AI summary by TwinMind
How Retail Cheese Prices Weather Market Volatility | WSJ Price Index
The Wall Street Journal
6m 9s
CME Cheese Trading Overview
- Chicago Mercantile Exchange hosts 10-minute electronic trading sessions at 11 AM daily
- Trades 40-pound blocks and 500-pound barrels of wholesale American cheddar cheese
- Only cheeses traded on commodity markets
- Blocks: sliced/shredded for grocery stores, restaurants
- Barrels: primarily processed cheese products
- Cheese sellers nationwide monitor CME prices, especially blocks
COVID-19 Market Volatility (2020)
- Wild price swings attributed to first coronavirus lockdowns
- Schools and restaurants closed, halting bulk purchases
- Initial drop when bulk orders dried up early 2020
- Government intervention: Farmers to Family Food Box Program
- $100 million/month dairy product purchases including cheese
- Multiple basket types: dairy basket, milk basket
- Products distributed through local food centers
- Price explosion during program due to huge volume requirements in narrow window
- After few months, prices returned slightly lower than pre-pandemic levels
- Customers purchased vast quantities at retail stores
Retail Price Stability vs Wholesale Volatility
- Consumer cheese prices remained stable despite CME swings
- Retail stability contrasts with other foods (ground beef, eggs, apples showed more volatility)
- Some inflation present but CME-style swings largely absent from retail
Price Smoothing Mechanism
- Andrew Novakovich (agricultural economist, 40+ years experience) explains price smoothing
- Grocery stores don't reflect rapid wholesale increases fully
- Stores anticipate recouping margins when prices recede
- Consumers see much smoother price effects vs wholesale roller coaster
Consumer Expectations and Pricing Strategy
- Customer expectations influence grocery pricing strategies
- Apples example: seasonal growth creates expected price fluctuations
- Cheese considerations:
- Perishable nature
- More frequent purchases than other foods
- Higher likelihood customers notice price changes
- Incentive for grocers to maintain stable pricing
Cross-Cheese Market Impact
- Swiss cheese example: no spot/futures markets exist
- Swiss producers use cheddar pricing insights for valuation
- Swiss typically priced higher than cheddar
- When cheddar prices swing, wholesale prices of other cheeses follow
Artisanal Cheese Industry Response
- Aaron Weiswall (artisanal creamery owner) case study
- 2020: one of best years due to farm markets and direct sales
- Public avoided retail stores, preferred direct purchases
- Farmstead creamery model:
- Produce own milk on-site
- Age cheeses in on-site cave
- Direct-to-consumer sales bypass volatile wholesale markets
2021 Challenges
- Labor shortages affecting artisanal operations
- Producing/selling everything made but longer hours required
- Can't find sufficient workers
- Supply chain pressures throughout economy
- Adaptation strategies:
- Increasing minimum customer purchase requirements
- Changing delivery minimums
- Increasing delivery prices
- Holding cheese prices steady (no increases ~5 years)
- Uncertainty about price sustainability if conditions continue
