AI summary by TwinMind
How the Soviets Won Chess
Asianometry
19m 21s
Pre-Soviet Russian Chess History
- Russians excelled at chess before Soviet Union - 1616 Augustus the younger noted Russians played "most ingeniously"
- Alexander Petrov became Russia's first great chess master/theorist - legacy in Petrov's Defense opening
- 1914: All-Russian Chess Association established but WWI ended activities immediately
- WWI devastated Russian chess schools, followed by 1917 revolution and civil war
- Mass exodus of top players during wars - of 18 players in 1913-14 all-Russia tournament, only 6 remained after 1920
- Alexander Alekhine strongest remaining player, nearly executed by Soviet Secret Police in 1919 at age 26
- Saved by chess enthusiast who recognized him
- Ossip Bernstein also nearly executed in Odessa, saved by winning chess game against commanding officer
Early Soviet Leaders and Chess
- Marx: enthusiastic but not strong player, aggressive style, poor loser - only one questionable recorded game
- Lenin: passionate but not strong player, lost temper when losing, played rarely after 1910s politics
- Last recorded game August 1920 against Nikolai Krylenko during vacation
- Lenin did not promote chess within the state he founded
Foundation of Soviet Chess Program (1920-1925)
- Alexander Fedorovich Ilyin-Zhenevsky: actual founder of Soviet chess program
- Old Bolshevik administrator and chess master
- Appointed chief commissar of compulsory military training program (Vsevobuch)
- Believed chess developed "boldness, inventiveness, willpower and strategic ability"
- Proposed government-sponsored chess literature and games
- First All-Russian Chess Olympiad October 1920 in Moscow during ongoing Civil War
- Strange tournament held with hunger, poverty, inflation widespread
- Telegrams sent to regional offices to find chess players, promised food availability
- Invited 4 great players who couldn't attend (Rubinstein in Poland, Bernstein fled to Serbia, Bogolyubov/Selesniev imprisoned in Germany)
- 16 players eventually participated, jobs guaranteed upon return
- Alekhine won convincingly, Gregory Levenfish finished 3rd despite losing first two games
- Food struggles: herring head soup first course, herring tails second course
- Players threatened to leave, appeased with 15,000 rubles, bread, cheese, cigarettes
- Alekhine left for West after second secret police investigation in November 1920, never returned
Political Infiltration and Krylenko Era (1925-1938)
- Soviet government began infiltrating chess program for political purposes
- Two schools: Saint Petersburg (chess as art) vs Moscow (chess as educational tool for masses)
- Nikolai Krylenko took control from Ilyin-Zhenevsky
- Supreme commander Red Army, one of most powerful men in country
- Created chess section, proposed "Five-Year Plan of Chess"
- Slogans: "take chess to the workers," "chess must become feature of every workers club"
- 1925 Moscow International Chess Tournament
- Attended by world champion Capablanca, former champion Lasker
- Won by Soviet master Efim Bogolyubov
- Political bent drove wedge with international chess organizations
- Late 1920s: Soviets restricted masters from "bourgeois events" abroad
- April 1929: recruited workers into factory tournaments, sought 1.5 million chess club members
Rise of Botvinnik and International Recognition (1930s)
- Mikhail Botvinnik emerged as biggest star
- Defeated Capablanca at age 14 in 1925 simultaneous exhibition
- Capablanca "threw pieces off board" in anger
- Won Soviet championship 1931 at age 20
- 1933: Botvinnik vs Salo Flohr match
- Krylenko personally approved, housed in best Moscow hotel
- Positioned as chance for USSR to "catch up and overtake the West"
- Botvinnik tied 6-6 after being down two games
- 1934: over 500,000 registered serious amateur chess players in USSR
- Half of world's above-average chess players were Soviet
- Program restructuring: formalized tournaments, training systems, stringent ranking for Grand Master titles
- 1937: government issued monthly stipends to Chess Masters equal to soccer stars
- Critics noted hypocrisy of elevating classes while promoting chess for masses
Great Terror and WWII (1937-1945)
- Late 1930s Great Terror: several sports administrators purged, some players vanished into prison camps
- 1938: Krylenko denounced, received 20-minute trial, executed immediately
- Chess reputation within USSR remained strong under new bureaucrats
- 1941: German invasion paused chess activities
- Several strong players served in fighting
- Chess magazine staff mobilized mid-issue
- Ilyin-Zhenevsky died during Saint Petersburg evacuation
- Wartime chess: Moscow/Saint Petersburg held championships to prove life continued
- Air raid warnings gave opponents extra analysis time
- Hospital chess clubs promoted healing - hundreds of thousands injured soldiers participated
Post-War Dominance (1945-1948)
- September 2, 1945: USSR vs USA radio match on WWII end date
- Americans had been champions throughout 1930s
- Soviets crushed Americans 15.5 to 4.5
- Botvinnik and Vasily Smyslov annihilated Arnold Denker and Samuel Reshevsky
- Americans attributed loss to Soviets being "full-time chess professionals"
- World Championship complications after Alekhine's 1946 death at age 53
- Alekhine considered collaborator due to racial chess articles in occupied France
- FIDE stepped in to organize super tournament for new champion
- Soviet negotiations with FIDE
- 600,000 registered players had to join "international bourgeois organization"
- Initially pulled out due to press criticism about potential collusion
- Botvinnik boycotted 1947 Soviet championship in protest
- Last-second decision to join FIDE when they considered handing crown to Max Euwe
- 1948: Three Soviet players in five-person tournament in Netherlands and Moscow
- Botvinnik won convincingly, became world champion
- USSR would hold championship for many more years (with single exception)
Soviet System Analysis
- Soviet central planning showed incredible success in certain sports including chess
- Government focused on world-class competitions to demonstrate superiority of their way of life
- Easier to produce singular achievements like Mikhail Botvinnik than commercially successful computers
- Chess success easy to define (win/lose/draw) vs unclear winning conditions for achieving socialism
