from correlation)
  • Footnote 25 acknowledged "causation should be read as associated with"
  • Excellent predictive models don't guarantee causal understanding

Hypothesis Formation Evolution

  • Pre-large data era: significance testing prestige in science reorganization
  • Current crisis in significance testing methodology
  • Genesis from different statistical philosophies:
    • William Gosset (Guinness Corporation): economical beer-making experiments
    • Fisher (British statistician): scientific truth replacement theory, randomization, p<0.05 suggestion
    • Neyman (Polish-American): decision theory for practical action
  • Fisher-Neyman "warfare" for decades over fundamentally different worldviews
  • Textbook flattening created standard scientific procedures
  • Radically different from modern machine learning/data science approaches

Field Making Discussion

  • Mathematical statistics field creation (adjective "mathematical" distinguished from other statistics)
  • Academic departmental statistics vs. algorithmic hypothesis testing
  • Algorithmic approach: collect data → confidence interval → p-value → <0.05 determination → next hypothesis
  • Both Fisher and Neyman would have hated this algorithmic approach
  • Biggest insult for both: calling someone "Bayesian"

Early AI vs. Modern NLP

  • Early AI vision: human intelligence not from data accumulation/sensory input
  • Deeply anti-empirical approach, focused on mathematical ability, chess, logic
  • Turing had more capacious vision including sensory world
  • Mid-20th century: language as small number of rules (Chomsky influence)
  • Google researchers' "Unreasonable Effectiveness of Data" paper
  • Complete inversion: language as empirical science rather than physics-like rules
  • Modern AI transformation from rule-based to data-driven approaches

Data Privacy Evolution

  • 1970s: bipartisan US conversation about data privacy
  • Privacy laws constrained federal government but not corporations
  • Individualistic privacy understanding emerged
  • Privacy as personal concern vs. ecological concept affecting communities
  • Individual action solutions (cookie opt-outs) vs. systemic protections

Current Privacy Concerns and Solutions

  • Three-player power distribution: individuals, corporations, state
  • Multinational companies subject to multiple jurisdictions (EU regulations affecting US users)
  • Principles → standards → rules → code → product decisions chain
  • Individual software engineers/product owners have outsized impact through private ordering
  • Corporate power includes deplatforming capabilities
  • "Unstable three-player game" between corporate, state, and individual power

Future Vision for Data Science/ML

Chris Wiggins' Excitement:

  • Causality as explicit field with modeling assumptions
  • Deep learning/large language models continued progress
  • Extremely performant but uninterpretable methods
  • Theory development for understanding why methods work
  • Healthcare applications: privacy-preserving data access, population stratification challenges

Matthew Jones' Perspective:

  • Large language models as intelligence exploration tools, not human substitute
  • Integration with affected communities (scientific collaborations, community development)
  • Recognition of political/ethical implications at all levels (federal to municipal to schools/jails)

Audience Q&A Highlights

Large Language Models Integration

  • Weekly lab updates incorporating LLM material
  • Environmental costs of training considerations
  • Infrastructure metaphor: neither good nor bad, but collective building requiring community input
  • Eliza chatbot example: artificial intelligence without machine learning
  • Reinforcement learning optimizing "appearance of spontaneity"

Health Data Privacy Evolution

  • Belmont principles framework: respect for persons, benefits vs. harms, justice
  • Latanya Sweeney's re-identification research (Harvard professor, former MIT student)
  • Anonymous database re-identification using join keys (age, zip code, gender)
  • Genomics/DNA data sharpening privacy conversations post-late 1990s
  • Genotype-phenotype mapping opportunities vs. potential harms

Collaboration History

  • 10-year professional relationship beginning with machine learning history talk
  • Journalism school teaching program: data analysis tools for journalists
  • Columbia student initiative suggesting joint class
  • Evolution from small seminar to larger lecture course
  • Student feedback driving connection between history and ethics/politics
  • Organic book development from educational context

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome