AI summary by TwinMind
How technology changes our sense of right and wrong | Juan Enriquez
TED
7m 29s
Opening Context on Polarization and Moral Discourse
- Extreme polarization makes discussing right/wrong dangerous
- Risk of targeting/judgment for statements made 10 years ago, 10 months ago, 10 hours ago, 10 seconds ago
- Threats from both opponents ("burn you at the stake") and allies ("cancel you" for insufficient orthodoxy)
Three Core Concepts About Right and Wrong
- Right/wrong changes over time
- Right/wrong changes due to technology
- Technology moves exponentially
Historical Examples of Moral Evolution
- Human sacrifice: previously normal/natural for appeasing gods, ensuring rain
- Public executions: common, legal, normal
- Families took children to watch beheadings in Paris streets
- Slavery/indentured servitude: practiced for millennia
- Across Incas, Mayas, Chinese, North/South American Indians
- Key questions: why did something so wrong last so long? Why did it disappear in few short decades legally?
Technology's Role in Ending Slavery
- Extraordinary abolitionists risked lives (acknowledged)
- Energy and industrial revolution as catalyst
- Single barrel of oil = energy equivalent of 5-10 people's work
- Combined with machines = millions of people's equivalent labor
- Results after quitting oppression:
- Doubling in lifespan (after millennia of flat lifespan)
- World economy exploded (after millennia of flatness)
- Enormous wealth/food produced by far fewer hands
Technology Changing Human Interaction
- Machine guns in WWI fundamentally changed warfare
- Drove people into trenches (British vs German)
- No man's land between = death
- Desertion in opposite direction = shot by own side
- Modern parallel: narrowcast social media as today's machine guns
- Shooting at each other with posts, tweets, photographs, accusations, comments
- Created two trenches with almost no middle ground for discussion
Contemporary Polarization Examples
- US lawn signs: "Black Lives Matter" vs "We support the police"
- Rarely both signs on same lawn
- Most people would support both positions if asked
Gay Marriage Opinion Shift
- Complete 180-degree shift in opinion
- Today: two-thirds support
- Causes: protests, people coming out of closet, social media impact
- Technology brought people into homes via television, film, posts
- Friends/neighbors/family comfortable saying "I'm gay"
- Opinion shifted even in conservative places
- Pope Francis example:
- 2010 as Cardinal: completely against gay marriage
- Became Pope, three years later: "Who am I to judge?"
- Today: supports civil unions
Exponential Technology and Ethics
- Technology now moving exponentially
- Right/wrong changes accordingly
- Rigid positions ("I know right, you're wrong") prevent discussion, tolerance, evolution, learning
Future Ethical Shift: Meat Consumption
- Most people not vegetarians yet due to lack of alternatives
- Synthetic meat price drop: $380,000 (2013) to $9 (today)
- Prediction: large chunk becoming vegetarian/quasi-vegetarian
- Future perspective: fancy restaurants with bloody steaks will look different in 10-30 years
Call for Humility and Forgiveness
- Two rarely heard words in polarized times: humility and forgiveness
- Humility when judging past/ancestors/forefathers
- If educated/living in that time, would've done many things wrong
- Not because they're right, but because understanding of right/wrong changes across time
- Forgiveness crucial today
- Cannot cancel people for wrong words, actions from 10 years ago, triggering others
- Must build community through dialogue with different viewpoints
- Need to allow space instead of creating no man's land
- Require middle ground, empathy space
- Final message: time to build community
