AI summary by TwinMind
How Taiwan Makes Your Shoes
Asianometry
15m 49s
Global Athletic Footwear Industry Overview
- Nike: $250 billion company
- Athletes earn hundreds of millions from shoe endorsements
- Vintage Jordan 1s trade for thousands on StockX
- Big brands outsource manufacturing to third parties
- Low-wage labor in Asia produces shoes
- Biggest branded maker from Taiwan: 300 million pairs annually
PCC Origins and Early Development (1969-1970s)
- 1969: Tai Yu Yen founded Baochan Group (PCC) in Fushing, Dunhua County
- Started as small 10-person factory producing traditional woven footwear
- Japanese dominated US market: 48 million pairs/year, 80% share
- Taiwan/South Korea eventually overtook Japanese dominance
Taiwan's Plastic Technology Foundation
- 1950s: Guamindan regime seized Japanese oil refinery in Gauchon
- Government used American aid to refine petroleum into plastics
- Manufacturers experimented weaving plastic fibers for straw hats
- Applied same techniques to shoe uppers
- Combined plastic uppers with cheap plastic insoles
- PCC switched from woven to plastic shoes for domestic market
Export Market Expansion (Mid-1960s-1970s)
- Mid-1960s: Japanese shoe manufacturers faced labor shortages
- Kobe/Himeji companies moved factories to Taiwan
- Taiwanese companies exported to Japan initially
- Late 1960s: Industry formed Taiwan Plastic Shoe Exporters Association (TPC)
- Redirected exports toward US market
- Taiwan became heart of shoe industry
First US Company Entry
- ES Original: First American company building Asian factories for US import
- President Ellis Saftey ordered 50,000 dozen sandals
- Sandals sold to JCPenney: 62.5 cents/pair, retailed $1
- Factory grew rapidly
Taiwan's Export Boom (1968-1973)
- 1968-1973: Taiwan exported 200 million pairs
- Footwear factories increased 10x
- Shoe exports doubled 1969-1970 alone
- 1973: Taiwan replaced Italy as US leading shoe import source
- Taiwan became world's largest footwear manufacturer
US Manufacturing Decline
- Post-WWII: US made all shoes domestically
- Early 1960s: 250,000 Americans employed, 700+ companies, 600 million pairs/year
- 1966: East Asian cheap imports began devastating US industry
- American job losses led to political pressure for import barriers
Trade Restrictions and Market Shift (1977-1978)
- 1977: Taiwan agreed to freeze exports at 1976 levels + 3% growth
- By 1978: PCC grew to 10,000 employees, facilities in 2 cities
- Produced boots, shoe parts, women's shoes
- Export limits forced Taiwan industry to move upmarket
- Invaded remaining American shoe manufacturing
Athletic Footwear Strategy
- PCC decided to make athletic footwear
- Two reasons:
- Longer production runs vs women's shoes (retooled yearly)
- Higher prices: $5/unit vs $2-3/unit for women's shoes due to competition
Nike and Athletic Endorsements
- Nike/Adidas dominate athletic footwear
- 1984: Nike signed Michael Jordan, stealing from Adidas
- Jordan brand: Nike's 85% market share in performance basketball
- Jordan brand: $4.7 billion revenue fiscal 2021
- Nike's fastest growing segment: 30%+ year-over-year growth
- Jordan retired 15+ years ago but name still sells
- Other endorsers: Kanye West's Yeezy line
Manufacturing Complexity
- Footwear production remains labor-intensive
- Western companies moved upstream to most profitable roles
- Brands accrue most industry profits
PCC's Athletic Shoe Entry (1979)
- PCC bought equipment with no customers initially
- 1979: Struck deal with Adidas as Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM)
- 1971: Adidas first sought Asian OEMs to augment German production
- Originally considered India, but Taiwanese sourcing agent knew Adi Dassler's son-in-law
Brand-OEM Collaboration Process
- Close collaboration between brands and OEMs
- Adidas draws/approves designs with athletes/endorsers
- OEM evaluates feasibility and production costs
- Requires sharing private trade secrets
- Early days: Adidas transferred advanced manufacturing knowledge to Taiwanese OEMs
- Phil Knight (Nike) bypassed Japanese suppliers for direct Taiwan sourcing
- Partnered with former Mitsubishi trading company employee
Athletic Shoe Manufacturing Process
- Among most difficult products in garment industry
- 3D items requiring high quality and comfort
- Two major components:
- Lasted upper: insole (paperboard/fabric) + leather upper
- Sole: outsole (rubber) + midsole (EVA/PU foams)
- Critical "lasting" stage: attach insole to foot-shaped cast ("last"), stitch leather upper around it
- Final step: glue lasted upper and sole together
- Up to 200 separate steps, involves 120+ pairs of hands
- Highly manual: cutting, stitching, lasting, finishing, inspection
Vertical Integration Strategy
- Athletic shoe production requires coordination across industries: leather, plastic, textile, cementing, chemical, paper
- PCC expanded vertically into related industries
- 1990s: Nike wanted environmentally friendly shoeboxes
- PCC joint venture with Chenglong Corporation (major paper company)
- Started producing own resins, glues, shoe parts
- Founded logistics company for production management
- Joint ventures/subsidiaries run own P&L, free to deal with outsiders
- Brand managers compete for business
Corporate Restructuring (1996)
- PCC transferred shoe manufacturing + 67 supply subsidiaries to Hong Kong-listed company: YY Industrial Holdings
- Allowed parent company expansion into: sportswear, retail, hotels, dentures
- Distanced Taiwanese parent from labor issues
Labor Cost Pressures and Overseas Expansion (Late 1980s)
- Taiwanese labor became expensive
- Factors: improving lifestyles, environmental regulations, Taiwan dollar appreciation vs USD
- Higher costs cut into tight margins
- Options: automate or seek cheaper labor abroad
- Athletic shoe production extremely resistant to automation
- Chose overseas expansion
China Operations (1988)
- 1988: Warming PRC-ROC relations encouraged expansion
- PCC set up first production facility in Zhuhai City, Guangdong
- Expanded throughout China
- Today: Most athletic shoes made in China, also Indonesia, Vietnam, Cambodia, Myanmar
Factory Conditions and Labor Issues
- Massive facilities: 15,000-20,000 employees (like Foxconn)
- Dormitory-style living provided
- Productivity systems: piece rate quotas, overtime, authoritarian enforcement
- Workers attempt to organize/strike for better conditions
- Management often responds with repression
2014 Dongguan Strike
- 40,000 workers at YY factory stopped working
- Issue: Local government pocketing social insurance contributions
- Aging workforce, factory facing wage pressure from cheaper Vietnam
- Communist Party hostile to large spontaneous labor movements
- Police intervention, national government mediated negotiations
- Resolution: YY raised monthly wages $36, reimbursed missing insurance, added benefits
- Total strike cost: $60 million
- Production shifted to other factories abroad
- Some strikers continued but police repressed further activity
Vietnam Strike (2016)
- YY experienced another major strike in Vietnam
- Company shuffles production between factories to adjust to:
- Labor shortages
- Myanmar unrest
- Pandemic impacts
Other Major Manufacturers
- Fangtai: Prominent large Taiwanese manufacturer, big Nike supplier
- Majority of big OEMs from Taiwan or South Korea
- "The Foxconns of shoes"
Industry Evolution
- Journey from simple factories → design service providers → massive vertically integrated supply chains
- Today: New athletic shoe can be conceptualized, designed, mass-produced in few months
- Complex, well-made objects requiring respect for work and costs involved
