AI summary by TwinMind
How the Nobel Peace Prize Works | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
50m 32s
Introduction and Cocktail Discussion
- Josh Clark and Chuck Bryan discuss their custom cocktails
- Chuck B drink: bee's knees variation with whiskey, honey, crème de menthe
- Josh's drink: gin, blonde dart (ginger lemon liqueur from Old Fourth Ward Distillery), pineapple gum syrup, ginger bitters, lemon juice, honey syrup, egg white
- Discussion of cocktail preparation techniques and frozen glassware
Alfred Nobel Background
- Alfred Nobel: inventor of dynamite, wealthy industrialist
- Father Emmanuel Nobel: created weaponry for Russians in late 19th century
- Family moved from Sweden to Russia, children raised with private tutors
- Alfred spoke 5 languages, well-versed in literature and chemistry
- Described himself as misanthrope, never married, had no children
- Brother Emil died in 1864 nitroglycerin explosion with 4 others
- Alfred moved lab to barge on Swedish lake to continue experiments
- Eventually invented dynamite as more stable explosive
- Died with close to $10 million (equivalent to $300+ million today)
- Held over 350 patents
Nobel's Transformation Story
- Legend: French newspaper mistakenly published Alfred's obituary when brother Ludwig died in 1888
- Called him "Merchant of Death" - wealth from "new ways to mutilate and kill"
- Historians unable to locate original article copy
- Alternative theory: influenced by Bertha von Suttner, peace activist assistant
- She wrote "Lay Down Your Arms," won Nobel Peace Prize in 1905
- Nobel changed from mutual assured destruction philosophy to peace promotion
Prize Establishment Process
- Alfred Nobel died December 10, 1896
- Legal wrangling delayed first prize until 1901
- Executor transported $350 million in cash via stagecoach through Paris with revolver
- Nobel left vague instructions: "go figure it out"
- Family contested will, nearly prevented prize creation
- Prize funded by investment returns, not principal amount
Prize Structure and Significance
- Started at about $1 million value, maintained that level since 1980s
- Unique large cash prize for the era
- Gained immediate international recognition
- Positive feedback loop: prestigious recipients enhanced prize reputation
- Customary (not required) for Peace Prize winners to donate money
- No appeals process, no revocation possible
- Usually first line in winner's obituary
Selection Process and Committee
- Norwegian Nobel Committee: 5 members appointed by Storting (Norway's legislature)
- 6-year terms, renewable, all Norwegian nationals so far
- Cannot be active government leaders (changed from earlier rule)
- Mainly retired politicians currently
- Extensive research staff and advisors
- 300+ nominations annually whittled to 20-30, then final selection
Timeline and Rules
- Nominations due end of January
- Initial research February-March
- Intensive research March-August
- Announcement October
- Ceremony December 10 in Oslo (anniversary of Nobel's death)
- Maximum 3 laureates per year
- Organizations can win
- Must be living recipients (one posthumous exception: Dag Hammarskjöld, 1961)
- No self-nominations allowed
Nomination Process
- Qualified nominators: elected officials at national level worldwide
- Members of parliament, presidents, cabinet secretaries automatically qualified
- Professors in certain fields for other Nobel prizes, but Peace Prize more restrictive
- 50-year secrecy rule on nominations and nominators
- Controversial nominations include Hitler, Stalin, Mussolini
- Being nominated carries no inherent honor due to broad nomination pool
Historical Eras and Approaches
- Pre-WWII: mostly pacifist committees and peace congresses
- Post-WWII/Cold War: shifted toward democracy promotion, humanitarian work
- Recipients include Desmond Tutu, Nelson Mandela, Malala, Jimmy Carter
- Sometimes awards to opposing sides of conflicts (Mandela & de Klerk 1993)
Notable Controversies
- Henry Kissinger 1973: shared with Le Duc Tho (who declined)
- Kissinger criticized as war criminal for Cambodia bombing, civilian deaths
- Barack Obama 2009: premature award in first year of presidency
- Later criticized for drone strikes, Libya intervention
- Aung San Suu Kyi: later oversaw war crimes against minorities
- Abiy Ahmed 2019: won for Ethiopia-Eritrea peace, later oversaw ethnic cleansing
Major Criticisms
- Gandhi never won despite 5-6 nominations
- Eurocentrism: almost exclusively Americans/Europeans until 1960
- Pro-democracy bias potentially overlooks other political systems
- Risk of awarding to active political leaders
- Committee has publicly admonished some winners post-award
Medal and Ceremony Details
- Until 1980: 23-karat gold
- Current: 18-karat green gold (gold-silver alloy) plated with 24-karat gold
- Designed by Gustav Vigeland
- Front: Alfred Nobel's image
- Back: Three men with Latin inscription "Pro pace et fraternitate gentium"
- Winner's name engraved
- Ceremony in Oslo (differs from other Nobel prizes in Stockholm)
Alternative Recognition
- Right Livelihood Award ("Alternative Nobel") created 1980
- Jakob von Uexküll created after Nobel Foundation rejected environmental/global perspective prizes
- Funded by selling $1 million stamp collection
- Less well-known than Nobel Peace Prize
