AI summary by TwinMind
How New York Became America’s Fastest Shrinking State
RealLifeLore
30m 46s
US Population Changes 2020-2023
- Census Bureau data: April 2020 - July 2023 population changes by county
- Growth areas: Washington, Idaho, Western Montana, Utah, Colorado Front Range, Arizona, Texas triangle, Florida, Georgia, Tennessee, Carolinas, Northern Virginia
- Decline areas: California, Lower Mississippi Basin (Louisiana/Mississippi), Illinois, upper Appalachia (Eastern Kentucky, West Virginia, western Pennsylvania), New York State
New York State's Population Crisis
- New York became fastest shrinking state in America 2020-2023
- Lost net 630,000 residents April 2020 - July 2023
- 90% of state losses from NYC alone (550,000+ residents)
- NYC population decreased 6.2% in 3 years
- Equivalent to entire Wyoming population lost
- Continuing 0.5% annual decline 2022-2023
- Worst losses since 1970s
Historical Context of NY Political Power
- Most populous state 1810-1960s (150+ years)
- Peak influence 1940: 10% of Americans were New Yorkers
- Had 45 House seats (10% of total) in 1940
- Lost political power as other regions grew faster
- California overtook as most populous by 1970
- Texas surpassed by 2000, Florida by 2014
- Now 4th most populous state
- Lost House seats every decade since 1950
- Down to 26 seats in 2020 (half of 1940 peak)
- Risk losing 3 more seats by 2030 census
Geographic and Economic Divide
- Upstate vs Downstate cultural/economic split
- 51% of state population lives on islands (Long Island, Manhattan)
- 2/3 of population in 4% of land area (southern region)
- Downstate: urban, dense, wealthy
- Upstate: rural, sparse, less affluent
Erie Canal Era and Industrial History
- Erie Canal completed 1825: first Atlantic-Great Lakes route
- Created competitive advantage for NY ports
- Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, Albany grew along canal
- Called "America's first Super Highway"
- Expanded 1905-1918
- Buffalo ranked top 10 US cities 1900-1910
- By 1950 Buffalo metro nearly same size as Queens
Upstate Decline Beginning 1950s
- St. Lawrence Seaway opened 1959: bypassed Erie Canal
- Interstate highway system (1956) competed with canal trade
- Final commercial Erie Canal service ended 1994
- Manufacturing moved overseas (China)
- De-industrialization favored service sector
- Buffalo lost 50%+ of peak population 1950-2010
- Rochester, Syracuse each lost 33%+ of peak population
- Upstate decline lasted until 2010s stabilization
Pre-Pandemic Warning Signs 2016-2019
- NYC growth stagnated, slight decreases
- Upstate decline stabilized, some increases
- 2016: first population loss in decade (0.1%)
- Increasing losses 2017-2019
- 2020 census: 20.2 million peak population
COVID-19 Impact March 2020
- First case March 1, 2020
- 30,000+ cases by end of March
- Strictest lockdowns in country
- Theaters, gyms, venues closed March 17
- Restaurants takeout/delivery only
- Pause order March 22: all non-essential businesses closed
- Phase reopening began June 2020
- Full restrictions lifted June 2021
Pandemic Consequences
- 45,000+ COVID deaths in NYC
- Unemployment hit 16% (August 2020, 2x national average)
- Thousands of businesses permanently closed
- Crime rates surged: 2023 assaults highest on record since 1990s
- Overall crime at highest level since 2006
Population Loss Factors
Remote Work Impact
- High earners could relocate while keeping jobs
- $250,000 income purchasing power: only $82,400 in NYC
- Top 2% pay 51% of state taxes
- Each wealthy departure = major tax revenue loss
Demographics and Migration
- Larger elderly population than TX/CA
- Retirees moving to Florida (no retirement income tax)
- Top destinations: Florida (91,000), New Jersey (75,000)
- 2021-2022 migration data
Housing Affordability Crisis
- 68% housing cost increase 2011-2022 (highest in nation)
- Average household spends $30,000/year on housing (40% of median income vs 34% national)
- Price-to-income ratio: 9.8 years (5th highest nationally)
- Average 1-bedroom rent: $4,200/month (highest in country)
- 11% year-over-year rent increase 2023
Income Requirements
- Single adult needs $138,000 salary to live comfortably
- Family of 4 needs $318,000 household income (top 5%)
- 33%+ of renters spend 50%+ of income on rent
- Departing demographics: $32,000-$65,000 earners (largest group), $65,000-$172,000 earners (second largest)
Housing Supply Crisis
- Job growth outpaced housing construction 40+ years
- 2010-2021: 21% job increase, only 9% housing increase
- Manhattan mostly built up, surrounded by water
- High construction costs, interest rates post-pandemic
- Only luxury housing profitable due to costs/regulations
- Dallas, Houston, Austin each permit more housing than entire NY State
Wealth Inequality
- Manhattan: top 1/5 earn 53x more than bottom 1/5
- 2013: 1 in 36 residents millionaire
- 2023: 1 in 24 residents millionaire
- 350,000+ millionaires in NYC
- More millionaires than any city globally
- NYC millionaires = Cleveland's total population
- More millionaires than LA + Chicago combined
Borough-Level Changes
- Outer boroughs (Queens, Brooklyn, Staten Island, Bronx) declining
- Manhattan returned to growth 2022-2023
- Manhattan still 97,000 below pre-pandemic levels
- Pattern: lower/middle class leaving, wealthy arriving
Future Projections
- 2023: 0.5% population decline continues
- Remains fastest shrinking state
- Summer 2023-2024 data due end of year
- Likely return to 2016-2019 trend
- Housing shortage = continued lower/middle class exodus
- Continued wealthy resident attraction
