AI summary by TwinMind

How Do MLM Companies Defend Themselves Against Being Classed as Pyramid Schemes? - How Money Works

How Money Works

10m 56s

MLM Industry Growth Despite Criticism

  • MLMs receive universal criticism across news, social media, aware groups for unethical business tactics
  • Despite bad reputation, MLMs grown year-over-year with larger victim pools
  • Critics claim MLMs are unstable pyramid schemes mathematically guaranteed to fail
  • Industry filled with decades-old companies contradicts failure predictions
  • Critics not wrong about industry overall but misunderstand day-to-day operations
  • Public misunderstanding key to explaining continued growth

Income Statistics and Member Expectations

  • Major criticism: almost everybody loses money in MLMs
  • Charts show tiny percentage of participants make any money
  • Income disclosure statements reveal only few dozen members per company make six-figure incomes promised to new participants
  • US companies legally required to produce these documents after ruling mandating income transparency
  • Most people join without expectation of making business from it

Member Motivations and Discount Model

  • Companies claim people join for discounted product prices available to members
  • Herbalife weight loss shake example: public retail price significantly higher than wholesale member price
  • For frequent consumers, membership financially sensible - similar to Costco membership model
  • Costco has positive public image despite similar structure
  • Reality: many sign up due to pressure from family/friends ("auntie, long lost friend, third cousin twice removed")
  • Easiest way to stop recruitment calls is acquiescing and buying signup pack
  • Products often collect dust in garage, but stops harassment
  • These become part of 99% who join and never make money

Product Pricing Analysis

  • Critics argue MLM products extremely expensive for what they are
  • Weight loss shake discount still doesn't make price competitive with market alternatives
  • Critics claim high prices needed for big margins to pay bonuses to pyramid top
  • Companies market products as premium alternatives (hard to measure)
  • Regular market alternatives exist that are more expensive
  • Some MLM products actually relatively good value

Amway Case Study

  • Amway: oldest and largest MLM operating globally
  • Started selling concentrated, cost-effective cleaning products
  • Compared to other concentrated household cleaners, Amway alternatives cheaper or comparable
  • Pricing doesn't consider additional member discounts
  • Contradicts criticism that MLM products need massive markup for pyramid payments

Business Opportunity Defense

  • Hundreds of examples of people becoming wealthy through MLMs
  • Critics acknowledge most don't become wealthy
  • Even ignoring inactive members, most involved lose money
  • Those who profit often would earn more at minimum wage McDonald's job
  • MLM companies argue this is normal business reality
  • Starting own business tomorrow has higher loss potential than MLM membership
  • Every MLM loss story (few thousand on vitamins/skincare/leggings) matched by traditional business failure (tens of thousands on cafe)
  • Most people trying any business fail and lose more money
  • MLMs offer sales-based business opportunity with minimal upfront investment/financial risk

Modern MLM Pitch Strategy

  • Companies have prepared responses for every criticism
  • Costco comparison for membership losses
  • Most members shop occasionally with no business interest
  • Starting business is hard, MLMs provide opportunity without huge financial burden
  • Premium products more expensive than budget alternatives but competitive with other premium offerings
  • Everyday products more economical than market alternatives
  • Companies reshape opinions by working with common criticisms

Loss Leader Strategy

  • Products like cleaning supplies priced as loss leaders
  • Loss leaders: products priced cheaply/unprofitably to get people in store
  • Hope customers spend more on profitable items
  • Amway uses low-value cleaning products to dispel overpriced criticism
  • Then sells overpriced products from profitable ranges
  • This adaptation allows continued growth despite shady reputation

Final Assessment

  • Not calling MLMs outright scam (too easy for objection handling)
  • Suitable for skilled salesmen willing to work commission-only while building/managing commission-only team
  • Not suitable for those not starting business or not good salesmen
  • Don't let MLM participants convince you otherwise

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome