AI summary by TwinMind
How the Supreme Court Has Shaped Vaccine Mandates, From Smallpox to Covid
The Wall Street Journal
6m 4s
Historical Legal Precedent - Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905)
- Lutheran pastor Henning Jacobson refused government-mandated smallpox vaccine
- Claimed previous vaccination caused serious suffering
- Argued healthy, law-abiding people don't pose community danger
- Supreme Court ruled against Jacobson
- Justice John Marshall Harlan wrote majority opinion
- "Liberty secured by constitution does not import absolute right to be wholly freed from restraint"
- Personal freedom can be limited when threatens community
- Established precedent: manifold restraints necessary for common good
Current COVID-19 Vaccine Mandate Landscape
- 20+ states, dozens of cities adopted vaccine mandates since vaccines became widely available
- Mandates largely upheld by judges (both Republican and Democrat appointees)
- Most cite Jacobson precedent
- Federal mandates cover:
- Federal workers
- Healthcare workers treating Medicare/Medicaid patients
- OSHA mandate: businesses 100+ employees must ensure workers vaccinated or tested weekly
Legal Challenges to Federal Mandates
- Dozens of states, business groups, religious groups sued to block mandates
- Arguments against federal authority:
- OSHA lacks authority to issue such mandates under federal law
- Centers for Medicare/Medicaid Services exceeds authority
- Supreme Court agreed to fast-track arguments (Case 21A244)
Supreme Court Arguments Analysis
- Liberal justices appeared supportive of government orders
- Questioned distinction between state vs federal police power
- "If within police power to protect health/welfare of workers... states can do it but federal government can't?"
- Conservative justices expressed skepticism
- Questioned federal government's expansive power
- "Why isn't Congress having say in this?"
- "Why doesn't this be primary responsibility of states?"
Court's Expected Decision Framework
- Decision expected in coming weeks
- Court doesn't need final ruling on lawfulness
- Only needs to decide if "likely lawful"
- Will effectively determine mandate fate regardless
- Conservative-leaning court historically:
- Not fan of expansive federal regulation
- Prefers deferring to states
- Previously blocked Biden eviction moratorium (August)
Constitutional Structure Implications
- Federal government has limited power in constitutional system
- States typically first line of defense for health protection within borders
- Key question: Can federal government overrule states opposed to vaccine mandates?
- Ruling unlikely to change public vaccine debate
- Jacobson lost case century ago, beliefs persist about individual liberties
