AI summary by TwinMind
How Hong Kong Lost the Lead in Semiconductors
Asianometry
13m 37s
Four Asian Tigers Electronics Assembly Origins
- Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong = "Four Tigers" led regional prosperity
- All four had deep roots in electronic assembly industry
- Assembling components into finished goods for export
- First few decades: Tigers achieved prosperity through this industry
- 1970s: Industry unsustainable as manufacturers moved to cheaper locations
- South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore: successfully upscaled and ascended value chain
- Hong Kong: failed to upgrade, got left behind with lasting consequences
Hong Kong's Economic Transformation
- Originally shipping node connecting China to world
- British exports (opium) entered China through Hong Kong
- Communist revolution closed China to Western exports
- Korean War led to US embargo on China goods
- Hong Kong needed economic remake, found success in textiles and electronics
- Shanghainese textile barons fled mainland, set up in Hong Kong
- Japanese companies (Sony) began globalizing supply chains
- Hong Kong offered cheap radio/TV assembly location
- Early 1960s: Hong Kong = single biggest manufacturer in developing world
- Built on cheap labor, liberal trade, growing consumer culture abroad
Electronics Industry Dominance
- Textile industry declined due to rising labor costs
- Electronics assembly dominated Hong Kong economy
- Hong Kong assumed "workshop for the world" role (like China today)
- Sony radio assembly (1959) led to TVs, calculators
- Fairchild Semiconductors moved electronics assembly to Hong Kong
- Motorola, National Semiconductors followed
- Motorola especially critical for future semiconductor industry potential
- Provided rare opportunity to acquire foreign technology
- Late 1980s: Hong Kong ahead of Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan in technical sophistication and employment
Value Chain Ascension Challenge
- Companies competing on "cheaper" always face cheaper competition elsewhere
- Two paths to defeat challenge (ascending value chain):
- Create consumer name brands, go direct to consumer
- South Korea approach: Samsung, LG, Hyundai
- China approach: Huawei, Xiaomi
- Control pricing and consumer relationships
- Upgrade technical offerings with sophisticated solutions
- Taiwan, Singapore: semiconductor foundry industry
- Cutting-edge, complicated technology only few can do
- Control ultra-special technology
- Create consumer name brands, go direct to consumer
- Hong Kong failed both approaches, lost electronics industry
TSMC Founding and Industry Split (1987)
- TSMC independent foundry model cracked integrated semiconductor industry
- Created two parallel paths:
- Foundries: industrial chip fabrication work
- Requires government-scale resources, military-style execution
- Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore embarked with hefty government budgets
- Fabless semiconductor makers: chip design, customer relationships
- Qualcomm, MediaTek, NVIDIA, Apple
- More profitable than foundries
- Requires highly educated engineers with entrepreneurial skills
- Foundries: industrial chip fabrication work
Hong Kong Government Policy Failures
- Did not encourage R&D-led industrial upgrading in electronics
- Especially not towards foundries
- Colonial status: fiscal hands tied to UK's difficult post-WWII situation
- Fiscally conservative industrial policy emphasizing macro economy
- Stance: government should not pick winners/losers
- No tax incentives for individual companies
- Focused on basic needs: transportation (MTR), public housing, healthcare
- Lack of industrial manufacturing representation in Legislative Council
- Policy dominated by financial/trading interests
- Steered towards free trade, low profit tax, smaller state
- Political concerns over handover had secondary influence
Land Problem
- Some government arms tried providing land for industrial factories
- Industrial estates in Taipo, Ren Long, O created
- Government pushed land prices higher for revenue generation
- Majority of government revenues from land sales rather than taxes
- Manufacturers faced rising labor costs AND surging land rents
- Electronics assembly industry died, companies moved to China
- Only knowledge-based functions remained: sales, consultation, account management, marketing
- Manufacturing employment collapsed, huge worker layoffs
- Blue collar collapse consequences continue to present day
Hong Kong's Fabless Semiconductor Potential
- Hong Kong fabless semi-space initially led Taiwan, South Korea rivals
- Heart of consumer electronics supply chain location advantage
- Pool of highly educated engineers for multinationals
- Motorola Hong Kong division strong in microprocessor design (early 1990s)
- Led development of Dragon Ball microprocessor series
- Motorola presence could seed entire industry
- Valence Semiconductor (founded 1985): homegrown champion
- Offered layout design services to Fujitsu, NEC
- Grew to designing entire systems
- Chips in popular consumer products (possibly PlayStation)
Industry Decline and Exodus
- Valence standout but rest lacked technical capabilities for escape velocity
- Insufficient know-how, investment capital, government support
- Motorola decamped, scaled back Hong Kong design center
- Moved operations to Suzhou, Shanghai, Beijing
- Spun off smaller design shops: ON Semiconductor, Solomon Systec
- Tiny shops insufficient to train/sustain semiconductor design ecosystem
- Talented engineers went abroad for well-paying work
- Other countries offered attractive deals for multinational corporations
- Singapore, China especially effective, India and Taiwan competed
- 2002: Motorola asked Francis Ho (Secretary of Commerce/Economic Development) for state support to stay
- Request turned down, Motorola left
Lessons and Consequences
- No administration should take current economic highlights for granted
- Administration believed in macro economy philosophy: provide market building blocks, market handles rest
- Philosophy can achieve success for certain industrial policy goals
- Electronics/semiconductor industries require more government involvement
- Competitor governments highly involved, offering market-distorting incentives
- Natural economic adjustment assumption: Hong Kong lost electronics but gained "vibrant finance and services industry"
- Deindustrialization had costly human consequences
- Loss of big tax base for government
- People who lost jobs became permanent losers
- Workers stayed lost over time
