AI summary by TwinMind
How Do MLM Companies Defend Themselves Against Being Classed as Pyramid Schemes? - How Money Works
How Money Works
10m 56s
MLM Industry Growth Despite Criticism
- MLMs receive universal criticism across news, social media, aware groups for unethical business tactics
- Despite bad reputation, MLMs grown year-over-year with larger victim pools
- Critics claim MLMs are unstable pyramid schemes mathematically guaranteed to fail
- Industry filled with decades-old companies contradicts failure predictions
- Critics not wrong about industry overall but misunderstand day-to-day operations
- Public misunderstanding key to explaining continued growth
Income Statistics and Member Expectations
- Major criticism: almost everybody loses money in MLMs
- Charts show tiny percentage of participants make any money
- Income disclosure statements reveal only few dozen members per company make six-figure incomes promised to new participants
- US companies legally required to produce these documents after ruling mandating income transparency
- Most people join without expectation of making business from it
Member Motivations and Discount Model
- Companies claim people join for discounted product prices available to members
- Herbalife weight loss shake example: public retail price significantly higher than wholesale member price
- For frequent consumers, membership financially sensible - similar to Costco membership model
- Costco has positive public image despite similar structure
- Reality: many sign up due to pressure from family/friends ("auntie, long lost friend, third cousin twice removed")
- Easiest way to stop recruitment calls is acquiescing and buying signup pack
- Products often collect dust in garage, but stops harassment
- These become part of 99% who join and never make money
Product Pricing Analysis
- Critics argue MLM products extremely expensive for what they are
- Weight loss shake discount still doesn't make price competitive with market alternatives
- Critics claim high prices needed for big margins to pay bonuses to pyramid top
- Companies market products as premium alternatives (hard to measure)
- Regular market alternatives exist that are more expensive
- Some MLM products actually relatively good value
Amway Case Study
- Amway: oldest and largest MLM operating globally
- Started selling concentrated, cost-effective cleaning products
- Compared to other concentrated household cleaners, Amway alternatives cheaper or comparable
- Pricing doesn't consider additional member discounts
- Contradicts criticism that MLM products need massive markup for pyramid payments
Business Opportunity Defense
- Hundreds of examples of people becoming wealthy through MLMs
- Critics acknowledge most don't become wealthy
- Even ignoring inactive members, most involved lose money
- Those who profit often would earn more at minimum wage McDonald's job
- MLM companies argue this is normal business reality
- Starting own business tomorrow has higher loss potential than MLM membership
- Every MLM loss story (few thousand on vitamins/skincare/leggings) matched by traditional business failure (tens of thousands on cafe)
- Most people trying any business fail and lose more money
- MLMs offer sales-based business opportunity with minimal upfront investment/financial risk
Modern MLM Pitch Strategy
- Companies have prepared responses for every criticism
- Costco comparison for membership losses
- Most members shop occasionally with no business interest
- Starting business is hard, MLMs provide opportunity without huge financial burden
- Premium products more expensive than budget alternatives but competitive with other premium offerings
- Everyday products more economical than market alternatives
- Companies reshape opinions by working with common criticisms
Loss Leader Strategy
- Products like cleaning supplies priced as loss leaders
- Loss leaders: products priced cheaply/unprofitably to get people in store
- Hope customers spend more on profitable items
- Amway uses low-value cleaning products to dispel overpriced criticism
- Then sells overpriced products from profitable ranges
- This adaptation allows continued growth despite shady reputation
Final Assessment
- Not calling MLMs outright scam (too easy for objection handling)
- Suitable for skilled salesmen willing to work commission-only while building/managing commission-only team
- Not suitable for those not starting business or not good salesmen
- Don't let MLM participants convince you otherwise
