AI summary by TwinMind

How New York Became America’s Fastest Shrinking State

RealLifeLore

30m 46s

US Population Changes 2020-2023

  • Census Bureau data: April 2020 - July 2023 population changes by county
  • Growth areas: Washington, Idaho, Western Montana, Utah, Colorado Front Range, Arizona, Texas triangle, Florida, Georgia, Tennessee, Carolinas, Northern Virginia
  • Decline areas: California, Lower Mississippi Basin (Louisiana/Mississippi), Illinois, upper Appalachia (Eastern Kentucky, West Virginia, western Pennsylvania), New York State

New York State's Population Crisis

  • New York became fastest shrinking state in America 2020-2023
  • Lost net 630,000 residents April 2020 - July 2023
  • 90% of state losses from NYC alone (550,000+ residents)
  • NYC population decreased 6.2% in 3 years
  • Equivalent to entire Wyoming population lost
  • Continuing 0.5% annual decline 2022-2023
  • Worst losses since 1970s

Historical Context of NY Political Power

  • Most populous state 1810-1960s (150+ years)
  • Peak influence 1940: 10% of Americans were New Yorkers
  • Had 45 House seats (10% of total) in 1940
  • Lost political power as other regions grew faster
  • California overtook as most populous by 1970
  • Texas surpassed by 2000, Florida by 2014
  • Now 4th most populous state
  • Lost House seats every decade since 1950
  • Down to 26 seats in 2020 (half of 1940 peak)
  • Risk losing 3 more seats by 2030 census

Geographic and Economic Divide

  • Upstate vs Downstate cultural/economic split
  • 51% of state population lives on islands (Long Island, Manhattan)
  • 2/3 of population in 4% of land area (southern region)
  • Downstate: urban, dense, wealthy
  • Upstate: rural, sparse, less affluent

Erie Canal Era and Industrial History

  • Erie Canal completed 1825: first Atlantic-Great Lakes route
  • Created competitive advantage for NY ports
  • Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, Albany grew along canal
  • Called "America's first Super Highway"
  • Expanded 1905-1918
  • Buffalo ranked top 10 US cities 1900-1910
  • By 1950 Buffalo metro nearly same size as Queens

Upstate Decline Beginning 1950s

  • St. Lawrence Seaway opened 1959: bypassed Erie Canal
  • Interstate highway system (1956) competed with canal trade
  • Final commercial Erie Canal service ended 1994
  • Manufacturing moved overseas (China)
  • De-industrialization favored service sector
  • Buffalo lost 50%+ of peak population 1950-2010
  • Rochester, Syracuse each lost 33%+ of peak population
  • Upstate decline lasted until 2010s stabilization

Pre-Pandemic Warning Signs 2016-2019

  • NYC growth stagnated, slight decreases
  • Upstate decline stabilized, some increases
  • 2016: first population loss in decade (0.1%)
  • Increasing losses 2017-2019
  • 2020 census: 20.2 million peak population

COVID-19 Impact March 2020

  • First case March 1, 2020
  • 30,000+ cases by end of March
  • Strictest lockdowns in country
  • Theaters, gyms, venues closed March 17
  • Restaurants takeout/delivery only
  • Pause order March 22: all non-essential businesses closed
  • Phase reopening began June 2020
  • Full restrictions lifted June 2021

Pandemic Consequences

  • 45,000+ COVID deaths in NYC
  • Unemployment hit 16% (August 2020, 2x national average)
  • Thousands of businesses permanently closed
  • Crime rates surged: 2023 assaults highest on record since 1990s
  • Overall crime at highest level since 2006

Population Loss Factors

Remote Work Impact

  • High earners could relocate while keeping jobs
  • $250,000 income purchasing power: only $82,400 in NYC
  • Top 2% pay 51% of state taxes
  • Each wealthy departure = major tax revenue loss

Demographics and Migration

  • Larger elderly population than TX/CA
  • Retirees moving to Florida (no retirement income tax)
  • Top destinations: Florida (91,000), New Jersey (75,000)
  • 2021-2022 migration data

Housing Affordability Crisis

  • 68% housing cost increase 2011-2022 (highest in nation)
  • Average household spends $30,000/year on housing (40% of median income vs 34% national)
  • Price-to-income ratio: 9.8 years (5th highest nationally)
  • Average 1-bedroom rent: $4,200/month (highest in country)
  • 11% year-over-year rent increase 2023

Income Requirements

  • Single adult needs $138,000 salary to live comfortably
  • Family of 4 needs $318,000 household income (top 5%)
  • 33%+ of renters spend 50%+ of income on rent
  • Departing demographics: $32,000-$65,000 earners (largest group), $65,000-$172,000 earners (second largest)

Housing Supply Crisis

  • Job growth outpaced housing construction 40+ years
  • 2010-2021: 21% job increase, only 9% housing increase
  • Manhattan mostly built up, surrounded by water
  • High construction costs, interest rates post-pandemic
  • Only luxury housing profitable due to costs/regulations
  • Dallas, Houston, Austin each permit more housing than entire NY State

Wealth Inequality

  • Manhattan: top 1/5 earn 53x more than bottom 1/5
  • 2013: 1 in 36 residents millionaire
  • 2023: 1 in 24 residents millionaire
  • 350,000+ millionaires in NYC
  • More millionaires than any city globally
  • NYC millionaires = Cleveland's total population
  • More millionaires than LA + Chicago combined

Borough-Level Changes

  • Outer boroughs (Queens, Brooklyn, Staten Island, Bronx) declining
  • Manhattan returned to growth 2022-2023
  • Manhattan still 97,000 below pre-pandemic levels
  • Pattern: lower/middle class leaving, wealthy arriving

Future Projections

  • 2023: 0.5% population decline continues
  • Remains fastest shrinking state
  • Summer 2023-2024 data due end of year
  • Likely return to 2016-2019 trend
  • Housing shortage = continued lower/middle class exodus
  • Continued wealthy resident attraction

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome