AI summary by TwinMind
How the New England Vampire Panics Worked | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
46m 45s
Discovery of JB-55 Grave (1990)
- Kids playing at gravel quarry in Connecticut discovered old graves
- Connecticut state archaeologist Nick Bellantoni called to excavate
- Found lost family cemetery from late 18th/early 19th century
- Most graves buried "Yankee style" - thrifty, bare bones manner
- One grave stood out: JB-55 (likely initials and age)
- Coffin broken, red colored, different from others
- Thigh bones crossed over ribs
- Skull detached from spine, placed on rib cage
- Rib cage broken, coffin smashed
- Body arranged in "Jolly Roger" pirate flag formation
Connection to Vampire Panics
- Bellantoni had never seen anything like it before
- Colleague suggested it might be vampire-related
- Met Michael Bell, Rhode Island folklorist
- Bell revealed: only intact physical evidence of vampire panics that gripped New England late 18th-late 19th century
- Bell documented ~80 exhumations, mostly in Connecticut/Massachusetts/Vermont/New Hampshire/Rhode Island
- Some cases reached as far west as Minnesota
- Contemporaries were shocked by the practice
- Henry David Thoreau wrote about attending one in his journal
Historical Context & Documentation
- Vampire panics happened ~150 years ago, not colonial times
- Well-documented because they occurred relatively recently
- George Stetson (anthropologist) published monograph in late 1890s
- Boston Daily Globe blamed inbreeding for weird behavior
- International news coverage - people worldwide were appalled
- Some thought Stetson was being fooled by rural New Englanders
New England Religious/Social Climate
- Contrary to Puritan stereotype, only 10% belonged to churches in 1800s rural New England
- Rhode Island founded as haven for religious dissenters
- Population was superstitious rather than strictly Christian
- Practiced folk magic: buried shoes by fireplace to catch devil, horseshoes over doors
- Believed in good/evil, spirits, demons without Christian framework
Tuberculosis Connection
- Vampire panics were reaction to tuberculosis outbreaks
- TB arrived in New England ~1730s
- By late 18th/early 19th century: #1 killer of New Englanders
- Called "consumption" - body consuming itself
- Symptoms mimicked vampire characteristics:
- Voracious hunger while wasting away
- Coughing fits with blood
- Life force appearing to be drained
- Highly contagious, spread through coughing/sneezing
- Families living in 1-2 room houses easily infected multiple members
Vampire Diagnosis Process
- When multiple family members died/became sick, suspected vampire in family
- Had to determine which dead relative was the vampire
- Dug up multiple coffins to examine bodies
- Looked for "vampire" signs:
- Bloated appearance (actually gas buildup)
- Long fingernails (skin receding from nail beds)
- Red/bloody lips (TB lung tissue breakdown continued after death)
- Fresh blood near heart (normal decomposition)
- Bodies that died of TB in winter often appeared pristine due to cold preservation
- Self-fulfilling prophecy: TB victims naturally exhibited "vampire" characteristics
Vampire Dispatching Methods
- Called "apotropaic remedy" - counteracting evil
- Methods varied by region:
- Maine/Plymouth Massachusetts: flipped body face down
- Stake through heart (to pin them down, not kill)
- Connecticut/Rhode Island/Vermont: burned heart, mixed ashes into tonic for sick family members
- European origins: beheading, brick in mouth, binding with thorns
- JB-55 treatment: bones arranged in cross pattern (European tradition)
Mercy Brown Case (1892)
- Most famous vampire panic case
- Exeter, Rhode Island farming town
- Population declined 2/3 in 70 years before her death
- Brown family deaths over ~decade:
- Mother Mary Eliza died of TB
- Sister Mary Olive (age 20) died of TB
- Brother Edwin sick with TB
- Mercy Brown died of TB
- Neighbors pressured father George Brown to exhume family members
- George Brown didn't believe in vampires but relented to stop harassment
- Doctor present during examination pointed out evidence of tuberculosis
- Townspeople ignored medical evidence
- Burned Mercy's heart and liver, mixed ashes into tonic
- Edwin drank tonic, died within months (TB was incurable)
Connection to Dracula
- Providence newspaper reporter covered Mercy Brown case
- Article picked up by New York World in 1896
- Newspaper clipping found in Bram Stoker's papers
- Scholars debate whether it influenced Dracula (published shortly after)
- Real vampire legends originated from actual superstitions about tuberculosis
- Modern vampire mythology grew from these real historical beliefs and practices
Aaron Mankey Collaboration
- Aaron Mankey (Lore podcast creator) joining HowStuffWorks
- Had covered vampire panics in multiple Lore episodes
- Synchronicity of him discussing topic same week as episode planning
