AI summary by TwinMind

How Hong Kong Lost the Lead in Semiconductors

Asianometry

13m 37s

Four Asian Tigers Electronics Assembly Origins

  • Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong = "Four Tigers" led regional prosperity
  • All four had deep roots in electronic assembly industry
    • Assembling components into finished goods for export
  • First few decades: Tigers achieved prosperity through this industry
  • 1970s: Industry unsustainable as manufacturers moved to cheaper locations
  • South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore: successfully upscaled and ascended value chain
  • Hong Kong: failed to upgrade, got left behind with lasting consequences

Hong Kong's Economic Transformation

  • Originally shipping node connecting China to world
  • British exports (opium) entered China through Hong Kong
  • Communist revolution closed China to Western exports
  • Korean War led to US embargo on China goods
  • Hong Kong needed economic remake, found success in textiles and electronics
  • Shanghainese textile barons fled mainland, set up in Hong Kong
  • Japanese companies (Sony) began globalizing supply chains
  • Hong Kong offered cheap radio/TV assembly location
  • Early 1960s: Hong Kong = single biggest manufacturer in developing world
  • Built on cheap labor, liberal trade, growing consumer culture abroad

Electronics Industry Dominance

  • Textile industry declined due to rising labor costs
  • Electronics assembly dominated Hong Kong economy
  • Hong Kong assumed "workshop for the world" role (like China today)
  • Sony radio assembly (1959) led to TVs, calculators
  • Fairchild Semiconductors moved electronics assembly to Hong Kong
  • Motorola, National Semiconductors followed
  • Motorola especially critical for future semiconductor industry potential
  • Provided rare opportunity to acquire foreign technology
  • Late 1980s: Hong Kong ahead of Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan in technical sophistication and employment

Value Chain Ascension Challenge

  • Companies competing on "cheaper" always face cheaper competition elsewhere
  • Two paths to defeat challenge (ascending value chain):
    1. Create consumer name brands, go direct to consumer
      • South Korea approach: Samsung, LG, Hyundai
      • China approach: Huawei, Xiaomi
      • Control pricing and consumer relationships
    2. Upgrade technical offerings with sophisticated solutions
      • Taiwan, Singapore: semiconductor foundry industry
      • Cutting-edge, complicated technology only few can do
      • Control ultra-special technology
  • Hong Kong failed both approaches, lost electronics industry

TSMC Founding and Industry Split (1987)

  • TSMC independent foundry model cracked integrated semiconductor industry
  • Created two parallel paths:
    1. Foundries: industrial chip fabrication work
      • Requires government-scale resources, military-style execution
      • Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore embarked with hefty government budgets
    2. Fabless semiconductor makers: chip design, customer relationships
      • Qualcomm, MediaTek, NVIDIA, Apple
      • More profitable than foundries
      • Requires highly educated engineers with entrepreneurial skills

Hong Kong Government Policy Failures

  • Did not encourage R&D-led industrial upgrading in electronics
  • Especially not towards foundries
  • Colonial status: fiscal hands tied to UK's difficult post-WWII situation
  • Fiscally conservative industrial policy emphasizing macro economy
  • Stance: government should not pick winners/losers
  • No tax incentives for individual companies
  • Focused on basic needs: transportation (MTR), public housing, healthcare
  • Lack of industrial manufacturing representation in Legislative Council
  • Policy dominated by financial/trading interests
  • Steered towards free trade, low profit tax, smaller state
  • Political concerns over handover had secondary influence

Land Problem

  • Some government arms tried providing land for industrial factories
  • Industrial estates in Taipo, Ren Long, O created
  • Government pushed land prices higher for revenue generation
  • Majority of government revenues from land sales rather than taxes
  • Manufacturers faced rising labor costs AND surging land rents
  • Electronics assembly industry died, companies moved to China
  • Only knowledge-based functions remained: sales, consultation, account management, marketing
  • Manufacturing employment collapsed, huge worker layoffs
  • Blue collar collapse consequences continue to present day

Hong Kong's Fabless Semiconductor Potential

  • Hong Kong fabless semi-space initially led Taiwan, South Korea rivals
  • Heart of consumer electronics supply chain location advantage
  • Pool of highly educated engineers for multinationals
  • Motorola Hong Kong division strong in microprocessor design (early 1990s)
  • Led development of Dragon Ball microprocessor series
  • Motorola presence could seed entire industry
  • Valence Semiconductor (founded 1985): homegrown champion
    • Offered layout design services to Fujitsu, NEC
    • Grew to designing entire systems
    • Chips in popular consumer products (possibly PlayStation)

Industry Decline and Exodus

  • Valence standout but rest lacked technical capabilities for escape velocity
  • Insufficient know-how, investment capital, government support
  • Motorola decamped, scaled back Hong Kong design center
  • Moved operations to Suzhou, Shanghai, Beijing
  • Spun off smaller design shops: ON Semiconductor, Solomon Systec
  • Tiny shops insufficient to train/sustain semiconductor design ecosystem
  • Talented engineers went abroad for well-paying work
  • Other countries offered attractive deals for multinational corporations
  • Singapore, China especially effective, India and Taiwan competed
  • 2002: Motorola asked Francis Ho (Secretary of Commerce/Economic Development) for state support to stay
  • Request turned down, Motorola left

Lessons and Consequences

  • No administration should take current economic highlights for granted
  • Administration believed in macro economy philosophy: provide market building blocks, market handles rest
  • Philosophy can achieve success for certain industrial policy goals
  • Electronics/semiconductor industries require more government involvement
  • Competitor governments highly involved, offering market-distorting incentives
  • Natural economic adjustment assumption: Hong Kong lost electronics but gained "vibrant finance and services industry"
  • Deindustrialization had costly human consequences
  • Loss of big tax base for government
  • People who lost jobs became permanent losers
  • Workers stayed lost over time

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome