AI summary by TwinMind
How I learned to love pseudoscience
Sabine Hossenfelder
13m 13s
Definition and Evolution of Pseudoscience
- Pseudoscience defined as theories conflicting with evidence, promoted by denying evidence/scientific method or ignorance
- Historical examples of former "science" now considered pseudoscience:
- Astrology: once respectable discipline, every king/queen had personal astrologer
- Early medical practices: snake oil (boiling snakes in oil), tapeworms for weight loss
- Some "pseudoscientific" theories later proven correct:
- Continental drift/tectonic plates: considered pseudoscience until Evans confirmed
- Atomic theory: initially decried as pseudoscience due to unobservable atoms
Pseudoscience as Natural Byproduct of Science
- Inevitable consequence of scientific progress
- Some people cling to falsified theories longer than reasonable
- Some "crazy ideas" eventually proven correct
- Functions as necessary component rather than just evil
Development of Single-Blind Trials: Mesmerism Case
- Franz Mesmer (German physician) claimed discovery of universal fluid penetrating universe/human body
- Theory: blocked fluid flow caused illness, could be controlled through magnetism
- Body had magnetic poles: north (head, fluid entry from stars), south (feet, connected to Earth's magnetic field)
- Mesmer's Paris practice (1778):
- 30+ patients magnetized simultaneously around oak case (1 foot high)
- Case filled with powdered glass and iron filings
- Jointed iron branches through lid holes held by patients
- Subdued light, absolute silence, patients bound by cord in concentric rows
- Mesmer wore lilac silk coat, carried long iron wand
- Walked among patients touching diseased body parts
- Patients frequently reported feeling significantly better
- Benjamin Franklin and Antoine Lavoisier debunked mesmerism:
- Blindfolded patient groups
- Some told they'd receive treatment but didn't
- Others received treatment without knowledge
- Found effects related to belief in treatment, not actual treatment
- Established psychological vs physical benefits
- Led to development of single-blind trial methodology
Development of Double-Blind Trials: Homeopathy Case
- Homeopathy invented by German Samuel Hahnemann
- Theory: diluting natural substances makes them more effective for treating illness
- 1835 experiment by Friedrich Wilhelm von Hoven (Nuremberg public health official):
- Dispute with homeopath Johann Jacob Reuter
- Reuter claimed: 1 grain salt in 100 drops water, diluted 30 times by factor of 100 produced extraordinary sensations
- Von Hoven's experimental design:
- 50 homeopathic salt water samples (following Reuter's recipe)
- 50 plain water samples (placebo)
- Samples numbered and randomly assigned through repeated shuffling
- 100 vials labeled consecutively, mixed, placed on two tables
- Dr. Luna recorded contents in sealed list
- Neither von Hoven nor patients knew assignments
- Results after 3 weeks:
- 50 participants total
- Only 8 experienced unusual effects
- 5 received homeopathic dilution, 3 received water
- Effect not statistically significant
- Von Hoven member of "Society of Truth-Loving Men" (skeptical society countering 19th century quackery)
Historical Skeptical Societies and Drug Regulation
- Society of Truth-Loving Men: one of many 19th century skeptical societies
- Oldest existing skeptical society: founded 1881 in Netherlands
- Called "Vereniging tegen de Kwakzalverij" (Society Against Quackery)
- Awarded annual "Master Charlatan Prize" to discourage quackery
- Still active today
- Led to governmental drug regulation:
- Netherlands: among first countries with drug regulation
- UK: first country with 1868 Pharmacy Act
- Modern skeptical societies historically fought pseudoscience, provided scientific information
Statistical Significance Development: Telepathy Testing
- Late 19th century telepathy belief among prominent figures
- Nobel Prize winners Lord Rayleigh and Charles Richet proposed testing:
- One person draws random playing card, concentrates
- Another person guesses card
- Results compared against random chance
- Method essentially modern statistical significance calculation
Philosophy of Science Origins
- Karl Popper developed falsification demarcation criterion
- Motivated by desire to show Marxism and Freud's psychoanalysis weren't proper science
- Though falsification not best method, work instrumental to philosophy of science discipline
- Entire field emerged from fighting pseudoscience
Modern Pseudoscience Challenges
- Ongoing fight requires constant method updates
- Current examples of likely future pseudoscience:
- Foundations of physics research on multiverses
- Unobservable particles research
- Predicted to be considered pseudoscience in 50 years
- Medical quackery continues:
- COVID remedies that come and go
- Modern fight focuses on getting relevant information to those who need it
- Forces scientists to improve:
- Develop methods to identify fake studies
- Explain why results can't be trusted
- Improve communication skills
Safety Warning and Resources
- Homeopathic remedies warning: not all strongly diluted
- Some contain barely diluted active plant ingredients
- Can be dangerous when overdosed
- Check labels carefully before assuming "just water and sugar"
- Recommended reading: Michael Jordan's "On the Fringe" (history of pseudoscience)
