AI summary by TwinMind

How did Silicon Valley Bank fail? : Business case study

Think School

23m 49s

SVB Overview and Collapse Context

  • Silicon Valley Bank collapsed Friday, March 10, 2023
  • Second biggest bank collapse in US history (16th largest US bank)
  • Epicenter of tech startups and Venture Capital ecosystem
  • Bank stock lost 80% value in one week, 60% in single day
  • Invested in ~21 Indian startups
  • Management fired, investors not protected
  • Federal officials working around clock for resolution

Historical Background and Growth

  • Founded 1983, became largest Silicon Valley bank by local deposits
  • Served successful startups: Airbnb, Fitbit, Pinterest
  • Catered to businesses, Venture capitalists
  • Crisis started with pandemic and Russia-Ukraine war

Inflation and Federal Reserve Response

  • Energy crisis sparked global inflation
  • US inflation peaked at 9.1% (highest in decade)
  • Pre-pandemic: 2.5% → Post-pandemic: 5% → Post-war: 9.1%
  • Federal Reserve raised interest rates from 0.08% (2020) to 4.25-4.33% (2023)
  • 425 basis points increase in one year
  • Interest rate mechanism explained:
    • Fed lends to commercial banks at repo rate
    • Banks lend to consumers at higher rates (profit margin ~2%)
    • Rate increases reduce consumer spending power
    • Example: $300k home loan EMI increased from $2,336 to $2,720 (16.7% increase)
    • Annual purchasing power decreased by $4,704 per family

SVB's Golden Period (2020-2021)

  • Low Fed rates (0.08%) enabled profitable lending at 3% (2.92% profit margin)
  • Global VC funding reached $681 billion in 2021
  • Deposits jumped from $61.76 billion (2019) to $189.2 billion (2021) - tripled
  • Competitive deposit strategy: paid 2.33% vs industry average 1.17%, Bank of America 0.96%
  • High deposit rates attracted large startup customers ($100M deposits earning $2.33M annually)

Investment Strategy and Asset-Liability Mismatch

  • Invested $91 billion in held-to-maturity (HTM) treasury and mortgage bonds
  • Only $26.1 billion in available-for-sale (AFS) investments
  • $80 billion specifically in illiquid mortgage-backed securities
  • 97% of mortgage-backed securities had 10+ year maturity
  • Weighted average yield: only 1.56% vs 2.33% promised to depositors
  • Created negative carry situation (paying more than earning)

Mortgage-Backed Securities Explanation

  • Banks package loans into securities, sell to investors
  • Example: $1B loan portfolio sold as securities promising 3% return
  • Bank charges borrowers 6%, keeps 3% spread as profit
  • HTM securities cannot be sold before maturity without heavy penalties
  • AFS securities can be sold but at market prices

Market Deterioration Factors

  • Federal Reserve stopped buying mortgage-backed securities post-COVID
  • 425 basis point rate hike reduced demand for loans and mortgage securities
  • New government bonds offered better returns with less risk
  • Bond values dropped significantly (example: $250M unit value fell to $150M)
  • SVB's $91B bond portfolio value dropped to $76B (15B loss on paper)
  • Current mortgage yields: 5% vs SVB's locked-in 1.6%

Startup Winter and Liquidity Crisis

  • Funding winter began affecting startup ecosystem
  • Startups withdrew deposits instead of taking expensive loans
  • SVB deposits dropped $20 billion in three quarters
  • Created catch-22: needed cash for withdrawals but money stuck in bonds
  • March 8, 2023: SVB sold $21B AFS portfolio at loss
  • Portfolio yielding 1.79% vs current 10-year treasury 3.9%
  • Attempted to raise $2.25B in equity and debt to cover losses

Bank Run and Final Collapse

  • Surprise disclosure shocked clients who expected sufficient liquidity
  • VCs (Peter Thiel's Founders Fund, Union Square Ventures) instructed portfolio companies to withdraw
  • Word spread rapidly, creating panic withdrawals
  • Stock plunged 60% in one day
  • Trading halted, FDIC took control
  • $175B in customer deposits under FDIC control
  • New bank created: National Bank of Santa Clara to hold deposits/assets

Impact on Indian Startups

  • Depends on deposit recovery from FDIC
  • If deposits returned: limited chaos
  • If not returned: significant startup ecosystem crunch
  • Crisis may trigger scrutiny of other banks
  • Risk assessment needed: check startup/portfolio exposure to affected banks
  • Higher exposure = greater impact

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome