AI summary by TwinMind

How Taiwan Created TSMC

Asianometry

12m 14s

Background and Challenge (Early 1970s)

  • Taiwan faced economic transition challenge - needed to upscale from agricultural/simple electronics assembly
  • Economy consisted mostly of agricultural products and low-value electronic assembly exports
  • Previous attempts to build world-competitive chemical industry failed
  • Semiconductor industry identified as next logical step for electronics assembly industry
  • US dominated semiconductor manufacturing, Japan secondary player
  • Taiwan hosted few foreign factories (General Instruments since 1966) for low-value assembly only
  • Taiwanese companies lagged far behind cutting edge, no market credibility

Government Strategy Debate

  • Ministry of Economic Affairs debated best approach
  • Sun Yun Shen (Minister of Economic Affairs, born in Shandong): backed entrance to development of companies and industry
  • Wai Shan Ran (Director of National Science Council): argued for funding basic electric engineering sciences for semiconductors to "root" industry in Taiwan
  • Jianjin Guo (Premier, Chiang Kai-shek's son): opposed basic research, favored applied research for industrial purposes
  • Decision: Focus on applied research and practical skills became consistent theme

ITRI Formation and Technology Transfer

  • Founded Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI) as publicly funded laboratory
  • Purpose: Applied science research with intention to spin off projects as private companies
  • ITRI created subcommittee ERSO to tackle semiconductor industry entry
  • Strategy: Invite foreign companies from US/Europe to teach Taiwanese specific semiconductor technologies

RCA Technology Transfer Agreement (1976)

  • 7 companies invited to bid for contract
  • RCA won over General Instruments and Hughes
  • Chosen not for most advanced technology but for willingness/capability to teach
  • Agreement: RCA invited 30-40 Taiwanese engineers to campus for 1 year
  • Training included: raw science of semiconductors, management techniques, industrial knowledge
  • RCA provided licensing for technology few years behind cutting edge
  • Lucky break: RCA later exited semiconductor industry, left Taiwan with license for all technologies

CMOS Technology Choice

  • Taiwan chose to learn Complementary Metal Oxide Semiconductors (CMOS)
  • CMOS had not fully matured, small market at time
  • Over time became dominant semiconductor manufacturing process technology
  • Government acted as venture capitalist, backed young technology that paid off significantly

UMC Formation and Early Results (1980)

  • ERSO spun off United Microelectronics Corporation (UMC) in 1980
  • UMC headquarters across street from TSMC in Xinjiu
  • Used RCA knowledge, acted as traditional vertically integrated semiconductor maker
  • Government provided technology, helped recruit talent, closed first deal
  • UMC became Taiwan's most profitable industrial manufacturer
  • Failed to be flagship success - could not compete in industry
  • Produced low-level chips for toys and watches
  • Field too competitive for breakthrough success
  • ERSO spun off 2 other chip design companies - both failed, acquired by competitors

TSMC Formation and Success

  • Represented innovative foundry business model disrupting existing semiconductor market
  • Entered with much more advanced technology than UMC
  • Technology from Dutch corporation Philips (continuing Dutch-Taiwanese ties)
  • Philips provided 1.5 micron process technology input for TSMC's core service
  • ERSO sourced high-skilled Taiwanese workers
  • Taiwan government invested money but wanted private investors for market oversight
  • Philips received substantial chunk of TSMC shares
  • Intel and Texas Instruments offered investment chance but passed
  • Taiwanese businessmen offered/ordered to invest
  • Wang Ching (Formosa Plastics titan) bought 5% because government required, sold after IPO year 2, missed $20 billion fortune

TSMC Strategy Differences

  • Focused on international export market from beginning (government request + Morris Chang's American background)
  • Helped fuel fabless semiconductor trend in America
  • UMC focused on domestic market initially - made company too comfortable, didn't become world-class
  • Key lesson: Need to compete across entire world to create world-class firm

Government Development Strategy

  • Small companies clustered together, guided by government
  • Contrast with South Korea: gave lots of money to special companies (Samsung, LG, etc.) to dominate sectors
  • Silicon Valley used as guide
  • Founded many small companies in different parts of semiconductor value chain
  • Provided starting boost, arranged resources including housing (Hsinchu Science Park)
  • Tax incentives: semiconductor companies taxed at just 1.5% in early 1990s
  • No subsidies pumping or competition shielding once companies started
  • No protective tariffs for captive domestic market
  • Did not prop up failing companies (contrast with Latin America/Europe domestic industry strategies)
  • Government helped industry as whole during existential threats (earthquake example: state utilities provided water/power to Hsinchu Science Park first over residential areas)

Success Factors Beyond Government Control

  • Reverse brain drain from Western countries to Taiwan (1980s-90s)
    • Booming Taiwanese economy
    • Surge in Chinese nationalism over Diaoyu Islands sovereignty
    • Taiwan as "free China" benefited from overseas Chinese returning to help motherland
  • Timing and luck factors crucial
  • Singapore tried similar strategy few years later with mixed results

Key Lessons for Developing Countries

  • Partner with more advanced foreign technologies
  • Stress test products in global competitive landscape
  • Success never preordained - hard work plus right place/right time
  • Applicable to Chinese government's semiconductor strategy development

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome