AI summary by TwinMind
How Diversification Works
The Plain Bagel
10m 54s
Diversification Fundamentals
- Risk management strategy involving holding money across array of different investments
- Reduces exposure to idiosyncratic risks (business/company specific risks)
- Management bad investment decisions on new products
- New regulation cutting company sales
- Natural disasters destroying key facilities
- Example: $100,000 in one stock vs $100,000 split across 10 stocks ($10,000 each)
- Each stock: 2/3 chance double money, 1/3 chance lose everything
- Single stock investor: 1/3 chance lose everything
- Diversified investor: only loses everything if all 10 investments hit 1/3 odds (extremely unlikely)
Correlation and Portfolio Construction
- Works best when positions are uncorrelated (correlation coefficient close to zero)
- Stock prices need to move independently of one another
- Portfolio visualizer tool available for calculating correlation
- Common approaches for ensuring uncorrelated positions:
- Invest across different industries/sectors
- Banks benefit from rising interest rates (charge more for loans)
- Real estate companies benefit from falling interest rates (borrow more to buy buildings)
- Invest in companies of different sizes
- Geographic diversification (different countries)
- Reduces geopolitical risks (tariffs, war)
- Split between asset classes: cash equivalents, stocks, fixed income, alternatives
Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT)
- Popular approach for building investment portfolios
- Investing in uncorrelated assets increases return per unit of risk
- Makes investments more risk efficient
- Assumes risk equals stock price volatility/fluctuations
- Diversification smooths out price volatility of entire portfolio
- Provides smoother performance and easier ride to stomach
Marginal Diversification Benefits
- Shrinking marginal benefit with each additional stock
- Every additional stock decreases volatility by smaller amounts
- First few positions have dramatic effect on volatility
- Benefit plateaus around 20 stocks
- 30 stocks captures most diversification benefits
- Leaves behind systemic/market risk (affects wide range of companies)
- Cannot remove all risk from portfolio when investing
Practical Implementation Challenges
- 30 stocks difficult threshold for small investors
- High percentage transaction fees with few thousand dollars
- Some stocks (Google) trading above $1,000 - difficult to evenly split money
- Solutions: zero fee broker services, mutual funds, ETFs
- Funds allow exposure to hundreds/thousands of stocks through one unit
Active vs Passive Investing Perspectives
Passive Investors
- Diversification across thousands of stocks is ideal approach
- Removes virtually all company specific risk
Active Investors - Downsides of Too Many Positions
- Cost: more positions to trade, hefty transaction fees when rebalancing
- Time consuming to stay on top of all companies
- Reduces marginal benefit of analysis per company
- Undervalued stock won't have much impact if just 1 of 1000 positions
- Need to find 100 exceptional stocks to earn above average returns
- Large mutual funds criticism: rules prevent holding too much in individual companies
- As funds grow, number of positions increases, harder to deliver Alpha returns
Portfolio Strategy Recommendations
- Warren Buffett's big swing analogy: wait for right pitch, take big position
- Degree of diversification debatable, but some diversity is prudent
- Don't have all money in just few investments or sectors
- Starting investors: consider using funds until enough money for complete individual securities portfolio
- Avoid false diversification: multiple mutual funds/ETFs with overlapping holdings
- Consider human capital: if work in energy sector, branch investments to other areas
- Avoid double hit to career and investments if industry falters
Conclusion
- Whether need 1000 baskets or 10 is debatable
- Diversification reduces risk, helps offset bad investments with good ones
- Fundamental component of investing
