AI summary by TwinMind
How Ethics Can Help You Make Better Decisions | Michael Schur | TED
TED
11m 31s
Personal Background and Rule-Following Nature
- 25-year television comedy writer (sketches, animated shows, sitcoms)
- Last decade focused on ethics study
- Lifelong intense rule follower
- Kindergarten: immediately lined up when teacher said, frustrated with others who didn't
- Mouthwash: used for exactly 30 seconds nightly per label instructions
The 2005 Fender Bender Incident
- Wife JJ bumped car in slow traffic
- Police saw no damage, parties exchanged numbers
- Days later: other driver demanded $836 for entire fender replacement
- Occurred during Hurricane Katrina
- Speaker and JJ had recently visited New Orleans, fallen in love with city
- City now literally underwater, speaker very emotionally affected
Initial Response and Escalation
- Examined other car: barely visible pencil-line mark on crease
- Told other driver he shouldn't care about minor damage
- Arguments made to driver:
- Such claims why LA car insurance rates expensive
- Cars get dings/dents all time, stupid to care
- More important things in life (Hurricane Katrina)
- Offer: donate $836 to Red Cross Katrina relief in his name if he didn't file claim
- Driver said he'd think it over
Media Campaign Development
- Speaker told friends about "awesome" gesture
- Friends began pledging additional money
- Escalation: $2,000 → $5,000 → $25,000+ in 1.5 days
- Hundreds of people pledged across country
- Other driver completely unaware of campaign
- Created blog with hourly updates
- Received media inquiries (news programs, NPR)
- Dream: rescue New Orleans single-handedly with computer and "fire hose of self-righteous anger"
Moral Awakening and Self-Doubt
- Speaker and JJ simultaneously felt sick to stomach
- Both overcome with awful feeling something very wrong
- Couldn't pinpoint exact problem
- Realizations:
- Driver cared about car damage, speaker didn't - was that wrong?
- Small negotiation not worth fury/rage/shame being directed at driver
- Response: crying, hiding under bed, reading philosophy
Philosophy Education Journey
- Called philosophy professors for discussions
- All professors willing to talk (love discussing philosophy)
- Learned theories from smartest people over 2,500 years
- Goal: make better decisions, become better people
Immanuel Kant - Categorical Imperative
- Must design universal rule/maxim before acting
- Test: what if everyone did this action?
- Speaker's maxim: drag unrelated global calamity into any negotiation, tell other person they shouldn't care about their concerns
- Result: terrible world (example: sister borrowing $5, deflecting with polar ice caps)
- Also violated: treat people as ends in themselves, not means to end
- Speaker was using other person to get what he wanted
Aristotle - Virtue Ethics
- Certain qualities everyone should have: generosity, courage, friendliness, mildness
- Practice daily to have exact right amount (not deficiency or excess)
- Virtue ethics can be maddeningly imprecise
- Speaker's assessment: excess anger, deficiency of friendliness
- "Definitely was not getting it exactly right"
Utilitarianism - Bentham and Mill
- Only care about results of actions
- Create more happiness/pleasure than pain/suffering
- Initial hope: enormous money to people in need outweighs pain caused to one person
- But must consider broader societal impact
- Everyone knowing this happened would fear it could happen to them
- Society becomes "bummed out and sad"
- Total pain/suffering might outweigh happiness created
Resolution and Outcome
- No straightforward philosophical answer (Aristotle never wrote about fender benders with horse-drawn carriages)
- Felt all great philosophers would disapprove:
- Bentham and Mill: disappointed
- Aristotle: annoyed
- Kant: disapproving finger wave
- Called other driver, apologized profusely, told entire story
- Driver was kind and forgiving (enormous relief)
- Already cut check, mailed it
- Updated blog with outcome
- Most people thought happy outcome
- Encouraged Red Cross donations anyway
- Final result: $25,000+ donated to Hurricane Katrina relief
Why Continue Studying Moral Philosophy
- Analogy: Jeopardy preparation (trivia books, atlas) vs. half-court shot ($50,000 prize - basketball practice at YMCA)
- Likely never be on Jeopardy or take NBA half-court shot
- Guaranteed: will face complicated, confusing, gut-wrenching moral dilemmas
- Fact of life on Earth
- Dilemmas with no clear rules, only vague investigation where everything seems wrong
Preparation and Practice Value
- Reading ethics theories helps understand:
- What they say and mean
- How they help make better decisions
- How to become better people
- No guarantee of making right choice in complex ethical dilemmas
- Like basketball: practice doesn't guarantee success under pressure (15,000 screaming fans, likely air ball)
- But preparation increases odds of success
- Increases chances of "sinking shot" or getting "close enough to rim" to avoid embarrassment/becoming meme
- Understanding ethical theories increases chances of success "at simply being human beings who have to negotiate with other human beings"
- Speaker considers this most important thing
