AI summary by TwinMind
How Goldman Sachs Fumbled Credit Cards, Personal Loans and More | WSJ
The Wall Street Journal
6m 35s
Goldman's Consumer Banking Entry (2016-2019)
- 2016: Launched Marcus high-yield savings account as first consumer product
- Built consumer business from scratch hiring executives from consumer lending, tech sector, own bank
- Claimed technology advantage over established consumer banks
- Algorithmic trading expertise
- Risk management capabilities
- Digital distribution strengths
- 2019: Launched Apple Card credit card partnership with major fanfare
- Industry reaction: fascination but skepticism about Goldman's ability to succeed
Rapid Expansion Phase (2020-2021)
- 2020: Rolled out Marcus Pay installment payment product with JetBlue
- Won General Motors credit card bid
- 2021: Nearly poached JetBlue credit card from Barclays
- Led by CEO David Solomon (became CEO 2018)
- Philosophy: "either be real consumer lender offering variety of services or don't do it at all"
- Emphasized big bank advantages: balance sheet, technology investment capability
Internal Problems and Warning Signs
- Consumer business executives disagreed with company decisions, began leaving
- Described internally as "science experiment"
- New cloud platform for consumer products management
- Consumer division felt it was terrible idea
- Costly implementation
- Resulted in product rollout delays
- Summer 2021: Greensky acquisition despite red flags from Goldman partners
- Concerns about indirect consumer access through contractor middlemen
- Price concerns raised
Financial Pressures and Shareholder Concerns
- Consumer lending only 3% of company revenue
- Shareholders frustrated with multiple simultaneous consumer activities
- High expenses from:
- Building different products
- Staffing expansion
- Regulatory compliance costs
- Extended profitability timeline pushed further into future
- 2022: Investment banking business slowed from record 2021 highs
- Consumer unit became problematic expense center without earnings contribution
Strategic Retreat (Fall 2022-Present)
- Fall 2022: Reorganization moved consumer lending to separate unit
- Revealed true costs ("bleeding money bigger and longer than expected")
- Following internal review, scaled back consumer ambitions:
- Ended talks with T-Mobile, Hawaiian Airlines, Expedia for credit card programs
- Stopped issuing personal loans
- Paused Marcus checking account rollout
- Attempting to sell Greensky
- Looking to offload GM and Apple partnerships
- Early 2023: Began discussions with American Express about taking over partnerships
- Massive retreat after only 6 years in consumer space
Current Status and Assessment
- Gained nearly $150 billion in consumer deposits (retained)
- No plans to stop accepting consumer deposits
- Company spokesperson declined comment on missteps
- Consumer foray characterized as "manageable fail"
- Comparison to Morgan Stanley wealth management strategy (initially criticized, later successful)
- Current focus: "extremely focused on growth of asset wealth management platform"
- Shareholder relief about return to Goldman's traditional strengths
- Investors accepting potential losses on business unit sales for future without consumer lending
