AI summary by TwinMind
How did Silicon Valley Bank fail? : Business case study
Think School
23m 49s
SVB Overview and Collapse Context
- Silicon Valley Bank collapsed Friday, March 10, 2023
- Second biggest bank collapse in US history (16th largest US bank)
- Epicenter of tech startups and Venture Capital ecosystem
- Bank stock lost 80% value in one week, 60% in single day
- Invested in ~21 Indian startups
- Management fired, investors not protected
- Federal officials working around clock for resolution
Historical Background and Growth
- Founded 1983, became largest Silicon Valley bank by local deposits
- Served successful startups: Airbnb, Fitbit, Pinterest
- Catered to businesses, Venture capitalists
- Crisis started with pandemic and Russia-Ukraine war
Inflation and Federal Reserve Response
- Energy crisis sparked global inflation
- US inflation peaked at 9.1% (highest in decade)
- Pre-pandemic: 2.5% → Post-pandemic: 5% → Post-war: 9.1%
- Federal Reserve raised interest rates from 0.08% (2020) to 4.25-4.33% (2023)
- 425 basis points increase in one year
- Interest rate mechanism explained:
- Fed lends to commercial banks at repo rate
- Banks lend to consumers at higher rates (profit margin ~2%)
- Rate increases reduce consumer spending power
- Example: $300k home loan EMI increased from $2,336 to $2,720 (16.7% increase)
- Annual purchasing power decreased by $4,704 per family
SVB's Golden Period (2020-2021)
- Low Fed rates (0.08%) enabled profitable lending at 3% (2.92% profit margin)
- Global VC funding reached $681 billion in 2021
- Deposits jumped from $61.76 billion (2019) to $189.2 billion (2021) - tripled
- Competitive deposit strategy: paid 2.33% vs industry average 1.17%, Bank of America 0.96%
- High deposit rates attracted large startup customers ($100M deposits earning $2.33M annually)
Investment Strategy and Asset-Liability Mismatch
- Invested $91 billion in held-to-maturity (HTM) treasury and mortgage bonds
- Only $26.1 billion in available-for-sale (AFS) investments
- $80 billion specifically in illiquid mortgage-backed securities
- 97% of mortgage-backed securities had 10+ year maturity
- Weighted average yield: only 1.56% vs 2.33% promised to depositors
- Created negative carry situation (paying more than earning)
Mortgage-Backed Securities Explanation
- Banks package loans into securities, sell to investors
- Example: $1B loan portfolio sold as securities promising 3% return
- Bank charges borrowers 6%, keeps 3% spread as profit
- HTM securities cannot be sold before maturity without heavy penalties
- AFS securities can be sold but at market prices
Market Deterioration Factors
- Federal Reserve stopped buying mortgage-backed securities post-COVID
- 425 basis point rate hike reduced demand for loans and mortgage securities
- New government bonds offered better returns with less risk
- Bond values dropped significantly (example: $250M unit value fell to $150M)
- SVB's $91B bond portfolio value dropped to $76B (15B loss on paper)
- Current mortgage yields: 5% vs SVB's locked-in 1.6%
Startup Winter and Liquidity Crisis
- Funding winter began affecting startup ecosystem
- Startups withdrew deposits instead of taking expensive loans
- SVB deposits dropped $20 billion in three quarters
- Created catch-22: needed cash for withdrawals but money stuck in bonds
- March 8, 2023: SVB sold $21B AFS portfolio at loss
- Portfolio yielding 1.79% vs current 10-year treasury 3.9%
- Attempted to raise $2.25B in equity and debt to cover losses
Bank Run and Final Collapse
- Surprise disclosure shocked clients who expected sufficient liquidity
- VCs (Peter Thiel's Founders Fund, Union Square Ventures) instructed portfolio companies to withdraw
- Word spread rapidly, creating panic withdrawals
- Stock plunged 60% in one day
- Trading halted, FDIC took control
- $175B in customer deposits under FDIC control
- New bank created: National Bank of Santa Clara to hold deposits/assets
Impact on Indian Startups
- Depends on deposit recovery from FDIC
- If deposits returned: limited chaos
- If not returned: significant startup ecosystem crunch
- Crisis may trigger scrutiny of other banks
- Risk assessment needed: check startup/portfolio exposure to affected banks
- Higher exposure = greater impact
