AI summary by TwinMind

How Ethics Can Help You Make Better Decisions | Michael Schur | TED

TED

11m 31s

Personal Background and Rule-Following Nature

  • 25-year television comedy writer (sketches, animated shows, sitcoms)
  • Last decade focused on ethics study
  • Lifelong intense rule follower
    • Kindergarten: immediately lined up when teacher said, frustrated with others who didn't
    • Mouthwash: used for exactly 30 seconds nightly per label instructions

The 2005 Fender Bender Incident

  • Wife JJ bumped car in slow traffic
  • Police saw no damage, parties exchanged numbers
  • Days later: other driver demanded $836 for entire fender replacement
  • Occurred during Hurricane Katrina
    • Speaker and JJ had recently visited New Orleans, fallen in love with city
    • City now literally underwater, speaker very emotionally affected

Initial Response and Escalation

  • Examined other car: barely visible pencil-line mark on crease
  • Told other driver he shouldn't care about minor damage
  • Arguments made to driver:
    • Such claims why LA car insurance rates expensive
    • Cars get dings/dents all time, stupid to care
    • More important things in life (Hurricane Katrina)
  • Offer: donate $836 to Red Cross Katrina relief in his name if he didn't file claim
  • Driver said he'd think it over

Media Campaign Development

  • Speaker told friends about "awesome" gesture
  • Friends began pledging additional money
  • Escalation: $2,000 → $5,000 → $25,000+ in 1.5 days
  • Hundreds of people pledged across country
  • Other driver completely unaware of campaign
  • Created blog with hourly updates
  • Received media inquiries (news programs, NPR)
  • Dream: rescue New Orleans single-handedly with computer and "fire hose of self-righteous anger"

Moral Awakening and Self-Doubt

  • Speaker and JJ simultaneously felt sick to stomach
  • Both overcome with awful feeling something very wrong
  • Couldn't pinpoint exact problem
  • Realizations:
    • Driver cared about car damage, speaker didn't - was that wrong?
    • Small negotiation not worth fury/rage/shame being directed at driver
  • Response: crying, hiding under bed, reading philosophy

Philosophy Education Journey

  • Called philosophy professors for discussions
  • All professors willing to talk (love discussing philosophy)
  • Learned theories from smartest people over 2,500 years
  • Goal: make better decisions, become better people

Immanuel Kant - Categorical Imperative

  • Must design universal rule/maxim before acting
  • Test: what if everyone did this action?
  • Speaker's maxim: drag unrelated global calamity into any negotiation, tell other person they shouldn't care about their concerns
  • Result: terrible world (example: sister borrowing $5, deflecting with polar ice caps)
  • Also violated: treat people as ends in themselves, not means to end
  • Speaker was using other person to get what he wanted

Aristotle - Virtue Ethics

  • Certain qualities everyone should have: generosity, courage, friendliness, mildness
  • Practice daily to have exact right amount (not deficiency or excess)
  • Virtue ethics can be maddeningly imprecise
  • Speaker's assessment: excess anger, deficiency of friendliness
  • "Definitely was not getting it exactly right"

Utilitarianism - Bentham and Mill

  • Only care about results of actions
  • Create more happiness/pleasure than pain/suffering
  • Initial hope: enormous money to people in need outweighs pain caused to one person
  • But must consider broader societal impact
  • Everyone knowing this happened would fear it could happen to them
  • Society becomes "bummed out and sad"
  • Total pain/suffering might outweigh happiness created

Resolution and Outcome

  • No straightforward philosophical answer (Aristotle never wrote about fender benders with horse-drawn carriages)
  • Felt all great philosophers would disapprove:
    • Bentham and Mill: disappointed
    • Aristotle: annoyed
    • Kant: disapproving finger wave
  • Called other driver, apologized profusely, told entire story
  • Driver was kind and forgiving (enormous relief)
  • Already cut check, mailed it
  • Updated blog with outcome
  • Most people thought happy outcome
  • Encouraged Red Cross donations anyway
  • Final result: $25,000+ donated to Hurricane Katrina relief

Why Continue Studying Moral Philosophy

  • Analogy: Jeopardy preparation (trivia books, atlas) vs. half-court shot ($50,000 prize - basketball practice at YMCA)
  • Likely never be on Jeopardy or take NBA half-court shot
  • Guaranteed: will face complicated, confusing, gut-wrenching moral dilemmas
  • Fact of life on Earth
  • Dilemmas with no clear rules, only vague investigation where everything seems wrong

Preparation and Practice Value

  • Reading ethics theories helps understand:
    • What they say and mean
    • How they help make better decisions
    • How to become better people
  • No guarantee of making right choice in complex ethical dilemmas
  • Like basketball: practice doesn't guarantee success under pressure (15,000 screaming fans, likely air ball)
  • But preparation increases odds of success
  • Increases chances of "sinking shot" or getting "close enough to rim" to avoid embarrassment/becoming meme
  • Understanding ethical theories increases chances of success "at simply being human beings who have to negotiate with other human beings"
  • Speaker considers this most important thing

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome